• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

Welding halves together

Melo965

Resource contributor
Messages
118
Country
us-washington
Hi Everyone,

So this is a basic question I know. . . .

I made a canopy, then pushed and pulled some vertices to reshape it on the left side.

So now it is just the way I want it but only on the left half. So then I made a clone and moved the copy over to work on it, and then deleted all the right side canopy polys.

Then I made a clone again, and used the mirror modifier (not the button!), and then pushed both halves back together so they line up perfectly.

I am stuck on how to weld the two halves back together again. I can select canopy02(L) or canopy03(R) or both at once, but how do I select matching edge vertices on canopy02 and canopy03 at the same time so I can weld them back together. I know I don't want to group them, welding is the better method to avoid issues down the line.

No textures or animation yet, so that is not a complicating factor.

Thanks a lot for the help!
 
You need to attach one side to the other to make the canopy one part. Then select the vertices along the joint and weld them.
 
When you weld them up, use the distance scaler to adjust so you do not weld them 'length wise' along the edge. Usually a distance of like .001 will do the trick.

If you are using a later version of Max, you can add 'Symmetry' to your part. Before you add it, make sure your Gizmo is exactly on the center line. Then add Symmetry, flip to the axis you need, and your other side appears. You can hide it, etc. It has a auto-weld too, that isnt permanent, and you set the distance of welding so it doesnt mess up the mesh. Usually again .001 will do. This way, if you collapse the stack, the part is then one part, all welded and the seam disappears.
 
Robert,

Thanks!, worked just fine. I ended up reshaping it twice, then welding it back together.

Lionheart,

I am still just using Gmax. 3DS Max is out of my price range. It costs way more than the Spitfire flight I took in the profile picture. :-)

Building my first Gmax aircraft, and it is not going to be payware. I welded 2 vertices at a time at the join just to be on the safe side. Also used a very small weld distance as you suggested.

Thanks!
 
I am still just using Gmax. 3DS Max is out of my price range. It costs way more than the Spitfire flight I took in the profile picture.

First off, that extremely cool! :cool:
Secondly, can I be the guy who suggests Blender as an alternative? I've heard many times that GMAX is concidered to be 'outdated' and Blender is free and quite comprehensive.
 
can I be the guy who suggests Blender as an alternative? I've heard many times that GMAX is concidered to be 'outdated' and Blender is free and quite comprehensive.

...and can I be the guy who suggests that having started, Melo continues with Gmax and Milton's excellent tutorial videos. :teacher: The two programs are very very different for the beginning modeller: had he started with Blender I would strongly urge sticking with it too, so no party line here. Strictly speaking, both programs are "outdated" next to cutting-edge modelling tools.
 
First off, that extremely cool! :cool:
Secondly, can I be the guy who suggests Blender as an alternative? I've heard many times that GMAX is concidered to be 'outdated' and Blender is free and quite comprehensive.

Like Tom said below, I better stick with Gmax for now since it is finally making enough sense. Although it is taking me a lot longer than Milton to get a similar amount of work accomplished on my aircraft.
 
...and can I be the guy who suggests that having started, Melo continues with Gmax and Milton's excellent tutorial videos. :teacher: The two programs are very very different for the beginning modeller: had he started with Blender I would strongly urge sticking with it too, so no party line here. Strictly speaking, both programs are "outdated" next to cutting-edge modelling tools.

Tom, I agree - sticking with Gmax for now. Anyone else who is getting started, go watch all 47 of Milton's videos as I have. I am going through them again in parallel with the parts I am currently modeling, making a huge difference.
 
Secondly, can I be the guy who suggests Blender as an alternative? I've heard many times that GMAX is considered to be 'outdated' and Blender is free and quite comprehensive.
In addition to the remark already made by F747fly...

TIP: When you can not get this job done the you wanted it too.. inside your current modelling package, you now have the choice to download
and install Blender (for free), model the specific part in Blender and then export/import it in your current modelling package.


Blender has en excellent object modifier (called "the mirror modifier") which enables you to only model 1 side of a 3D Mesh-object and Blender will do the rest for you, guaranteeing perfect 3D symmetry in your modelled object. Follow the links below to get started:
- https://www.blender.org/download/ - Blender download location
- https://docs.blender.org/manual/en/dev/modeling/modifiers/generate/mirror.html - Blender mirror modifier manual section
>>
- https://www.youtube.com/results?search_query=blender+mirror+modifier&page=&utm_source=opensearch - Blender mirror modifier tutorials on YouTube
- http://www.dummies.com/web-design-development/doing-half-the-work-with-the-blender-mirror-modifier/ - Blender mirror modifier explanation

When you learn to master this awesome 3D Mesh-Object-modifier, you can get your (symmetrical based) 3D modelling in half the time!
since Blender automatically will create a perfect symmetrical copy of the "other halve"
 
The mirror modifier in GMax does't function like the symmetry one in Max, which is what I believe the text implies that the one in Blender does (i.e. building both halves of a symmetrical object at once). However... GMax has a way of accomplishing more or less the same thing. It's the only acceptable application of the mirror button - creating a mirrored instance of the part. Hit the mirror button, select the desired mirror axis, and check "instance" under "clone selection." The original part now functions as a "control object" for the other part. Since the other part is mirrored (to be more precise, has a scale of -1 applied), all changes of the control object will be reflected in an opposite sort of fashion.

When the parts are done to the model builder's satisfaction, the mirrored instance can be attached to the "control object," and then the relevant vertices can be welded. This is how I now build gear bays. Beware that any test exports before attaching the mirrored instance into the control object will show an "inside-out" part. This is normal (or, rather, the non-normal normals are normal!).
 
Strictly speaking, both programs are "outdated" next to cutting-edge modelling tools.
The "piece behind the steering wheel" is what really matters. Sure, a high end software is very helpful but I've seen superb modeling by many of our friends using Gmax; those lads know how to make it dance!
;)
 
FSDS too, although few still use it, can produce excellent results: Anthony's work is outstanding. The trick is to learn your modelling tool inside - out and stick with it, not chop and change with the weather or the fashion of the moment.

Blender, FSDS, Gmax and 3ds Max are the only tools which can directly produce new FS models: anything newer or funkier is unsupported.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top