• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

Copyright Interpretation

Status
Not open for further replies.
Publishing your work does not require you to make any statements regarding copyright or usage, nor does it require you to respond to inquiries about those rights. Silence does not equal consent.

If you want to use anyone's content, you should make sure it's OK. Don't assume it's OK until told otherwise.

When I publish, I generally include a usage guide to the effect that you can do whatever you like with the content. For free stuff, it's the easiest way. I sometimes will even include source code to help other derive their own tools, using the code.

If you develop a derivative tool or BGL that you do not have specific permission to create, then be prepared to endure the wrath of the originator... be it a modeler, a company, or Microsoft themselves.

I have never heard of a single case of Microsoft 'defending' their rights concerning content or 'backward-engineering' their content. This doesn't mean Microsoft has surrendered their rights... it just means they have not chosen to exercise those rights... yet. The same would be true of any company or individual that has chosen not to exercise those rights... yet.

Dick
 
You could also make a reasonable case that a building in a public area is in "the public domain" ... and hence your likeness is no more or less illegal than a photograph or painting ... or a sculpture for that matter.

As a side note, "public domain" seems to be a gray area. Let's say I walk past a field and see a horse standing there, and decide I want to do a painting of that horse. The horse is there for all to see. Public domain? Yet by law, the owner of the horse also has rights to images of that horse. If my painting looks enough like the horse that the owner can ID it, I can be sued for not getting permission to do the painting.

Bob
 
To add to Bob's thoughts:

Novelists and screenwriters have to be especially careful about borrowing from life, as many people are very private and this leads to the disclaimers about any persons living or dead...

When I write that I haven't heard of Microsoft going after anyone, I qualify that by stating this concerns content for the flight simulator series. They do go after Apple, Oracle, Google...

Disney, on the other hand very much goes after individuals and small enterprises. No Mickey, Minnie or Goofy allowed! And some airlines and aircraft manufacturers are pretty touchy about using their imagery or forms for models.

Again, concerning static models... I think it would be better to just make your own models, if possible. Too much detail in the modeling of the scenery will just lower framerates.

Dick
 
I am not an expert in US law.

I doubt that any FS creation has exceeded the amount of time that a copyright / patent lasts, so that particular argument probably has no currency here.

With regard to making buildings etc ... you are probably correct if you copied a blueprint of them, and possibly correct if anyone felt afronted at you making a likeness ... this has NOTHING to do with decompiling a model and using it against the original authors wishes, however. Totally different issue.

You could also make a reasonable case that a building in a public area is in "the public domain" ... and hence your likeness is no more or less illegal than a photograph or painting ... or a sculpture for that matter.

The other thing that is worth remembering is that there are "other" statutes and laws enforced in places other than the U.S.

The world does extend west past Hawaii and a long way east of New York!

As I said, I am simply stating the way the law is written and interpreted here. That's all I can comment on. Since they have had to add all sorts of new things to cover online material, I know that if something resides, is offered from, or sold from a US based server, it is subject to US copyright laws automatically. Doesn't mean it isn't still covered by any other country, or the country of origin.

As for creating an item, especially if sold, that is a true likeness of a current building, item, etc.... then TECHNICALLY you ARE required to get permission to use that likeness in any project. Just as the people that create the pictures and books showing doors in cities around the world...they are required to get permission to use those images before selling them as published works. HOWEVER...as you state, there is an assumption of free use simply because it is already public. Thus, after reasonable attempts are made to contact various parties that are or may be in interest of said items, use of images becomes one of public domain.

However, think about this...if I take a photo of a baseball...and I put that photo online...I automatically OWN the rights to that photo.. Are there losers in the world that would sue if you use their photo of a baseball park...yes.. I guess I just don't play that way.. I could care less. If I put it online, then I honestly don't care what is done with it. I just don't..

Can you make a model of the Washington monument and sell it in package of scenery items? Of course you can. Are you breaking the letter of the law? Yes! Is anyone going to come knocking on your door about it? NO!

I have dealt with international copyright laws in my own business.. I have traveled all over the world to defend some and to answer complaints of our use of some... This is a FUN issue for me... I love discussing it because it is one of the FEW things I do keep up on and understand. :)

- Greg

PS: My sister is an architect... That's why I know about the image rights.. That architect creates the facade of a building. They own the rights to the likeness of it. it simply isn't something 99.99999% of them would ever whine about. To copy something is the greatest form of flattery you can give.... And trust me, most architects will take it, when it comes to models, pictures, paintings, etc... Just don't BUILD the same looking building.. LOL
 
Last edited:
I had a quick look at US copyright law references online and it seems copyright in the US endures for the lifetime of the author and for up to 70 years after his or her death if there are heirs. Even the December 2010 cleanup amendments don't seem to affect that.

Anyone still developing for FS 1941? :rotfl:
 
If I put it online, then I honestly don't care what is done with it. I just don't.

Generation Internet. Saying "Thanks for this" with a number of views or downloads.

Then again, if I was to thank everyone for what they're contributing to the depth of the WWW, I'd be busy all day instead of reading and consuming.

I really need a global "Internet Day". There's holidays for all kinds of reasons (mostly religious ones), so why not for the internet as well? :D
 
i dont get it...if youve the tools to decompile, modify, recompile....it seems harder and more time intensive...and in the end not very satisfying...than building your own.....the textures being the difficult bit...at least for a static object....and without permission its no....with permission it seems more trouble than its worth.....a complex flyable aifcraft, doesnt make a great static object..

i havent tried it, so i may be wrong....jim
 
However, think about this...if I take a photo of a baseball...and I put that photo online...I automatically OWN the rights to that photo.. Are there losers in the world that would sue if you use their photo of a baseball park...yes.. I guess I just don't play that way.. I could care less.

Greg ... if the photo had taken you 18 months of painstaking modelling and texturing time, upset your wife and family and was intended to be your income (apart from being the fruit of so many hours labour) you would have a different outlook. The comparison is not valid IMHO.

The fact is a photo takes a couple of minutes to process from camera to internet (often less) ... so you are right that your "ownership" of it would be laughable.

Professional photographers would see it very differently if you use sample images from their website. They go to lengths to make them unusable. (That doesn't mean that if you remove all the watermarks that all is OK by the way)

Just because you CAN do something doesn't make it right. Just because the law will LET you do something doesn't make it "right" either.

The law is a "floor" protection to stop the "lowest" forms of behaviour that society terms "illegal"

It is not the benchmark of ethical and moral behaviour ... it is the safety net, and a signpost for the weak and corrupt.
 
Greg ... if the photo had taken you 18 months of painstaking modelling and texturing time, upset your wife and family and was intended to be your income (apart from being the fruit of so many hours labour) you would have a different outlook. The comparison is not valid IMHO.

The fact is a photo takes a couple of minutes to process from camera to internet (often less) ... so you are right that your "ownership" of it would be laughable.

Professional photographers would see it very differently if you use sample images from their website. They go to lengths to make them unusable. (That doesn't mean that if you remove all the watermarks that all is OK by the way)

Just because you CAN do something doesn't make it right. Just because the law will LET you do something doesn't make it "right" either.

The law is a "floor" protection to stop the "lowest" forms of behaviour that society terms "illegal"

It is not the benchmark of ethical and moral behaviour ... it is the safety net, and a signpost for the weak and corrupt.

But who are YOU to judge what is right or what is wrong? That is a weak argument because everyone has their own morals and standards.

As for spending many hours on a project..... So far, on my KNKL and NKL project, I have over 500 hours invested.. I have almost completed the project several times, only to scrap almost everything, and start over... And when I finally do release it, it will be 100% free do what you want with it.. So don't tell me how YOU would handle it..

As a side example... I had a laptop stolen from me.. Was I pissed? You can't even imagine. All my personal files, projects, photo's of my kids that were ONLY on there... But you know what... life moved on.. I got over it.. And somewhere someone that needed that computer more than I did got it..

I could just as easily go the total opposite of your thinking and say that anyone that creates something and then refuses to share it with others unless they get money..and even when they are finished using it, won't let someone else have it unless they are paid for it, again, even though they are done, won't ever use it or touch it again... that person is just a sad excuse for a human...they are lame, and worthless..

We would all agree that THAT is a pretty crappy view.. But, who are you...and who am I to say who is right and who is wrong..

The initial question dealt with something that someone has basically said they are done with, use it... but with this condition.. Copyright laws are actually quite specific in this regard.. Once you give someone the right to use something you no longer support or have use for, you can't condition their use of it.

Oh..and the copyright laws were JUST changed in the US.. About 3-4 weeks ago. So make sure you are looking at a current version.

- Greg

BTW: I am NOT condoning anything here btw.. So don't confuse what I am posting as my feelings... I have not stated my feelings on the subject... So please, don't accuse me of anything.. You don't know where I stand. :)
 
Folks

May I remind y'all that (as far as I know) none of us here are lawyers (or more specifically copyright lawyers).

Also copyright (along with the discussions on 'Flight') seems to be one of those subjects that engenders passion amongst us.

This is a moderatorial note that there appears to be somewhat of a 'personal' edge appearing in these discussions and that could easily lead to us locking this thread.
 
To add to what Jon already said. None of us (AFAIK) are lawyers, so don't turn this into a yes/no discussion please. FSDeveloper is a place for any developer (freeware, payware, etc) and that means we need to respect the copyright of each others work.

As simple as that, if you have no permission to use it and the readme doesn't give you, don't use it. Any thread that promotes ignoring the copyright on work will be closed.
 
Succinctly put Arno and Jon.

Explanations tend to start looking argumentative on forums ... But back to the original post, I do suspect you have gotten to the heart of the matter.

I'll readily admit that wonton use of others work gets me hot under the collar these days.

In any case ... It is much better to create something yourself that you can be proud of and call your own
 
I think there is a place for the subject of copyright in these forums and it falls into two categories:

(1) The copyright of others

(2) The copyright of 'us' in respect of our own work.

In the case of (1) we are bound to respect the rights of others. If that is unclear we ask them their intent. If they are unwilling or unable to clarify then we must err on the assumption that their copyright is full and clear and we basically can't use it.

In the case of (2) copyright is inherent in our work. We often use elements from others and we must therefore honor and acknowledge those copyrights and certainly not use anything that we do not have clear common (e.g. publicly specified) or personal (e.g. we asked and received). We should also place as clear a copyright statement in our work as we are able. I do not think this needs to be couched in obtuse legal terms - we can say - this is copy right me and you may not use it -

  • at all
  • or without my express written permission
  • or you may use it provided that my copyright is included and you acknolwdge it

Or it is public domain etc etc

Beyond this go speak to a lawyer.

Please note that I place this as is and it is copyright me so you may not enter into a discussion of the rights and wrongs thereof without my written permission (which I shall withhold)..... ;) :)
 
Last edited:
I think part of the problem is that many folks think that if they own something ( either they bought it or they got it free), they can do what ever they please with it. That is only true to a certain extent.

Let's say I buy a book about the "Mona Lisa". I can read that book. I can give that book away. I can throw that book out. I can cut it in half. But I can't photo copy a page of it.

Let's say I buy the Mona Lisa. Lucky me. I own The most famous painting in the world. It took Da Vinci decades to paint. I believe the copyright has run out on that painting. I can do whatever I like with the painting. I can look at it. I can put it in storage. I, or anyone can take a photo of it and sell it or give it away. I can loan it to a museum. I can burn it. All legal.

Could it be that our ethical and intellectual focus is a bit off? Who, in their right mind, would burn the Mona Lisa. A legal thing to do.
Yet I dare say all of us may have broken the law and copied a page of a book or the like.

Of course, we need copyright laws. Because we are the way we are. I just think it interesting that a completly unimportant book about the Mona Lisa has more protections than the actual object.

Bob
 
Very interesting and informative Bob :)
 
Interesting about no photo copies of a book. The library I go to has a photo copier (a pay one so they can make some money). No sign is posted on the photo copier warning about copyright infringement; the only sign describes how to put your money in the copier and how to copy the page of interest. No wonder people are confused about copyrights!

Regards, Mike Mann
 
Interesting about no photo copies of a book. The library I go to has a photo copier (a pay one so they can make some money). No sign is posted on the photo copier warning about copyright infringement; the only sign describes how to put your money in the copier and how to copy the page of interest. No wonder people are confused about copyrights!

Regards, Mike Mann

There is often an allowance in copyright to allow others to extract a small amount from a book - usually in connection with reviewing etc etc. So perhaps it covers copying a para or two ;)
 
There is often an allowance in copyright to allow others to extract a small amount from a book - usually in connection with reviewing etc etc. So perhaps it covers copying a para or two ;)

Maybe I can just copy part of the plane, like the fuselage and wings. I don't need the virtual cockpit for a static.:D

Regards, Mike Mann
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top