Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.
By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.


Robert...are you saying that p3d, or fsx displays specular color reflections? That's surprising...where do you see the reflected color? I don't think the sim ray traces, so I'm guessing you don't see the reflected color on itself.
Both sims do. There are some cool effects you can achieve using the specular map. Stuff like metal flake paint. This is not metal flake, but it does show specular effect in FSX...
![]()
Robert...are you saying that p3d, or fsx displays specular color reflections? That's surprising...where do you see the reflected color? I don't think the sim ray traces, so I'm guessing you don't see the reflected color on itself.
Both sims do. There are some cool effects you can achieve using the specular map. Stuff like metal flake paint. This is not metal flake, but it does show specular effect in FSX...
![]()
Bill, you mention bumps are critical for reflection. This is an interesting thought. This is intuitive, if bump maps are producing general roughness of a surface, the very definition of a diffuse reflectance surface, but I also think of bump maps as producing the appearance of features that are not polygonally present. Perhaps I drawing too fine a bead on the statement, as features certainly would break up a specular reflection.Looking good, Robert.


Bill, you mention bumps are critical for reflection. This is an interesting thought. This is intuitive, if bump maps are producing general roughness of a surface, the very definition of a diffuse reflectance surface, but I also think of bump maps as producing the appearance of features that are not polygonally present. Perhaps I drawing too fine a bead on the statement, as features certainly would break up a specular reflection.
In Milton's image, I keep seeing the smoothing removed...He's mentioned that the solution was some correction to the bump map. Do bump maps have the ability to mess with smoothing groups?

Model mesh smoothing 'cannot be altered' by Materials.![]()


Interesting thought ... what is smoothing really? The polys are still flat on that cylinder; smoothing does not round them.It's all in lighting or shading, right? So, what does a bump do differently? Bump highlights are for highs and darker areas are for lows. So, is that different from how smoothing uses light to make the polys appear round and smooth? Both smoothing and bumps use varying light to alter reality, just for different reasons, and in different ways. Just thinking out loud here folks ...
Bill, not arguing, but questioning. Can you explain the image Milton showed us where the fuselage clearly appeared "unsmoothed", even though a bump map (somehow improperly made) was added? Sure looks like it overwrote the normals status.Some settings to model parts (polygons) are done in the 3D design state. When exported, those are locked in. Textures/Materials change quite a bit, but in the field of smoothing polygons, you have what you exported.

Bill, not arguing, but questioning. Can you explain the image Milton showed us where the fuselage clearly appeared "unsmoothed", even though a bump map (somehow improperly made) was added? Sure looks like it overwrote the normals status.
. When unsmoothed, it would have looked like a faceted diamond. The anomaly shown in the images, is only caused by the improper bump maps. A bump map does not really do something with the mesh normals, but with the spec map. In fact, you need spec in order to have working bumps, because a bump map decides in what direction gloss (spec) is reflected.
Bill, not arguing, but questioning. Can you explain the image Milton showed us where the fuselage clearly appeared "unsmoothed", even though a bump map (somehow improperly made) was added? Sure looks like it overwrote the normals status.


I am currently converting an old Aero Commander "Hangar Queen" that suffers from heavy oxidation. Note that bumps are enabled but neutralized. Note in this screen shot how that oxidation on the fuselage is ready and willing to accept some serious bump textures.![]()