• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

FSX Engine Misfire

Messages
10,163
Country
us-arizona
Hey all,

If I wanted my engine to misfire with an icey carburetor, how might one go about that? Can it be done in XML? This would need to behave nicely or realistically. Has anyone here done such work with creating engine failures?



Bill
 
Couldnt carb-blockage be simulated with lower RPM and gradual fuel starvation?
I know nothing about it or how it works in FS. Its what I would try first if I knew nothing about it. Its logical :)

As for mis-firing, I dont know that a misfire would occur normally during carb icing, as it would simply starve the engine of fuel, just like when you pull the mixture to full lean/closed. If the ice breaks off and enters the valve, I supposed a misfire could occur as the heat would melt the ice immediately and decrease the fuels ability to ignite for a couple of cycles. Normally you would notice a gradual decrease in power, then it would shutter a little bit for a few seconds before it dies. Then your hosed; restarting an iced carb is hard to do and usually takes 3 minutes or so depending on outside temp and humidity for melting. Trim for best glide, turn on carb heat if not already and shut all cowl flaps(if present) to contain some engine heat, hopefully it melts. If you notice it in time you should have carb heat on before the starvation occurs and the engine temp is warm enough to melt the ice or prevent it. this is picked up during training if you have a half decent instructor.
 
Last edited:
I thought FSX already simulated an iced carb? I'm sure I've had it where the engine was down on power until I put the carb heat on and then it returned.

I'm not sure you get misfires with carb icing, all the accident reports I've read where it's been a factor seem to indicate it's quite a subtle fault as the engine appeared to be working normally but wasn't producing enough power to clear that hedge/barn/wire etc. Similarly I've had it in an R-22 a couple of times where applying carb heat gave an noticeable improvement in engine output but there was no real indication beforehand that anything was wrong.
 
Hey guys,


I could never find a way to control fuel flow or over-ride throttle. I had tried something like this a couple of years ago, and finally abandoned it.

On my planes, they never seem to ice over, so I wonder if its an invisible gauge. Or... perhaps a setting in FS.

Several planes have had this in the past, such as the Hughes Air Racer from Aerosoft. It had some amazing and pretty realistic engine behavior if you didnt monitor the engine well.
 
It requires SimConnect and C++....

Thats the only way to do it? You would think there was an easier way.



I'm not sure you get misfires with carb icing, all the accident reports I've read where it's been a factor seem to indicate it's quite a subtle fault as the engine appeared to be working normally but wasn't producing enough power to clear that hedge/barn/wire etc. Similarly I've had it in an R-22 a couple of times where applying carb heat gave an noticeable improvement in engine output but there was no real indication beforehand that anything was wrong.

Carb ice can cause, although rare, a misfire, just because its not in an accident report doesnt mean it hasnt happened. If a chunk of ice breaks free from the venturi throat and enters the cylinder or melts at the intake valve, it could flash steam or instantly melt from the heat thus causing too much humidity/water(removing oxygen) for the fuel-air mixture to ignite on that cycle. This would be a mis-fire.
Carb Icing problems that lead to a crash is the full fault of the PIC. With carb icing, the pilot should have noticed the gradual sluggishness of the engine, and the slow but steady decrease in power and RPM. Carb icing is not an immediate blockage, but blockage buildup over time. Applying carb heat early enough is the key to preventing it. Applying the carb heat just opens the exhaust port to recirculate the exhaust gas around back into the air intake to provide hot air to the venturi (rarely its a boot or cover for the carb that heats the area around the carb instead of reintroducing it to the intake). There are also electrically heated carb heat filaments to rapidly heat the venturi, but not all models have this.

I use carb heat whenever the conditions are right for it. High humidity (visible moisture such as clouds, fog, or mist) and OAT below 72F (I use 72 over 70 because its entirely possible that the OAT gauge may be off by a degree or so).
 
Thats the only way to do it? You would think there was an easier way.

Well there is FSUIPC which is based off SimConnect (at least for FSX) but there is still some C++ or Lua or LINDA(or whatever Pete uses) interface required...
 
"Carb ice can cause, although rare, a misfire," agree, it just might happen but surely a"one of a kind" event in one out of thousands....hummm,. I still have to see FSX figuring out how to simulate ice problems.....X-Plane does it well. There is some software somewhere advertising "ice situations even on the ground for FSX" but their previous products are really not anything to brag about.
 
I found what I had originally heard about long ago... It was called RealEngine V1.1 by Gunter also known as Teson1. He had a ton of realisms for engine behavior and failures for up to 4 engines.

But... I cant find his email and man, his kit is so dang huge and sophisticated. All I want is a couple of effects... sigh..
 
Hint: He's a member here.

Also, IIRC, RealEngine's code is commented, so finding what you're looking for is definitely a possibility.
 
"Carb ice can cause, although rare, a misfire," agree, it just might happen but surely a"one of a kind" event in one out of thousands....hummm,. I still have to see FSX figuring out how to simulate ice problems.....X-Plane does it well. There is some software somewhere advertising "ice situations even on the ground for FSX" but their previous products are really not anything to brag about.

I did state it was a very rare occurrence.

Xplane uses a completely different approach for sim creation and programming. I admire the setup and am about to move over to Xplane.

FSX i think simulates ice with modification to the aircraft based on the WX. Xplane modifies the weather characteristics, in turn changing the aircrafts response requirements, but not the aircraft itself. I dont know, this is just a theory.
 
Back
Top