• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

ATC Common sense???

Messages
875
Country
us-ohio
IF you are an ATC at Reagan airport in Washington.. shouldn't you stay awake during your shift??? Actually, common sense says that it is probably a good idea at ANY and ALL airports.

I am thinking... someone is going to lose their job... Thank GOD for that on the ball regional ATC from another airport, that took the flights and landed them safely at an airport that is NOT an easy one to fly into.

Any thoughts??


- Greg
 
IF you are an ATC at Reagan airport in Washington.. shouldn't you stay awake during your shift??? Actually, common sense says that it is probably a good idea at ANY and ALL airports.

I am thinking... someone is going to lose their job... Thank GOD for that on the ball regional ATC from another airport, that took the flights and landed them safely at an airport that is NOT an easy one to fly into.

Any thoughts??


- Greg

You have to be very careful, analysing any Aviation situation, on news reports.

When the tower did not respond, the pilot went back to the APPROACH Controller -- normal practice.

What is strange is that the Approach controller could not contact Regan Tower by Phone. If the controller was really asleep, the phone should have woken him ??

Now, if he was taking a "major" Potty break, then that might have explained his absence ... but then, that situation should be allowed for.
At the evry least, if the tower was going to be temporarily unmanned, I would ahve thought that Tower would have informed approach !!!

The plane landed as if Regan was an uncontrolled airport... at that time of night, when traffic was low, not the GREAT DEAL, that the news would have you believe.

However, since it is REGAN, its BIG NEWS and because it is the "Washington Government's local airport", it will get a lot of looking into.

More of our Tax money at work !!
 
As it turns out...he was sleeping on the job. They are saying it may be HIS bosses fault as they scheduled him several nights in a row. WAHHHHH!!!!!

There are times now that I work 18-20 hour days...and I may do that 5 days in a row. Back when I was in the US Coast Guard, there were times when we were on rescue missions that we would be up 3-4 days straight. Especially if there was really bad weather... We didn't get to use that as an excuse. And having studied for the ATC test and getting to intern at Boston Center in New Hampshire when I was in flight school, I know what they go through.. Sorry, but it is nothing compared to staring at the ocean for 3-4 days straight in 15-30 foot seas looking for a small boat..knowing that if you miss seeing it, people will die... Give me several nights of ATC work in a row any day!!!!

- Greg

PS: Oh..and I wasn't making it seem as the airport is so busy at that time of night that it was a big deal... have you ever looked at the approach for it??? It's a bitch!!! Fly it in FS sometime....the correct way, as per the charts... Good luck!!!
 
Last edited:
...have you ever looked at the approach for it??? It's a bitch!!! Fly it in FS sometime....the correct way, as per the charts... Good luck!!!

I work Potomac approach on VATSIM, and it is amazing to me that probably 10% of the pilots have a clue as to what it takes to fly in or out or Reagan. It is much different than its neighbors Dulles and Baltimore. Its actually quite aggravating cause a lot of decent VATSIM pilots manage to still muck it up.

And if you think you are the master of that, try flying DC Heliroutes properly.

Bonus, if you are genuinely curious how to be a better pilot:

Departing South or landing North is easy. Landing South or departing North is where you need to pay attention.

Learn the LDA/DME approach for runway 19. It is an ILS into runway 15 where at the last moment you swing over (but not across) the river and land on 19. Also be aware that in visual conditions, they may have you spot the field while it is ahead of you, take you though the downwind and say "Turn L/R heading XXX, cleared visual approach runway 15 (If APP initially instructed you that you will be landing 19, you still will, you approach 15 and are cleared to land on 19). When you get that instruction, turn base immediately and thence complete a visual approach.

When departing North, you will always be instructed to fly heading 320 immediately after takeoff. If you are in a big jet you cannot wait until after you pass the end of the runway to start this turn. You need to start this turn as soon as you're positive rate and hitting the gear button. If you cross the North shore of the Potomac you might have missiles coming after you.

Once you've made the turn to 320 you may contact departure without being instructed by Tower.

Really once you understand these things the challenge makes it that much more fun.

Oh, one last thing, and I got in a bit of trouble for this... Landing North, if its really busy they work on crazy tight separation. "...cleared for takeoff, traffic on a two mile final..." If you are approaching runway 1 always be prepared to swing to runway 33 at the last moment. They do this in the real world frequently, but the one time I tried it on a VATSIM pilot I got an argument.
 
I know....it's an insane approach.. I flew it twice when I was in flight school and had it on cross country flights. UGH!!!!! I swore I would never do it again.. the leg down the potomac and then DIVE into the airport... it's insane!!!! I wanted to kill my flight instructor for taking us there. But, I will say this... Once you do it a couple times...you really appreciate other so called 'difficult' approaches. Aspen is another bitch approach. Did that once when going to ski with another friend from flight school who had a condo there. (his parents did).. That's another one that I can be happy if I never do it again. LOL

- Greg
 
There are times now that I work 18-20 hour days...and I may do that 5 days in a row.

Great, but I wouldn't want ATC to do that. Considering the periods ATC are allowed to work legally you have to wonder if there were external factors, or if his duty roster didn't allow him sufficient rest time. In the UK they're very strict about duty time for ATC, as far as I can tell they can work less hours than aircrew. This is because it's safety critical and it's hard to keep arousal levels at a high enough level when you're staring at a radar screen or out a window for hours on end with nothing happening.
And don't get me started on the working patterns of the world's navies and coast guards which seem to think if you haven't been up for 24 hours then you can't be tired.
 
I was just in D.C. a few days ago (Thurs & Fri) and was constantly watching planes takeoff and land from DCA (yes, I was also "observing" monuments, etc :D)

...about the approach...

About 2 years back, I went to DC on easter weekend. Runway 19 was active and there was about a 15kt direct crosswind on final... observing from Gravelly Point (look in Google Earth) was QUITE entertaining :D
 
Random fact about DCA that is pretty cool, did you know TWR can make lights flash on the nearby bridges on demand? I guess its useful for helping AC get a visual landmark at night. Not sure when they actually use it though.

I keep saying it would be awesome if this could be done in the sim.
 
Random fact about DCA that is pretty cool, did you know TWR can make lights flash on the nearby bridges on demand? I guess its useful for helping AC get a visual landmark at night. Not sure when they actually use it though.

I keep saying it would be awesome if this could be done in the sim.

That would make perfect sense actually with the layout of the approach. FS lacks so much when it comes to ATC and real world anything... I mean, I can remember way back in fs5 having discussions about pilot controlled lighting at airports... That should have been a very simple thing to add in and yet, was never done.

What totally sucks...is that they basically kill the software, yet won't relinquish any of it so that others can FIX it... I mean, if a company goes out of business or stops all development on a title, they should release it out to open source or something.. Hell, release it to those that actually created it, and let them fix it.

- Greg

PS...I'll just keep dreaming ... it is 4:15am. LOL
 
What totally sucks...is that they basically kill the software, yet won't relinquish any of it so that others can FIX it... I mean, if a company goes out of business or stops all development on a title, they should release it out to open source or something.. Hell, release it to those that actually created it, and let them fix it.

Not another one of "those" threads :rolleyes:
 
Back
Top