• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

3DS Max 9 boolean

Messages
7
Country
unitedkingdom
Hello all,

My first post here. I've made a couple of aircraft with FS Design Studio which is easy but frustrating to use so I want to move on to Max. I understand that boolean operations in version 9 are improved over 7/8 does anyone have any experience of using Max 9? I know I could use Gmax but the long training video I saw of Max 9 impressed me so although I don't have it yet, I'm certainly considering it.

Thanks in advance!
 
Max9 could well be the Holy Grail, but until there's an exporter built for it so you can output content for FSX, it's pretty much pointless to even consider using it...
 
Hi there,...

I am using 3ds max since V6 and I have to admit that the V9 (latest) is a very nice product. It is very nice to see how products develop in a few years, but now to your question:

You know, you could use Gmax, but you don't want to?! Thats dumb...
That's the first thing I would do in your position. It's you know, some sort of attitude I kinda see in a lot of beginners...

If it's free, it's got to be shitty. I want the whole thing. Gimme a 3,495 dollar expensive product, yeah! For what? Ehh ... just in case Gmax wouldn't be enough.

I tell you, it is enough. For FS design it is veeeery good. Look at me. I have been modelling in 3ds switched to FSDS a few years ago, then to Gmax and stayed with it.

I still have to use 3ds sometimes (for other work) and the company sends me the updates, but I don't even upgrade, especially to V9. I did it, tried it out, well it's nice, but then installed V7 again.

Just as n4gix said, stick with Gmax, or try to buy a V8 standalone somewhere if you want to throw some money out. Upgrade when ACES release a V9 exporter...


But in my opinion - Stick with Gmax. If you like it and see that you know ALL it's features and you find it not enough - then buy some payware 3d modelling tool.


Regards!!
 
Max9 could well be the Holy Grail, but until there's an exporter built for it so you can output content for FSX, it's pretty much pointless to even consider using it...

I don't understand this kind of logic. As if exporting a model is the most important thing in game content creation...

I'd worry about modeling and texturing first; you gotta have something to export. If you have access to 3ds max 9 it's a no-brainer: do your modeling, unwrapping and texturing in max, and the rest (read: animation and sim-specific stuff) in gmax. Use the BFF script http://www.scriptspot.com/3ds-max/bff-2007 to transfer meshes to gmax.

Having said that, there are of course a few things to keep in mind whilst modeling; no co-linear or -located vertices, that sort of thing. If you find that the FSX exporter doesn't like your meshes it might be a good idea to do some modeling in gmax for a while - because you need to test/export often. Once you know what you're doing there's no reason to not use 3ds max 9, you'd miss out on a whole range of fantastic tools and possibilities.

gh
 
I don't understand this kind of logic. As if exporting a model is the most important thing in game content creation...

Gerard, with the utmost respect I would assert that for a relative newcomer to begin with Max9 is the equivalent of suggesting that a non-pilot purchase a 757 for their flight training...

I tend to think that one should concentrate on mastering the fundamentals first, using the free GMax's relatively "primitive" tools (which are actually not all that "primitive" as you well know).

Afterwards, then one might wish to invest in a more feature-rich application such as Max7, 8 or 9.

As for the BFF scripts, I've had them available for several months and quite honestly haven't been all that impressed. They simply didn't work too well with several projects I wanted to migrate from Max8 to GMax. :stirthepo
 
Gerard, with the utmost respect
No worries, I have no interest either way.
I would assert that for a relative newcomer to begin with Max9 is the equivalent of suggesting that a non-pilot purchase a 757 for their flight training...
This analogy doesn't quite fit, for the simple reason that at the core, the two applications are identical; same paradigm, same methods. If I teach someone to model aircraft in gmax, he'll have no problems switching to 3ds max, none. I need about 2 hours extra for teaching 3ds max-only features; tools and strategies that make life a whole lot easier. By and all, learning to model aircraft in 3ds max is not harder than in gmax. Modeling aircraft in 3ds max is in fact easier, and less time consuming.

I assumed money is not a problem for GeoDen :)

gh
 
Well, thanks for the advice. Let me clarify a little, I don't think I'm dumb since I was a software engineer for 25 years before I retired early having made a tidy sum from a large industrial control software package I architected and sold. Also, I have three years gauge writing experience with FS9 but other commitments have prevented me working with FSX yet and I wish to start making some models so I can do what I like to do, which is start with nothing and end up with something I've done entirely by myself.

I fully understand that I can use Gmax and I probably shall, I was simply impressed with the power of 3ds Max 9, it seemed like it would be more powerful and productive than Gmax. I was unaware of the FSX exporting problem. The models I made in FS Design Studio worked well but it is a tedious program to use and doesn't produce models of the quality I would like given the time I'm willing to invest in it. Perhaps others can produce high quality with that tool but I don't see the point in putting myself through unnecessary tedium when I could use a more professional tool. I think I read somewhere the ACES team uses 3ds Max 8 and since they have commercial pressures I'd be surprised if they didn't move to Max 9 if it could shorten the development cycle. I would have thought you professional developers would do likewise but I understand the relatively high cost of Max would take a long time to recover from the sale of necessarily cheap FS add-ons. I take my hat off to you guys who produce some very nice labour-intensive work and sell it for such low prices.

So, it seems no-one has tried the Max 9 boolean operations because nobody uses that tool yet, is that the answer to my question? I guess so.
 
I forgot to add.

Gerard said: "I assumed money is not a problem for GeoDen"

Well, I have every intention of enjoying my retirement so if I have to invest in a tool that will enhance my pleasure I would do so. But I'd never say money is not a problem, it's a question of how much.:)
 
Last edited:
It has taken quite awhile to amortize the cost of Max8, so the odds of me upgrading anytime soon are slim to none... ;) So of course I am not at all familiar with the "new boolean operations" of Max9.

Given that I also model almost exclusively in GMax v1.2 reduces those odds still further. That said however, I will likely begin making more use of Max8 for any new projects I begin, once I've finished up with the six that're currently in progress.

I think the major point I was attempting to make with my admittedly weak analogy is that, like a 747 cockpit, Max7, 8 and 9 is cluttered with a lot of "features" that simply will not work at all in FS.

I'd guess that a good 80% of the features in GMax won't work at all, or else cause "interesting problems" in FS. Considering that the most common "complaint" I hear from "GMax newbies" or "FSDSers" is that the GUI of GMax is "too complicated," I suspect that seeing Max's GUI would cause them to stroke out... :eek:

Of course, one could spend the time to "clean up and streamline" the GUI to remove the unneeded "stuff" from the GUI, but then one would have to already know what was essential to begin with... :D
 
Ok Bill, I understand.

I guess people unaccustomed to GUI interfaces would find Gmax and Max a little intimidating initially, but it's surprising how quickly people can become adept if they have the right attitude. I think playing with the Max 9 video and then using Gmax will give me a broader picture of things perhaps to come so I haven't wasted my time.

So I'll probably take your advice and make a model or two with Gmax and see how it goes, others have certainly produced fine models with it. A friend of mine has the Citation X for FS9 produced by your company, it's certainly very nice, did you model it with Gmax or Max 8 may I ask?

Thanks,

Geo
 
I'm sorry GeoDen I forgot to answer the Boolean question. The original Boolean tool in max has been criticized since release 1. The reason why a company called nPower made a much better one (plug in) - which was later bought by Autodesk and made available to max 8 subscription members. Pro Booleans is a standard feature in max 9 and is indeed much better than the original tool. Don't expect perfect results all of the time though, that's impossible with polygonal meshes, in any 3D software.

Anyway, you sound like you're serious about it :) The best advice I can give you is to download the max 9 trial version (which is fully functional) and play with it for a month. If you decide to buy make sure you also purchase a 12 month subscription (450,- euro extra) which entitles you to 1 upgrade. So, after the initial costs always having the newest version of max is about 300,- pounds per year.

During the trial period you could start with doing the Autodesk video crash course and after that some of Eric Maslowski's excellent video tutorials: http://forums.ego-farms.com/index.php?topic=78.msg98

Is 3ds max worth the money? Very hard question to answer. Softimage XSI Foundation for instance is a fantastic application that has all one needs for professional game content creation, it costs a mere $499,- http://www.softimage.com/products/foundation/

In many ways XSI is the more sophisticated application but the problem is, 3ds max is the de facto standard in the games industry. More often than not you can't get around it. Luckily (but not entirely by coincidence) max does have the best low poly modeling tool set of the 4 or 5 major 3D apps...

gh
 
Last edited:
Hi Gerard,

Well, that's more good and interesting information. Do you know if that Softimage XSI package can export an FS compatible file? Thanks for the links, they have shortened my research time!:)
 
Unfortunately not, you'd still need gmax for adding animation and sim-specific stuff like hierarchies, object tags etc. and exporting. So, a basic knowledge of gmax is mandatory still.

gh
 
So I'll probably take your advice and make a model or two with Gmax and see how it goes, others have certainly produced fine models with it. A friend of mine has the Citation X for FS9 produced by your company, it's certainly very nice, did you model it with Gmax or Max 8 may I ask?

Funnily enough, the current Citation X model for FS9 was modeled entirely in FSDS2.x, which only supports my firm conviction that...

"...a tool is only as good as the hands of the artist who weilds it..."

Most of the finest and most expensive furniture made today is still crafted using 18th century woodworking tools in the hands of a Master Craftsman.

Bobby Hayes, the Master Craftsman who used FSDS2.x to build the Citation X, has completely rebuilt the forthcoming FSX version 2.0 using GMax v1.2 along with some supurb mentoring from our own Owen Hewitt.

Of course, Bobby had already "mastered the fundamentals" by using the relatively crude "tools" which are all that FSDS2.x offers. His talent is what allowed him to capture the graceful curves of the classic "gull wing" of the CitX, which is completely absent in all other modeler's attempts to model the CitX. Of course, Bobby's Masters degree in Art played no small part in his success. :cool:

There are only two major reasons why I will switch almost exclusively to Max8 for any new projects: the ability to hand-tweak the X files before compiling, and the rendering system which is ideal for baking textures, neither of which is possible from GMax.
 
Last edited:
There are only two major reasons why I will switch almost exclusively to Max8 for any new projects: the ability to hand-tweak the X files before compiling, and the rendering system which is ideal for baking textures, neither of which is possible from GMax.

One out of two for FSDS isn't too bad... :) (hand tweaking x files for the masochist!)
 
Back
Top