• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

Copyright Issues

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
1,964
Country
unitedkingdom
I have a bit of an issue.

When making a commercial package of an airport does one need the permission of the airport owners to market it if it uses no actual imagery associated with the airport, but uses the airport name?

And... should a detail from a commons image be used depicting the logo of the airport be used is this an infringement of intellectual property rights, requiring the permission of the airport owners?

Any help will be appreciated.
 
Check with the airport operator. That is the only way to know for sure.
 
If the airport is public-owned, public use, most likely not. As far as logos go, you might want to run it by them.
 
Yeah cheers, I have discussed it with the airport.... they were happy for me to come and take photos for use for the project as long as I paid £350/$500 an hour, even for land-side photos.

I said that I couldn't afford that and asked if I could use a detail of a commons image of the terminal for it (including the logo), they then refused. Upon my asking why I was told they will have to speak to their legal team. I don't think I'll use it somehow.
 
Yes it is...

Well, I could use some for the terminal textures, It was just the part with their logo that caused the fuss, I think, I hope. You can't hold an intellectual property right on a small part of a photo of a building.
 
Yeah cheers, I have discussed it with the airport.... they were happy for me to come and take photos for use for the project as long as I paid £350/$500 an hour, even for land-side photos.

I said that I couldn't afford that and asked if I could use a detail of a commons image of the terminal for it (including the logo), they then refused. Upon my asking why I was told they will have to speak to their legal team. I don't think I'll use it somehow.

Then I guess you have your answer......................
 
Yup. But does one need explicit permission from an airport to release a package called the same name as the airport? As long as it contains no photo references and the name isn't copyrighted?

I'm sure some of you have released airports commercially.... did you get permission?
 
When I made NZWN, I did ask for specific permission in writing to reproduce the 'image' of the airport, I even asked if I could use their logo in my promotional stuff, and they were happy to let me do that. I always talk to someone at the airport rather than assuming that I can do what I like.

Sometimes this works well, sometimes not. Choosing who to contact at the airport is a bit of a lottery, choose the wrong person and at best you'll be held up for months. At worst, I've been told that if I take any photos of one particular major airport -- even if I line up with the airplane nutters at the viewing spots -- I'll get a trespass order.

Although I've completed some airports without any help or permission from the airport, I always ask, and a lack of support isn't the same as an actual 'no', but if they do say no, then I'll leave it alone.
 
Thank you, your advice has been extremely helpful.

But now I am worried that they might say that they wont allow me to publish my nearly completed airport. I do hope that is not the case.
 
Thank you, your advice has been extremely helpful.

But now I am worried that they might say that they wont allow me to publish my nearly completed airport. I do hope that is not the case.
I'm not living in your country and I don't understand this at all.
I used to make a small airport and asked them to take some photographs in detail. They said that it was their pleasure to let me do their airport but I needed to give them what I had done. So they would use my airport for flight training in PC. Beside that, having their airport in Flight sim world would bring more customers. It sounds like advertising for FREE. There are a lot of good things having the airport in FS world. Why they are so mean?
The profit we have cannot make us rich, just pay the bills.
I agree with toprob, the airport has no life. It depends on who you contact with. The right person, opened mind, see through things, will smooth out everything. A mean person will shut it down, only the money on the desk they see, not the relationship or benefit in future.
 
I have now been asked to put a disclaimer stating that the images used are not of the actual airport.
 
Last edited:
A mean person will shut it down, only the money on the desk they see, not the relationship or benefit in future.


What realistic benefit is there to the airport in having it modelled for flight simulator?

Almost anything we might want to use is the property of someone else so it's not unreasonable to have to pay to use it - if only to cover the costs of considering a request for and granting a licence.

It's not a question of "mean" people. Most organisations have policies to deal with licencing. Any organisation will want to put use limitations on individual licences - an airport wouldn't want to be used in, say, a game involving terrorism. If an airport has already granted commercial licences it's unlikely to grant free ones with no restictions on use - existing licencees wouldn't be too happy about that.

The underlying reality is that a long as companies are prepared to pay for the use of a another's rights then there's no advantage in giving free them away free.

Non-aeronautical activities can be big business. Heathrow's annual income from retail is £207m which equals 40% of its income from aeronautical activites. It makes over £50m a year from the railway connections.

.
 
It's not a question of "mean" people. Most organisations have policies to deal with licencing. Any organisation will want to put use limitations on individual licences - an airport wouldn't want to be used in, say, a game involving terrorism. If an airport has already granted commercial licences it's unlikely to grant free ones with no restictions on use - existing licencees wouldn't be too happy about that.
OK. I got that. Sorry for my word.
 
The underlying reality is that a long as companies are prepared to pay for the use of a another's rights then there's no advantage in giving free them away free.

There is a lot you can do to get around these things, provided you approach them in the right way. I never represent myself as a business when I approach an airport, rather as a very keen hobbyist, a real aviation geek. I try not to mention 'Microsoft' when I talk about the sim, as this can turn it into a money issue.

This goes for other contacts as well -- it is possible to get aerial images for a lot less than the full price, for instance, just by finding someone who can get excited about what I'm planning to do with it.

I'm always surprised that a lot of developers don't like to talk to people who could help them with whatever they want -- I couldn't manage without the help of a lot of airport personnel, and local council staff. If you can get excited about what you do, it is quite easy to pass this excitement onto someone who can help you.
 
What realistic benefit is there to the airport in having it modelled for flight simulator?

"Oh my, what a lovely airport. I'll look it up on Wikipedia. Oh, hey...a link to the article about the adjoining city. Dang, that's a nice city. I just might spend my holidays there..."

Regard it as a method of subtle manipulation.

For some, it takes a book; for others, it takes a "Cool places around the globe" programme on TV and for others, it takes a nicely done rendition in an interactive environment.

I don't wanna know how many "I want to go there someday!" all the ORBX stuff invokes...
 
"Oh my, what a lovely airport. I'll look it up on Wikipedia. Oh, hey...a link to the article about the adjoining city. Dang, that's a nice city. I just might spend my holidays there..."

Regard it as a method of subtle manipulation.

For some, it takes a book; for others, it takes a "Cool places around the globe" programme on TV and for others, it takes a nicely done rendition in an interactive environment.

I don't wanna know how many "I want to go there someday!" all the ORBX stuff invokes...


Come on! I did say realistic.
 
I think today's google earth can let you see everywhere include the airport that we are modelling. Absolute Privacy is not real for today. I think next step of the airport is charging google earth for the satellite photo that taken from the sky. :D
I think toprob gave a good advice here.

By the way, the topic is getting hot guys. Keep it cool or else tt might be get locked real soon.
 
By the way, the topic is getting hot guys. Keep it cool or else tt might be get locked real soon.

Saved me some key strokes ;)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top