• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

Flickering Roofs

Hi Ed:

In Sketchup Menu > File > Export > Browse dialog for file type (ex: *.SKP, KMZ, Collada *.DAE etc.) being exported to ModelConverterX, via the "Options" button, are you setting configuration to disable "2-sided Faces" during export from Sketchup ...before the file is imported by ModelConverterX ? :confused:

This disables export of the "back" side of faces (Sketchup by default always creates objects with 2-sided faces within its own work environment, but the reverse side which is usually the 'darker' face in "Textured with Shadows" mode, need not be exported). ;)


PS: AFAIK, "Manifold" is a 25-cent term in 3D modeling syntax which means a "solid" or 'airtight' object, meaning that we'd have closed windows, doors, and would have a bottom floor on any structures we build.

When we make objects this way, some 3D modeling and world rendering programs (including FS) handle them in a somewhat different manner.

IIRC, shadows and a few other attributes are easier to deal with; probably Arno and Jim know a bit more about how FS actually handles Manifold objects at run time after import via MCX and compilation to a MDL. :wizard:


Hope this helps eliminate the flicker ! :)

GaryGB
Simple answer to that Gary is, no I don't. I finish the model, save the file and then export. I don't go through any other steps. I'll take a look at that and the non-co-planer check and see what I find.
 
I'm thinking it's the two-sided faces thing, if you slew into the roof box so you can see the inside of it do you see the top side of the ceiling and the bottom side of the roof? If so I think that's where your problem lies and you need to figure out how to export single sided faces as Gary suggested. You shouldn't see those faces from inside the box.

It's also possible that you actually have those faces modeled in your sketchup model, in which case you'd need to delete them and re-export.

I just did show normals on one of my models in MCX and it looks to me like your normals are doubled up, you've got about twice as many arrows showing as mine does.

Manifold geometry is pretty rare in FS modeling BTW so don't worry about that, I have used it to cure flickers before though. Say a sign that flickers against the post it's mounted to, if you make the sign an actual box with very thin sides rather than just a couple planes slapped back to back it will then be manifold and the flickering will stop - well it did for me anyway on a couple signs I made a while back.
 
Gary I would have never paid any attention to that "Options" button, if you hadn't mentioned it. Staring me right in the face every time yet I would simply hit "export" and move on.

The Export Options as they are currently setup:
Export Two-Sided Faces. . .unchecked
Export Edges. . .unchecked
Triangulate All Faces. . .Checked
Export Hidden Geometry. . .unchecked

Also, Export Texture Maps. . .checked

**********************************************************
I did check for any hidden geometry. . .that was negative.

One thing I did do, but I don't see this affecting the roof area. Each of the hangar floors are dropped about 4" to keep from getting a flicker on the hangar floor. I just raise the hanger slightly to show the floor and the front edge of the flooring keeps it from looking like it's suspended in the air.

Below are some shots of various views of one of the offending hangars:
 

Attachments

  • ORA_flicker-2013-oct-20-003.jpg
    ORA_flicker-2013-oct-20-003.jpg
    588.7 KB · Views: 461
  • ORA_flicker-2013-oct-20-002.jpg
    ORA_flicker-2013-oct-20-002.jpg
    364.1 KB · Views: 406
  • ORA_flicker-2013-oct-20-001.jpg
    ORA_flicker-2013-oct-20-001.jpg
    914.3 KB · Views: 452
Hi Ed:

I just got a few more minutes free during a break from driving at a Starbucks to leech off their Wi-Fi with this (ridiculous) I-Pad2 non-computer. :p.


A few comments:

AFAIK, In Sketchup, we rarely need to concern ourselves with what orientation our "Normals" are pointed in, as this aspect of our 3D models is handled automatically and MCX imports / exports our models with little if any need for modification by us as end users.

It would be desirable to do the extra step of disabling export of "2-Sided Faces", wherever possible, since it results in there being less vertices in our 3D models as IIUC, textures add an extra set of "UVW" vertices on top of the wire frame "vertices" where our main object geometry "faces" meet / join / weld at "edges".

Reducing vertex count (plural for vertex is of course "vertices") helps run time performance in FS, so if a 3D model has walls and other exterior surfaces that are textured only on that exterior surface, we don't need the inner "face" surface to be exported in Sketchup.

For example, a hangar or other building that has no open surfaces and is textured on the exterior only (walls and roof) with no open doors that allow a view of the inside surface ...needs no 2nd surface when exported.


Thus, for a 3D model that needs no textures on the inside surfaces, we would not need / want to export 2-sided faces.

If one is using a wall or roof thickness created by 2 separate and non-co-planar surfaces, the inner "back" side of the textured faces will not be seen by the viewer, so if no other surface of the building will be textured on both sides of the same single face, that would be a 3D model we'd export by disabling 2-sided faces.

The "savings" from not exporting un-needed vertices in static geometry would begin to add up so they could be "spent" elsewhere in the "vertex budget" for a complex aerodrome scenery, especially if there will be a performance hit from AI traffic etc., so its good to consider ones "Options" when exporting from Sketchup prior to import by MCX. :idea:

But, if one has an open door in a hangar or other building that allows the viewer to see inside, it requires us to texture both sides of each visible face, or it would otherwise be transparent in FS; so for that kind of 3D model we would want to allow 2-sided faces during export.


Hope these additional concepts might prove helpful ! :)


Gotta' hit the road again....


[EDITED]

PS: Looks like our posts crossed on the server.

Looking at the example 3D model in your screenies, the larger areas of the roof are made with 2-sided single faces, and the eaves of the roof are each a "box" type of object to use Jim's term, and so is your door and floor.

For the above example 3D model in your screenies, IMHO, one would not want to disable 2-sided faces during export of that 3D model from Sketchup, because the larger areas of the roof use 2-sided faces (the roof faces are textured on both sides).


It would be interesting to see what the results are if you were to export another copy of the 3D model in the latter screenies immediately above, but this time do check the checkbox to "Export 2-sided faces" (meaning do not disable 2-sided faces on export). ;)

[END_EDIT]

GaryGB
 
Last edited:
Manifold geometry is pretty rare in FS modeling BTW so don't worry about that, I have used it to cure flickers before though. Say a sign that flickers against the post it's mounted to, if you make the sign an actual box with very thin sides rather than just a couple planes slapped back to back it will then be manifold and the flickering will stop - well it did for me anyway on a couple signs I made a while back.

Hi Jim:

Excellent info; I'll have to try that ! :)

GaryGB
 
Just an update:For this project I have eliminated the double-decker type roofing I had and went with a single plane. . .no flicker. Also, with one or two exceptions, every hangar/building I produced for this package is open inside and textured on all surfaces. Because this is a very popular and well-known Aerodrome I felt that was necessary to give a more realistic look. Just texturing a single texture on the front to give the illusion of an open hangar was my first consideration, but I quickly dropped that for the more realistic approach. A lot more work to be sure, but the end result is much better.

If I ever do another project like this I'll be better prepared. I honestly don't understand most of what was explained here. My modeling experience is self-taught with very little reading to enhance it. When I discovered how to do the basics, that's as far as my learning process went. Of course that also means that to the well-trained eye, the modeling I'm doing is probably overdone, as I'm completely unaware of shortcuts that would probably make the models better.

Quite amazingly, with over 600 objects on the Aerodrome, I see very little FPS hit, and I have no idea how I was able to accomplish that, lol. Thanks for all the help!
 
Hi Ed:

I just got a few more minutes free during a break from driving at a Starbucks to leech off their Wi-Fi with this (ridiculous) I-Pad2 non-computer. :p.


I agree, good to annoy the people with your last pictures and that...wifi connections. :D
 
I agree, good to annoy the people with your last pictures and that...wifi connections. :D

Hi Bernardo:

Although I suspect based on your use of the above "Emoticon" that your message was intended to be a good-natured expression of humor, I regret to say that, due to things getting lost in (semi-automated ?) translation from Portuguese (again ?), readers of your post here might possibly misinterpret what you meant to convey. :o

So, I do hope everyone reading this will be assured that my goal in posting from on the road via Wi-Fi on an IPAD2 was exclusively to try and help Ed with troubleshooting and enhancing his models made in Sketchup. :)


NOTE: I do regard the IPAD2 as a ridiculous non-computer, but it was my only recourse to try and offer some help on a timely basis, because the FSDeveloper website stalled repeatedly and failed to reload my post edits for final submission back to the server, when I previously attempted for an hour, to post via Opera Mini on my mobile phone (...frustrating me to no end; I hope I don't have to instigate a formal inquiry into what is going on with my connections to the server and/or mirroring host :rolleyes:).

The Emoticon I used was to poke fun at my having to resort to using an IPAD2... and not to "annoy" anyone anyone participating in this thread. ;)

Perhaps this is yet another misunderstanding of context and cultural differences which is bound to occur now and then on a forum used by people from throughout the world ? :confused:


FYI: I try to adjust the wording and content of my posts for the OP in the context of a forum where English is the "required" language to be used except by a special mutual agreement; however in this thread, the OP was an American who I believe fully comprehended what I meant. :wave:


I would be grateful if you would better translate your posts at FSDeveloper into English, to ensure less risk of misunderstanding in the future. :spushpin:

Thanks in advance.

GaryGB
 
Last edited:
Just an update:For this project I have eliminated the double-decker type roofing I had and went with a single plane. . .no flicker. Also, with one or two exceptions, every hangar/building I produced for this package is open inside and textured on all surfaces. Because this is a very popular and well-known Aerodrome I felt that was necessary to give a more realistic look. Just texturing a single texture on the front to give the illusion of an open hangar was my first consideration, but I quickly dropped that for the more realistic approach. A lot more work to be sure, but the end result is much better.

If I ever do another project like this I'll be better prepared. I honestly don't understand most of what was explained here. My modeling experience is self-taught with very little reading to enhance it. When I discovered how to do the basics, that's as far as my learning process went. Of course that also means that to the well-trained eye, the modeling I'm doing is probably overdone, as I'm completely unaware of shortcuts that would probably make the models better.

Quite amazingly, with over 600 objects on the Aerodrome, I see very little FPS hit, and I have no idea how I was able to accomplish that, lol. Thanks for all the help!

The exceptional quality of Ed's current work is already evident in these pix: :cool:

https://www.facebook.com/media/set/?set=a.630328420320583.1073741835.154936167859813&type=3


Of course, I'll be looking forward to seeing what enhancements Ed might add in the next set of pix too ! ;)

Keep up the great work, Ed ! :)

GaryGB
 
all right, transalation
I agree with you, the (Ipad) is good to show picutures (photos ?) to people, and wifi connections , no more than this,it was a little disappointing. Don't know which part can be misinterpreted :confused:
 
Hi again, Bernardo.

I appreciate your good intentions in making friendly conversation. :)

However, out of courtesy to the OP who came here looking for support, and who is trying to keep his commitments on a rather tight schedule, I respectfully suggest that this would be an opportune time for us all to focus our communications on the topic of this thread. :o

Would you perhaps instead, have a suggestion, or some feedback ...which might be more helpful to the OP's inquiries here ? :confused:


Thanks again for your understanding of, and kind consideration for, ...what we are trying to accomplish here on Ed's behalf. ;)

GaryGB
 
Last edited:
Back
Top