• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

P3D v4 V4 Transition

Messages
1,260
Country
us-texas
This is just a generic developer question. So it seems from customer feedback that my sceneries that were developed for FSX/P3D V3 are working flawlessly on P3D V4.

Is there really a significant change in terms of bglcomp or resample (two of which I exploit a lot!), or did I pull out a Homer? Otherwise it seems like backward compatibility is not such a big issue after all?


https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/pull_a_Homer


cheers!
David
 
Insofar as reported here by Arno and others, there is no known deprecation of any functionality between V4 and V3. The differences are additional parameters added to the V4 .mdl format which you can see as part of the available selections in the latest versions of MCX. Previous model builds are still supported and denied the latest features, like seasonal textures.
 
You'd have to appreciate LM for their "hindsight."
:)
 
One thing that is very interesting about V4, or any subsequent V's. I'd be careful stating things as "I'm fully devoted to P3D". Some developers may be jumping the gun too soon.

Reality check is LM has it's own IP flight simulation software that they don't share externally.........until they do (sarcastically LOL). That day will come, and they won't have any grief over "academic" users. P3D is nothing more to them than a commercial experiment. Let's enjoy while we can, right?
 
Reality check is LM has it's own IP flight simulation software that they don't share externally.........until they do (sarcastically LOL). That day will come, and they won't have any grief over "academic" users. P3D is nothing more to them than a commercial experiment. Let's enjoy while we can, right?

They would be really dumb to forfeit the market demand and ensuing additional revenue. Without the tens of thousands of "academic" users, I'm pretty sure that P3D would have ended up like ESP, i.e. deader than dead.
 
They would be really dumb to forfeit the market demand and ensuing additional revenue. Without the tens of thousands of "academic" users, I'm pretty sure that P3D would have ended up like ESP, i.e. deader than dead.

Nahh, don't take it personal, but they could care less about academic users. $49/license for thousands of users compared to the THAAD contract, the recent sales of PAC-3, the $9B multi-year F-35 purchase.

10,000 licenses x $49 = 490,000 That's 3/4 of an F-35 APU, or 1/8 of one PAC-3. That pays for 2.5 Engineers for one year. They make most of the revenue from commercial licenses and military sim development, which they could transition to their native software if they wanted to....and they eventually will. At that point I doubt they would share an SDK with us, but it would be great if they did.
 
Actually, it's called Prepar3D Professional Plus, and it is what I am running right now. This is the version being targeted to their military/commercial customers.
 
They have an even higher, customized level, which is what they pitch on their $MM in-breed sims.

To my surprise, the F-35 simulator at the "Customer Center" here in Fort Worth features non other than P3D Professional, and I would not doubt that they use Dino Cattaneo's F-35 flight model. That Dino really nailed that one, down to the G-limiter of pre Block 3.0.
 
That's not the one I was referring to, I'm aware of Professional Plus, a friend is using it for Flight Safety sim work.
 
Well, finished testing all my sceneries on V4. Glad to say, nothing to report!
19756471_1264255473696778_3770674234919084886_n.jpg
19756759_1264255433696782_7625690649504907043_n.jpg
19260606_1264255427030116_5919335952313908245_n.jpg
19554621_1264255430363449_99816586215784960_n.jpg
19875104_1264255423696783_4669840879859327724_n.jpg
 
Nahh, don't take it personal, but they could care less about academic users. $49/license for thousands of users compared to the THAAD contract, the recent sales of PAC-3, the $9B multi-year F-35 purchase.

10,000 licenses x $49 = 490,000 That's 3/4 of an F-35 APU, or 1/8 of one PAC-3. That pays for 2.5 Engineers for one year. They make most of the revenue from commercial licenses and military sim development, which they could transition to their native software if they wanted to....and they eventually will. At that point I doubt they would share an SDK with us, but it would be great if they did.

That's still half a million Dollars and a year worth of manhours for two and a half software engineer brains.
 
They have an even higher, customized level, which is what they pitch on their $MM in-breed sims.

You would be surprised that most visualisation software used for those multi million simulators is not at the level of FSX/P3D for all aspects. Of course performance and things like that are better. But often they can't cope with the amount of vegetation and buildings that the FS autogen system can handle.
 
I deal with Diamond Visionics all the time....way inferior and far more expensive. They charge tens of thousands of dollars to make "environment" changes that would take an FSSX/P3D developer a few hours to make.

What makes the customized levels of P3D more expensive is the fidelity of the weapons simulation....which involves big brother DOD. But I agree, visuals are not always better. Some still use monochromatic type imaging.
 
I deal with Diamond Visionics all the time....way inferior and far more expensive. They charge tens of thousands of dollars to make "environment" changes that would take an FSSX/P3D developer a few hours to make.

What makes the customized levels of P3D more expensive is the fidelity of the weapons simulation....which involves big brother DOD. But I agree, visuals are not always better. Some still use monochromatic type imaging.

I know what you are saying, I have worked with different professional image generators. Typically the tools involved to make the environment are quite complex and hard to use. So changes indeed take a lot of time. From that point of view the design is FS is quite good I believe.

The flight models and such are a different area indeed, that's where those simulators are much better than FS of course. But that has more to do with the different aim of using the simulation. I see FS more as good for visualisation and you can always hook it up to a good flight model externally. In a professional simulation all those components are also separate.
 
I know what you are saying, I have worked with different professional image generators. Typically the tools involved to make the environment are quite complex and hard to use. So changes indeed take a lot of time. From that point of view the design is FS is quite good I believe.

The flight models and such are a different area indeed, that's where those simulators are much better than FS of course. But that has more to do with the different aim of using the simulation. I see FS more as good for visualisation and you can always hook it up to a good flight model externally. In a professional simulation all those components are also separate.

God bless Sim Connect! LOL :):)
 
You would be surprised that most visualisation software used for those multi million simulators is not at the level of FSX/P3D for all aspects. Of course performance and things like that are better. But often they can't cope with the amount of vegetation and buildings that the FS autogen system can handle.

I flew the 767-200ER at CYVR about 15 years ago. I had been running FS9 for a couple of months. My FS9 blew the doors off that multi-million dollar flight simulator.
As a matter of fact FS2000 looked better! :-) This was a CAT-3 full sim with pilots from all over the world coming to VYR for training.

Ken
 
Back
Top