• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

FSXA Bump and Spec Map Enabled Model Question

Usually when the top of your plane is shaded, your bump maps are missing or messed up somehow.

I like to recycle my Materials on new planes. I'll import/merge over parts with certain materials I want to use, like left wing, which has all the various materials and settings I want. Then I need to go in and rename/reselect various material textures, like going from P51_Left_Wing to P47_Left_Wing. Sometimes I miss the bumps and this happens. Bumps are really important for reflections.
 
Robert...are you saying that p3d, or fsx displays specular color reflections? That's surprising...where do you see the reflected color? I don't think the sim ray traces, so I'm guessing you don't see the reflected color on itself.

Both sims do. There are some cool effects you can achieve using the specular map. Stuff like metal flake paint. This is not metal flake, but it does show specular effect in FSX...

mustang_screen31.jpg~original


Looking good, Robert.
 
Robert...are you saying that p3d, or fsx displays specular color reflections? That's surprising...where do you see the reflected color? I don't think the sim ray traces, so I'm guessing you don't see the reflected color on itself.

Both sims do. There are some cool effects you can achieve using the specular map. Stuff like metal flake paint. This is not metal flake, but it does show specular effect in FSX...

mustang_screen31.jpg~original

Robert, thanks for posting this image. I will admit to being unsure when I see such an image of this being a picture of specular reflection value (luminance) or color. You must be saying that the pinkier color heading into the white of the glare, is due to your specular color map. If its not too much trouble, would you please share what that map looks like?

Always learning!
 
Looking good, Robert.
Bill, you mention bumps are critical for reflection. This is an interesting thought. This is intuitive, if bump maps are producing general roughness of a surface, the very definition of a diffuse reflectance surface, but I also think of bump maps as producing the appearance of features that are not polygonally present. Perhaps I drawing too fine a bead on the statement, as features certainly would break up a specular reflection.

In Milton's image, I keep seeing the smoothing removed...He's mentioned that the solution was some correction to the bump map. Do bump maps have the ability to mess with smoothing groups?
 
When I first created a bump/spec enabled model, it looked exactly like all smoothing had been turned off. I assume that was because the bump map was a generic colored, improperly made bump texture.

Regarding specular highlights and colors, the SDK says this:

Specular textures are more difficult to comprehend than their diffuse counterparts. Basically the specular map defines two properties, how bright and how spread-out the highlights on a surface will be. For aircraft textures these two components are defined separately. The diffuse values and hues (everything which is not alpha) in the specular texture define the brightness and color of the highlight. The alpha values define how spread-out the highlight will be (often referred to as falloff). In general, a highlight will only be as bright as is defined in the specular texture. For example; a light blue color in the specular texture will result in a highlight which is blue in hue and should not ever be brighter than the color in the texture. A lighter color in the specular texture will result in a lighter (brighter and stronger) highlight. More saturation in the specular texture will result in a more colorized highlight. A dark value in the specular alpha will generally result in a wider, less sharp highlight. Bright values will sharpen and consequently reduce the size of the highlight.

There is some flexibility associated with specular map values and their effect on the highlight, because the Specular Power Term in the Flight Simulator X Material Dialog also affects highlights on a model. The Material Dialog values are set when creating an aircraft using an appropriate 3D modeling tool (3ds max or gmax) , and will apply to your repainted livery.
 
Bill, you mention bumps are critical for reflection. This is an interesting thought. This is intuitive, if bump maps are producing general roughness of a surface, the very definition of a diffuse reflectance surface, but I also think of bump maps as producing the appearance of features that are not polygonally present. Perhaps I drawing too fine a bead on the statement, as features certainly would break up a specular reflection.

In Milton's image, I keep seeing the smoothing removed...He's mentioned that the solution was some correction to the bump map. Do bump maps have the ability to mess with smoothing groups?


Model mesh smoothing 'cannot be altered' by Materials. ;)
 
Model mesh smoothing 'cannot be altered' by Materials. ;)

Interesting thought ... what is smoothing really? The polys are still flat on that cylinder; smoothing does not round them. :-) It's all in lighting or shading, right? So, what does a bump do differently? Bump highlights are for highs and darker areas are for lows. So, is that different from how smoothing uses light to make the polys appear round and smooth? Both smoothing and bumps use varying light to alter reality, just for different reasons, and in different ways. Just thinking out loud here folks ...
 
This might be two different subjects;
* Polygon Smoothing
* Surface smoothness via bump mapping, ie; pebbly finishes

With textures being able to effect polygon smoothing, that is not possible. Usually to get polygons to un-smooth, so they show their individual flat surfaces (triangles), your compiler will unweld the Vertices during export.

With putting on dull finishes and rough finishes, leather or pebbly, gashed up, dented in finishes, thats all done with bump mapping.

Milton, you can achieve the most brilliant bump mapping for your planes (WWII era) with that dimpled paneling that occurs when you fly in rough weather, the ribs start to show, the skin is beat up. You lay down a sheet (in a layer in PSD file) of something like pool water or something with some 'noise' going on. Then you use 'Eraser' tool with a fuzzy airbrush cut and carve out the ribbing area's. The area's left are the dips in the metal inside the ribbed area's, so the area's seem dented in. The areas will need to be darker then the surroundings so they show up in the sim as indentions. Brighter zones will appear raised. The P-51's were done like this in FSX Accelleration. They have that denting thing going on. Its a very nice touch to a vintage metal plane.

I went on a google and found this example. This would be exported as a bump or Normal map.

109_Foundersalpha.jpg


Note this above texture I found on the internet, I am only trying to show you the indention zones on the skins, the ribbings are bright zones, the indentions are dark zones. This looks like a Specular map, by the way, which would be a light gray. When converting to Bump/Normal map, its then a bluish color.
 
Last edited:
These are from my ancient Pasped Skylark package. T his shows the 'swimming pool water' blotchy cloud area's that I used. They have bright zones so that was wrong of me. They should be darker then the top gray zone. Top one is wing, bottom is fuselage. The fuselage tail area was fabric covered, the front area was metal (Aluminium).

hgdfs.JPG


retgfd.JPG


Note that these are then converted to Normal (I do this in Photoshop with the freeware addon by nVidia), and the result is a blue color. Then you modify it for FSX.

Here are the full 'color' Diffuse textures for those.

Skylark_Fuselage_t.jpg


Skylark_Wings_RH_t.jpg


You can clearly see the fabric zones and metal zones (rivets area). Then with bump mapping and the sun glazing off the surfaces at certain angles, you see the cool metal indentions.

On the pool water, it was colored and I made it black and white and made it a full layer spanning the entire texture (tiled it) and then cut out the ribbings.

Here, you can barely see the indensions and metal damage on the front side panel behind the cowling. I didnt want it to look totally beatup, so the indentions layer wasnt super dark. Lighter is not as harsh, super dark is 'very indented'.

lionheart_skylark_17-1000x638.jpg
 
Last edited:
Interesting thought ... what is smoothing really? The polys are still flat on that cylinder; smoothing does not round them. :) It's all in lighting or shading, right? So, what does a bump do differently? Bump highlights are for highs and darker areas are for lows. So, is that different from how smoothing uses light to make the polys appear round and smooth? Both smoothing and bumps use varying light to alter reality, just for different reasons, and in different ways. Just thinking out loud here folks ...

I understand your question, Milton....was kind of thinking this same thing. In fact, polygon smoothing is a process of altering the normals understood by the renderer. In a NOT smoothed model, the normals at the vertices are perpendicular to the plane of the polygon they belong to. When two polygons are "smoothed", the normals of the shared vertices are averaged.

Based on this understanding, I was suprised by Bill's statement, but he may be right. Like you say, bump maps do their magic by changing the normals, so the process seems identical, and I'm unsure how Bill determined differently.

I haven't done development for the sim renderer for a while, so I yield to more current expertise.
 
Some settings to model parts (polygons) are done in the 3D design state. When exported, those are locked in. Textures/Materials change quite a bit, but in the field of smoothing polygons, you have what you exported.
 
Some settings to model parts (polygons) are done in the 3D design state. When exported, those are locked in. Textures/Materials change quite a bit, but in the field of smoothing polygons, you have what you exported.
Bill, not arguing, but questioning. Can you explain the image Milton showed us where the fuselage clearly appeared "unsmoothed", even though a bump map (somehow improperly made) was added? Sure looks like it overwrote the normals status.
 
Bill, not arguing, but questioning. Can you explain the image Milton showed us where the fuselage clearly appeared "unsmoothed", even though a bump map (somehow improperly made) was added? Sure looks like it overwrote the normals status.

I believe that, in the shown images, the fuselage does not look 'unsmoothed' because it looks, well, smooth :duck:. When unsmoothed, it would have looked like a faceted diamond. The anomaly shown in the images, is only caused by the improper bump maps. A bump map does not really do something with the mesh normals, but with the spec map. In fact, you need spec in order to have working bumps, because a bump map decides in what direction gloss (spec) is reflected.

The images show a strong change in this 'reflection direction' (or 'normal') along the shoulder line of the fuselage. Light that falls above that line is reflected correctly, but light that falls below that line is reflected downward (at least this is how I interpret this anomaly). IIRC I had this same problem when I applied a black&white bumpmap to the sim, instead of a converted, blue-ish map.

Cheers, Daan
 
Bill, not arguing, but questioning. Can you explain the image Milton showed us where the fuselage clearly appeared "unsmoothed", even though a bump map (somehow improperly made) was added? Sure looks like it overwrote the normals status.


I am afraid I do not see a photo of the plane unsmoothed. Can you repost it here?
 
The first time I exported the Marauder and has bad bump/spec maps, the fuselage and engine nacelles did look un-smoothed. I had to go back to the model and double check to see what happened. Turned out to be just those bump/spec textures after all. I deleted that screen shot but could probably duplicate the affect. I'll try.

EDIT: Hmmm, tried to get that original unsmoothed appearance I had initially but the best I can accomplish now is a pumpkin affect. Oh, well.

I am currently converting an old Aero Commander "Hangar Queen" that suffers from heavy oxidation. Note that bumps are enabled but neutralized. Note in this screen shot how that oxidation on the fuselage is ready and willing to accept some serious bump textures. :)
 

Attachments

  • ms-2017-apr-13-001.jpg
    ms-2017-apr-13-001.jpg
    159.7 KB · Views: 423
Last edited:
I am currently converting an old Aero Commander "Hangar Queen" that suffers from heavy oxidation. Note that bumps are enabled but neutralized. Note in this screen shot how that oxidation on the fuselage is ready and willing to accept some serious bump textures. :)

Looking good, Milton!

A couple of times in the past, I created Ambient Occlusion renders for shading and somehow they were done in a way that appeared un-smoothed. The part must have been unsmoothed in Max, was later smoothed, but when checked in the sim, the render was of a point where it was rough, so it appeared (via shading) to be unsmoothed. Take that layer out, and the plane was fine.
 
Back
Top