• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

Flickering Roofs

Messages
687
Country
us-texas
I've completed my latest project and took a quick flight around the circuit to see it from the air. Major flickering on all the roofs of the hangars. Does anyone know what causes that and how I might be able to fix it? I have read other threads that talk about ground poly flickering and the use of a "Z-bias" setting, but none that states specifically how it's used. Would that correct this?
 
Turn off double sided. I presume that you have some thickness on your buildings.. + different textures. I mean inside and outside..
 
Turn off double sided. I presume that you have some thickness on your buildings.. + different textures. I mean inside and outside..
Yes the roofs have a thickness to them and the exterior and interior walls are textured with different textures. I'll give that a try, Thanks!
 
Send us an example... Not your piece of project, but make something similar to building so it has the same issue..
 
Send us an example... Not your piece of project, but make something similar to building so it has the same issue..
I tried to attach a zipfile (8meg), but this is what I got.

Your submission could not be processed because a security token was missing.
If this occurred unexpectedly, please inform the administrator and describe the action you performed before you received this error.
 
Each roof has approx 2" spacing

That's not enough if you've batched the models through MCX, that's one disadvantage to drawcall batching, if your geometry is not manifold you'll get some flickering whenever two planes are close together like that. You could try adding an empty LOD in MCX which will prevent MCX from batching the model. You of course give up the benefits of drawcall batching when you do that.
 
That's not enough if you've batched the models through MCX, that's one disadvantage to drawcall batching, if your geometry is not manifold you'll get some flickering whenever two planes are close together like that. You could try adding an empty LOD in MCX which will prevent MCX from batching the model. You of course give up the benefits of drawcall batching when you do that.
I'll know better than to take on any more projects like this til I learn more about what you're saying. What is "Manifold Geometry"? I understand the drawcall portion as I allow MCX to minimize the drawcalls. 60+ custom objects all with different textures. . .minimizing the drawcalls is a godsend. . .without it, I'd still be working on the first third of the project. Of course if what you say is correct, this whole project could end up going to someone else anyway.
 
even 15" , 20" 100" will get flickr at higher altitudes. I solved this issue. Double side - off, Make sure your face normals are looking outwards of each other.. (Inside to inside, roof to the sky.) Or, sure follow JRobinson's method, see whats better for you.
 
Here is just one of the offending hangars with the "normals" displayed.
 

Attachments

  • Normals.jpg
    Normals.jpg
    318.1 KB · Views: 467
Are you going to taste a beer in those hangars ? Remove inside thickness of the roof.. Yea, unless you need some kinda manifold structure..
 
Hi Ed:

In Sketchup Menu > File > Export > Browse dialog for file type (ex: *.SKP, KMZ, Collada / *.DAE, *.OBJ etc.) being exported to ModelConverterX, via the "Options" button, are you setting configuration to disable "2-sided Faces" during export from Sketchup ...before the file is imported by ModelConverterX ? :confused:

This disables export of the "back" side of faces (Sketchup by default always creates objects with 2-sided faces within its own work environment, but the reverse side which is usually the 'darker' face in "Textured with Shadows" mode, need not be exported). ;)


PS: AFAIK, "Manifold" is a 25-cent term in 3D modeling syntax which means a "solid" or 'airtight' object, meaning that we'd have closed windows, doors, and would have a bottom floor on any structures we build.

When we make objects this way, some 3D modeling and world rendering programs (including FS) handle them in a somewhat different manner.

IIRC, shadows and a few other attributes are easier to deal with; probably Arno and Jim know a bit more about how FS actually handles Manifold objects at run time after import via MCX and compilation to a MDL. :wizard:


Hope this helps eliminate the flicker ! :)

GaryGB
 
Last edited:
Are you going to taste a beer in those hangars ? Remove inside thickness of the roof.. Yea, unless you need some kinda manifold structure..
Sorry the first statement is over my head. As far as the roof thickness. . .are you saying that all roofs should be just a single plane. . .no thickness at all? Some of the roofs, have a string of 2x4's across the top to support the roof, is that what you are referring to as a "manifold"?
 
Here is just one of the offending hangars with the "normals" displayed.

So when you slew into the doorway of that hangar and look up do you see the inside of the roof or just sky? Really there should be no flicker between two polys that face opposite directions so if you're seeing sky from inside the hangar you may just need to flip normals on the interior roof plane which will make it visible and should eliminate the flicker. If you're using sketchup you're on your own but I'd double check what Gary said about exporting 2-sided faces.

Jim
 
No Manifold geometry means:
Every edge belongs to two faces,
every vertex is surrounded by one sequence of edges and faces,
faces only intersect each other in common edges and vertices,
there is a material on only one side of a face
Sorry I didn't realize that your model comes out of sketchup oven, well then that above may change the situation. Try. If not - try again.
 
Hi Again:

[EDITED]

Ed, In your screenie posted immediately above, due to a failure on my part to enlarge the screenie and examine it in greater detail, I thought I saw what looks like a non-co-planar face flickering on the wall under the word "Royal".

However, looking at it now that I'm back on a better screen, I see that I was mistaken.; my apologies. :o


FYI: Non-co-planar faces sometimes can form in Sketchup when making multiple faces to use different or repeating tiles from non-seamless textures which cannot be automatically tiled via the built-in texture tiling engine in Sketchup.

You may wish to examine the faces which show flickering in FS during a flight, from inside Sketchup, but with "Show Hidden Geometry" turned on, and inspect for non-co-planar faces.


[END_EDIT]

Hope this helps with the model enhancement process ! :)

PS: I'm on the road, and will check on this thread again tonite; here's wishing good luck with the troubleshooting ! :cool:

GaryGB
 
Last edited:
So when you slew into the doorway of that hangar and look up do you see the inside of the roof or just sky? Really there should be no flicker between two polys that face opposite directions so if you're seeing sky from inside the hangar you may just need to flip normals on the interior roof plane which will make it visible and should eliminate the flicker. If you're using sketchup you're on your own but I'd double check what Gary said about exporting 2-sided faces.

Jim
Every hangar is textured inside and out to include the ceiling.
 
Back
Top