- Messages
- 310
- Country

Hi Folks,
I'm wondering if anyone has experimented with various mip map filters when generating mip maps.
I've found that if I am very careful in creating the Sketchup textures I use, once the model is compiled in MCX, I can generate the key mip mapped dds files directly from Photoshop that I can substitute, something very handy when creating liveries. But it also allows a lot of control of the process of making the mipmaps. What the controls do is another question!
My understanding is that the end application can create mip maps on the fly using various algorithms (called filters) if so programmed. Mip mapping the textures in effect pre-makes these smaller textures, and one has the choice of the various filters.
The NVDIA dds plugin for PS lists the following filter types: point, box, triangle, quadratic, cubic, catron, etc, etc, up to Kaiser. Triangular is the default. So far I have not found much documentation about the characteristics of each. The first few are fairly straightforward. Point reduces 4 pixels to one using the nearest neighbor, box takes an average of the 4 pixels, and triangular is an interpolation which helps avoid some of the problems with a box filter. The algorithms then get much more complicated but since the mipmaps are only generated once, computational efficiency should not matter (I would assume).
Here are a couple of older references I found helpful:
http://number-none.com/product/Mipmapping,%20Part%201/index.html
http://number-none.com/product/Mipmapping,%20Part%202/index.html
For what it's worth, I compared mip map 2 (1/4 the size of the original) of a texture generated by MCX with the same mip map created with the dds plugin using Kaiser filtering. Here's the result below:
As per the references, the Kaiser filtering does produce a slightly sharper image if I look very closely, so it might be worth trying for the fun of it. Has anyone looked into this in more detail? There area heck of a lot of filter options to choose from! I'll bet that the differences are not really noticeable in the sim, but I won't know until I try under various circumstances.
Larry
I'm wondering if anyone has experimented with various mip map filters when generating mip maps.
I've found that if I am very careful in creating the Sketchup textures I use, once the model is compiled in MCX, I can generate the key mip mapped dds files directly from Photoshop that I can substitute, something very handy when creating liveries. But it also allows a lot of control of the process of making the mipmaps. What the controls do is another question!
My understanding is that the end application can create mip maps on the fly using various algorithms (called filters) if so programmed. Mip mapping the textures in effect pre-makes these smaller textures, and one has the choice of the various filters.
The NVDIA dds plugin for PS lists the following filter types: point, box, triangle, quadratic, cubic, catron, etc, etc, up to Kaiser. Triangular is the default. So far I have not found much documentation about the characteristics of each. The first few are fairly straightforward. Point reduces 4 pixels to one using the nearest neighbor, box takes an average of the 4 pixels, and triangular is an interpolation which helps avoid some of the problems with a box filter. The algorithms then get much more complicated but since the mipmaps are only generated once, computational efficiency should not matter (I would assume).
Here are a couple of older references I found helpful:
http://number-none.com/product/Mipmapping,%20Part%201/index.html
http://number-none.com/product/Mipmapping,%20Part%202/index.html
For what it's worth, I compared mip map 2 (1/4 the size of the original) of a texture generated by MCX with the same mip map created with the dds plugin using Kaiser filtering. Here's the result below:
As per the references, the Kaiser filtering does produce a slightly sharper image if I look very closely, so it might be worth trying for the fun of it. Has anyone looked into this in more detail? There area heck of a lot of filter options to choose from! I'll bet that the differences are not really noticeable in the sim, but I won't know until I try under various circumstances.
Larry