• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

Flight

Status
Not open for further replies.

scruffyduck

Administrator
Staff member
FSDevConf team
Resource contributor
Messages
34,981
Country
unitedkingdom
I am at Microsoft in Seattle. Yesterday Nick Whithome and I visited the Flight Team. The team includes a new Community Manager who we met along with other members of the team.

We came away with a much better understanding of where things are. Most of which are, of course, covered by NDA*. However I will say that they are clearly plugged in to, and listening to, the existing community. The team appears to have a higher percentage of licensed pilots than the old FSX team including the Creative Director who spent time as a commercial airline pilot. The folks we met are very passionate about Flight and committed to its future.

We will be staying in touch with the contacts we made and NDA permitting will obviously share what we can.

*The term NDA gets bandied about and the NDA for beta testers was routinely broken by some folks. Just for the record MVP's like Nick and I are pretty much under the same NDA agreement as Microsoft Employees as to what we can and can't say.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I am at Microsoft in Seattle. Yesterday Nick Whithome and I visited the Flight Team. The team includes a new Community Manager who we met along with other members of the team.

We came away with a much better understanding of where things are. Most of which are, of course, covered by NDA*. However I will say that they are clearly plugged in to, and listening to, the existing community. The team appears to have a higher percentage of licensed pilots than the old FSX team including the Creative Director who spent time as a commercial airline pilot. The folks we met are very passionate about Flight and committed to its future.

We will be staying in touch with the contacts we made and NDA permitting will obviously share what we can.

*The term NDA gets bandied about and the NDA for beta testers was routinely broken by some folks. Just for the record MVP's like Nick and I are pretty much under the same NDA agreement as Microsoft Employees as to what we can and can't say.

NDA!!!....What´s next in the Twenty First Century!!!!...." I´ll show you my stuff but don´t tell, don´t tell" ...it is like a 19th Century old woman´s tale. :D:D:D.....maybe I can get some with some candy on the side!!!!:rolleyes::rolleyes: or maybe you could say it is like saying " Come, amigo!!! join my ranks and I´ll share with you some woosy boosy secrets" like the kids around the corner. :):).....Very Asiatic maybe....LOL
 
Last edited:
NDA!!!....What´s next in the Twenty First Century!!!!...." I´ll show you my stuff but don´t tell, don´t tell" ...it is like a 19th Century old woman´s tale. :D:D:D.....maybe I can get some with some candy on the side!!!!:rolleyes::rolleyes: or maybe you could say it is like saying " Come, amigo!!! join my ranks and I´ll share with you some woosy boosy secrets" like the kids around the corner. :):).....Very Asiatic maybe....LOL

You are, of course, perfectly entitled to your opinions and I respect them. However it is a shame that when we try to share something that the response has nothing to do with the content (however limited) but focuses on the legal conditions. I would only say that NDA's are extremely common across all forms of life and are intended to protect the Interlectural and/or commercial interests of an organization.
 
I used to work for a QSR company. (Quick Service Restaurant)

We had NDAs as a condition of employment. We could not disclose anything related to how our pizzas, fried chicken, tacos were made. New products in development, failed product development. The NDA also covered any software we developed, modified or used in the business, not just in-store, but above store systems.

One thing specifically mentioned in our NDA was that purchasing or selling company stock soon before a new product release/ marketing push was not only against the NDA, but likely illegal under US insider trading laws.

While I may not like some of the specifics, or the many Microsoft NDAs we had to sign to be in pre-beta development of things like Windows 2000, Sharepoint, Outlook, Office - I also understood that I had a choice.

That is how the business works.

I'm pleased to learn that the new Flight team is still working with MVPs like Jon. It gives me hope for the future.
 
Last edited:
Good news Jon. Keeping contact with the team is about all we can hope for just now.

If you have the chance read the interview from this link:

interview-joshua-howard-microsoft-flight

Of interest is the comment that it will be a year or two before 3rd party developers are invited to supply content for Flight.

Obviously there are several publishers who’ve been producing and selling content for Flight Simulator games who’d love to be on board with Flight. Is it still the case that Microsoft will be keeping all the DLC in-house?

Yeah we believe that for the first year or two at least, this is something we’ve got to manage and understand and own ourselves. We need a more managed ecosystem to reach the kind of customer that we’re targeting now.

It was one of the more difficult decisions to take with the franchise but we think to appeal to millions of people we had to take a different approach. And one of the consequences of that approach was it’s going to be a much more significant effort to reintroduce that more extensible system. So I won’t say never. But it was outside the focus around the initial product and launch to try to do everything.

I think had we tried to do everything, had we tried to be as extensible as ever while also building a brand new experience I think it would’ve just been a recipe for failure. So let’s get a good experience out there, validate it and respond to what customers want. That gives us the time to understand really where the need and the desire is and then we can extend the product as we go.

So, there is a bit of light at the end of the tunnel. There also seems to be a very uptight attitude about keeping control. I gather that the situation at the end of the FSX development was viewed as a 'mess' by Microsoft's executives... leading to where we are now.

Of course, this mess allowed us to flourish as developers...

Dick
 
NDA!!!....What´s next in the Twenty First Century!!!!...." I´ll show you my stuff but don´t tell, don´t tell" ...it is like a 19th Century old woman´s tale. :D:D:D

Thanks to technological advances, industrial espionage runs rampant and the whole system with patents and stuff is nothing more than a waste of money and a thing of the past.

If you want to keep your advantage up in the business world, guard your information by encryption or NDAs. Or build in a self-destruction mechanism. Or else.
 
...Of interest is the comment that it will be a year or two before 3rd party developers are invited to supply content for Flight...

Thank you for that! It might be a while away, but maybe I now have something about Flight to look forward to.

...We came away with a much better understanding of where things are. Most of which are, of course, covered by NDA...

Which is nothing new. I know of people who saw CFS4 but couldn't talk about it years later, even though MS pulled the plug on it a few months before launch.
 
You are, of course, perfectly entitled to your opinions and I respect them. However it is a shame that when we try to share something that the response has nothing to do with the content (however limited) but focuses on the legal conditions. I would only say that NDA's are extremely common across all forms of life and are intended to protect the Interlectural and/or commercial interests of an organization.

Amigo Jon....your sence of humor today is awash!!!!! smile,:):) you took me to seriously..:o:o. I get the vive on NDA´s but its nice to laugh some too:e...smile you are on candid camera!!!!:eek::eek:
 
Last edited:
Thank you for opening a new topic. I am happy to hear about your invitation to Redmond and for MSGS allowing you a first-hand glimpse into their "Strategic Vision."

After reading Joshua's latest interview and his replies to very specific and focused questions regarding third-party involvement, which combined with my own information gathered during private exchanges with several of the folks involved at MSGS provides further support to an exercise in logic I performed last week.
=====================
I'm a very firm believer in the wise advice of the ancients to not allow ourselves to "burn our bridges behind us," so I'm certainly not about to emulate the two major player's remarkable acts of idiocy, i.e. not only breaking their NDA with MS, but also spewing venom everywhere.

To be perfectly frank about the way I've evaluated the situation, Flight does me no harm whatsoever, and irrespective of how things play out it's a most assuredly a win-win for me as a developer.

Let's consider the only three possible outcomes:

1. Flight is a failure -
FS9 and FSX remain viable platforms for continued development efforts + some of Flights' customers migrate to FS9/FSX.​
2. Flight is a success, but 3pd still locked out -
FS9 and FSX remain viable platforms for continued development efforts + some of Flights' customers migrate to FS9/FSX.​
3. Flight is a success, and 3pd are allowed to participate -
FS9 and FSX remain viable platforms for continued development efforts + some of Flights' customers migrate to FS9/FSX + Flight development increases income.​
See? It's clearly a win-win situation. In addition, Flight actually has some very nice features, and is massively "FUN" to boot!

If it's done nothing else, it's forced me to brush up my very rusty manual IFR procedures and practice hand navigation using only VOR/Localizer guidance!!! :rotfl:
 
To be perfectly frank about the way I've evaluated the situation, Flight does me no harm whatsoever, and irrespective of how things play out it's a most assuredly a win-win for me as a developer.

Let's consider the only three possible outcomes:

1. Flight is a failure -
FS9 and FSX remain viable platforms for continued development efforts + some of Flights' customers migrate to FS9/FSX.​
2. Flight is a success, but 3pd still locked out -
FS9 and FSX remain viable platforms for continued development efforts + some of Flights' customers migrate to FS9/FSX.​
3. Flight is a success, and 3pd are allowed to participate -
FS9 and FSX remain viable platforms for continued development efforts + some of Flights' customers migrate to FS9/FSX + Flight development increases income.​
See? It's clearly a win-win situation. In addition, Flight actually has some very nice features, and is massively "FUN" to boot!

Well said Father Bill.

To quote Bob Dylan,
"Every one of them words rang true and glowed like burnin' coal"

Thank You Father Bill for your massive wisdom. :D

Cheers
Gman
 
Excellent news Jon.
And thankyou for sharing something positive, around the edges of the NDA.

(As an aside, NDA's are not new at all, and quite standard. Almost all large employers have them)
 
Last edited:
I am back in Florida and catching up.

Gera - my sense of humor failure may be the result of too much information, too much beer, too much flying or not enough sleep!

Bill. Thanks for your summary. I think it is well said.

I would also say that FS9, FSX and Flight are not mutually exclusive. They can all reside on the same computer without problems. Other than if you try to fly in more than one at the same time of course ;)

I personally like Flight - but then I was always a GA sort of pilot. Big iron holds no pleasure for me. Someone suggested that Flight could become a great 'GA' sim while for heavier stuff FS9/X is always there. And before anyone infers I have no insight into what aircraft may appear in Flight in the future.

We have re-established lines of communication with these folks and they appear willing. However there is a need to build some trust after the wholesale breaking of the beta NDA (sorry to bring that acronym up again).
 
As an aside, NDA's are not new at all, and quite standard. Almost all large employers have them

They exist all over. We have all sworn our friends and relations to secrecy of some thing or another. Although there is nothing written down the folks on the ADE Dev team do not publicly post about what we are working on for upcoming releases etc ;)
 
quote " Gera - my sense of humor failure may be the result of too much information, too much beer, too much flying or not enough sleep!"

That's all right Jon...They say that Belgian Beer really kicks you after its sweet taste...information, too much of it is a bore!!! ..not sleeping can have a lots of ways and means 1) if you had fun, who cares!!! 2) if you din't have fun--get to bed man!!!..and Flying is the best medicine in the whole wide world!!!!!:p...Enjoy Florida.
 
I personally like Flight - but then I was always a GA sort of pilot. Someone suggested that Flight could become a great 'GA' sim while for heavier stuff FS9/X is always there. And before anyone infers I have no insight into what aircraft may appear in Flight in the future.

I could not agree more with you about this.
But I think most of us (not me, I prefer small GA and I love Flight) prefer big iron bird. As a scenery man, I found that the bigger airport the more sell it would be.

Flight is for flying in small GA. I found no ILS, no nav point, no VOR, DME, no ATC, no AI, no Autopilot, and a lot of "no" will come after. Even small GA need these. Microsoft took "simulator" out on purpose.

But scenery is breath taking and the small airplanes are not bad either. I love Flight but I think it could have something more than that.


I think they will release scenery base by the mission. If there is no mission in that area, no scenery will be released. The whole world is only in imagination while flying in Flight. It is out there somewhere. Simply you can get to any where else by small GA. That's why they choose Hawii which is the right place to put this game in cause it is to far to get to the rest of the world by the plane that they give us.

Who's need the whole world. So they make this for small GA and limited world to suit the plane.
This is the reason that there is no big iron bird in this game. So the gamer will be in the golden cage. If they give you 747, you will be out of their cage which is nothing out there.

However, I do love the scenery of Hawii. I think this is and introduction to the new commer and more will come after this free program. I'll keep my finger cross that the new one will be "Simulator" again.

If you love airliner and the rest of the world, please go back to FSX and FS9.
 
Last edited:
Hi Jon,

That is terrific news for Microsoft. I'm not quite sure what we as developers take away from it though.
 
Hi Jon,

That is terrific news for Microsoft. I'm not quite sure what we as developers take away from it though.

Nothing at the moment of course. If you look at the partners page here: https://microsoftflight.com/en-us/partners/ you might observe that there are no content developer partners listed. You could surmise that at this time content creation is all in-house.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top