• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

Flight

Status
Not open for further replies.
Note that the notes on the Alaska enhancement say 1.2 million square miles are covered.

Must include a lot of water because Alaska has a land area of about just a bit over half that.
 
Hi,

"Must include a lot of water"? It's my understanding that there is, in fact, another country adjoining much of Alaska. And not to go too far out on a limb, but I've heard it said that some people can even see Russia from their house.
To be a bit less frivolous, if the Aleutians were included a lot of water would have to be included.

Jim F.
 
Nothing at the moment of course. If you look at the partners page here: https://microsoftflight.com/en-us/partners/ you might observe that there are no content developer partners listed. You could surmise that at this time content creation is all in-house.

To me it would seem as if Microsoft wants to become the sole designer/developer in this franchise. Why no SDK? why all the secrecy?

I see flight as a big ripoff to all enthusiasts that for decades have been following this franchise and an interest in taking the 3rd party add on market out of business.
 
To me it would seem as if Microsoft wants to become the sole designer/developer in this franchise.

At the moment that certainly seems to be the case. Time will tell if the quality of the content they create stands up against what third party developers are producing for FS9/FSX. It is is not 'up to scratch' then folks will vote with their feet and MS will not make the return they are surely hoping for. The up coming Alaska package will be a pointer though....

Why no SDK? why all the secrecy?

For past versions of FS Microsoft did not get much share of the after market. It makes good business sense for them to tap into that.

We just do not know if there is an SDK or not. If there is then we do not know when it might be released. The public statements from them indicate that there is not likely to be such a things for a year or two.

I see flight as a big ripoff to all enthusiasts that for decades have been following this franchise and an interest in taking the 3rd party add on market out of business.

The FS9 and FSX markets are still alive and well. Also some payware developers are looking at creating add-ons for Prepar3D which is FSX and is still in development with Lockheed Martin.

I would say however that Microsoft could have handled the whole process of interaction with the community during development however ;)
 
If MS is crying because it did not do any "addons" for FS9 and FSX is of their own making. No one prohibited them from doing it, and if they had they would have had their piece of cake....bad marketing and a lousy group of managers is the reason, they can´t blame no one but themselves. Anyway if the price they have for the Hawaiian islands is an indication of their "intro" into addons, they´ll miss the boat again. Let´s see the $´s they want for "Alaska"?:twocents::twocents:
 
If MS is crying because it did not do any "addons" for FS9 and FSX is of their own making. No one prohibited them from doing it, and if they had they would have had their piece of cake....bad marketing and a lousy group of managers is the reason, they can´t blame no one but themselves. Anyway if the price they have for the Hawaiian islands is an indication of their "intro" into addons, they´ll miss the boat again. Let´s see the $´s they want for "Alaska"?:twocents::twocents:


I agree. They had plenty of chances. I wrote to them once before FSX came out and said 'why dont you come out with a new version of FS9, updated planes, etc. Just that branch of the franchise was doing well and had ample room for improvement before the redesign of the wheel, (FSX).

This is the past though. I think Aces or Microsoft Gaming have had the ability to do the same thing as us, and even better as they 'created' both the Sim and the SDK's. Just a single plane from them would have been interesting. They could have created a 'Silver Wings' themselves and had some MASSIVE fun programmed into it, things that we could never have done.




Bill
 
The public statements from them indicate that there is not likely to be such a things for a year or two.

I know you are under NDA, hopefully you know something more than us regarding this and of course you can't say. I take this as a Possible yes to a SDK in the future. ;)
 
You know what would be cool is that if MSG'g did a 'feedback and idea's' form that you could fill out for idea's for gamepack addons.

Apple do this and have went the directions of customers input and requests. iPhone, iPod, and iPad and their computer lines have come far with this little feature.

(the market knows what they want, listen to them). ;)
 
To me it would seem as if Microsoft wants to become the sole designer/developer in this franchise. Why no SDK? why all the secrecy?

I see flight as a big ripoff to all enthusiasts that for decades have been following this franchise and an interest in taking the 3rd party add on market out of business.

I think it might pay to look at it from MS point of view. For a decade plus they published a series of games (they're all games at the end of the day) that were moderately successful* and from which they basically made money on the initial sale and that was it.

Not being a charity someone looked at the business model and decided it sucked, other companies were selling add-ons for their game that cost more than the base game itself. So now they've decided to try a different tack. Will it work? Who knows, our problem is we're viewing it from the level of hard core FS enthusiasts, MS have at least realised that's not a market that's going to make them money. Seriously if you add up the members of all the flight sim forums it probably numbers in the low thousands.

The main complaint I've heard is that it doesn't cover IFR/Heavy Jets/Some aspect of flying a heavy that bores me but that's the point, the market for people who want to fly an 8 hour intercontinental sector and then fly the ILS to decision height is tiny. The market for people who want to fly below tree top height and land on the street is much bigger than hardcore FS users realise. The main question is 'is it big enough to make MS a decent profit?' Who knows, but the key word is 'decent', FSX made a profit, but for the amount of money they invested in it it was a rubbish return on investment compared to say Halo, or Office 2011.

Key point, MS isn't a charity and they don't care if you don't like them.

*By moderately successful, compare the sales of FSX to GTA III. MS wants to make money, not be loved.
 
You know what would be cool is that if MSG'g did a 'feedback and idea's' form that you could fill out for idea's for gamepack addons.

Apple do this and have went the directions of customers input and requests. iPhone, iPod, and iPad and their computer lines have come far with this little feature.

(the market knows what they want, listen to them). ;)


Not really, as Henry Ford said, 'if I'd given the market what it wanted I'd have made a faster horse'. The iPod/iPhone/iPad weren't conceived based on what the market wanted they were based on what the market didn't know they wanted.

If they paid any attention to what the customer wanted there'd be a f****g USB socket on the iPad for starters...
 
Not really, as Henry Ford said, 'if I'd given the market what it wanted I'd have made a faster horse'. The iPod/iPhone/iPad weren't conceived based on what the market wanted they were based on what the market didn't know they wanted.

If they paid any attention to what the customer wanted there'd be a f****g USB socket on the iPad for starters...

Hi Skippy,

I dont know about Ford, but with Apple, each Keynote address, Steve would always say things like 'Our customers wrote and asked that they would like 'this' and 'that' so we have now integrated this.. ' etc.

I watch Apple closely (with a magnifying glass) and I have stock in them. They intrique me. I believe they did and do listen to the people.

I just wanted to clarify that.


I have worked for ford and I was ripped off as a pro test driver. My background was bad with them. They rip off their employees and corporations (such as Land Rover / BMW). My dad was adopted from a ford family into the cool Ortis family.

I just wanted to clarify that. I still think that 'feedback' is good, but I do not know much.

Back to the subject at hand, Flight.
 
Steve would always say things like 'Our customers wrote and asked that they would like 'this' and 'that' so we have now integrated this.. ' etc.

I think you may be too trusting, he wasn't going to say, 'No one's asked for this but we're doing it anyway', or 'here are all the things people have asked for that we're not doing'.

Ultimately though market research only gets you so far because people don't tell the truth, they tell you want they think will make them sound best or for what they think they can get away with. And then you have to balance it against what you can deliver and try and make a profit.

After all no one's going to say they want to pay for add-on content for Flight, but MS can't provide it for free. At best they can get an idea of what direction to go in for future add-ons, but to be honest that's probably only worthwhile if the feedback is coming from someone who's bought some already rather than someone who's just got the base pack.
 
I think it might pay to look at it from MS point of view. For a decade plus they published a series of games (they're all games at the end of the day) that were moderately successful* and from which they basically made money on the initial sale and that was it.

Not being a charity someone looked at the business model and decided it sucked, other companies were selling add-ons for their game that cost more than the base game itself. So now they've decided to try a different tack. Will it work? Who knows, our problem is we're viewing it from the level of hard core FS enthusiasts, MS have at least realised that's not a market that's going to make them money. Seriously if you add up the members of all the flight sim forums it probably numbers in the low thousands.

The main complaint I've heard is that it doesn't cover IFR/Heavy Jets/Some aspect of flying a heavy that bores me but that's the point, the market for people who want to fly an 8 hour intercontinental sector and then fly the ILS to decision height is tiny. The market for people who want to fly below tree top height and land on the street is much bigger than hardcore FS users realise. The main question is 'is it big enough to make MS a decent profit?' Who knows, but the key word is 'decent', FSX made a profit, but for the amount of money they invested in it it was a rubbish return on investment compared to say Halo, or Office 2011.

Key point, MS isn't a charity and they don't care if you don't like them.

*By moderately successful, compare the sales of FSX to GTA III. MS wants to make money, not be loved.

I highly doubt that MS will make any profit at all in a market that till today the most sold FSX addon sold some where along 20+ thousand copies and I know of high rated scenery developers who don't even get to 2000 copies per product . if they think because they are Microsoft they will sell hundreds of thousands of copies, good luck! But they will fail. The costs associated with making their stuff are just to darn high that it will not break even.
They should stick to selling the boxes in retailers and they will be ok for the most part.
 
I highly doubt that MS will make any profit at all in a market that till today the most sold FSX addon sold some where along 20+ thousand copies and I know of high rated scenery developers who don't even get to 2000 copies per product . if they think because they are Microsoft they will sell hundreds of thousands of copies, good luck! But they will fail. The costs associated with making their stuff are just to darn high that it will not break even.
They should stick to selling the boxes in retailers and they will be ok for the most part.

I'd say you're right if they try and mimic the traditional FS add-on model, which is why I assume they've moved away from the in depth systems modelling to something that should appeal to a wider market. As to whether the less procedural mission style gameplay they've focused on allows them to develop a profitable payware market remains to be seen.
I'm guessing the previous business model wasn't making a big enough pay off for the investment they made so they wanted to try something else.
 
I'd say you're right if they try and mimic the traditional FS add-on model, which is why I assume they've moved away from the in depth systems modelling to something that should appeal to a wider market. As to whether the less procedural mission style gameplay they've focused on allows them to develop a profitable payware market remains to be seen.
I'm guessing the previous business model wasn't making a big enough pay off for the investment they made so they wanted to try something else.

I bought the MS scenery addon Japan back in the FS 5 days. Well, to be honest I loved it, that's because I didn't know anything better. Nowadays you have dozens of developers doing work that is astonishing to say the least and in levels of reality breaks any barrier MS might want to put in some day. To put in the level of detail, specialization and love for something, sometimes money is not what you are looking forward to. MS is a profit making machine and their intent will be making a huge profit, if they dedicate too much time into something their costs will go up, I doubt that they will work on stuff so hard that at the end of the day their profit margin can be in the positives... lets wait and see.
There are 30+ thousands airports in the world, hundreds of aircraft variants and I am sure that not even working straight for 10 years will allow them to make a decent effort enough to say that no 3rd party developers are needed any more. they can't and they wont.

If people (like me) went out and bought their stock product, was because of the chance in having an unlimited world was in my finger tips. Now, I will be limited to an area...

In the mean time, in the next 5 years I see myself still using FSX.
 
Once all of these legal stuff will be judged one could take any decision.
Beeing honest: Flight is not the platform an independend developer should work on, spend his ideas to.
Because
a) enduser price will be to expensive
b) undefined license fees
c) who is owner of any object, who owns the copyright of any object, even if you would buy a dev license?
Just a waste of time if you read the legal stuff as of known today.
 
Nice reading here! Let me add my 2cents.

So we are faced with new marketing politics from MS... We (3rd part developers) were loved before (with FSX) and not on board at all now (with Flight)... So what every of us is planning to do ? My own most income was selling add-ons for FSX... now no sales at all.
Foggy perspectives for Flight SDK - it's just busyness nothing personal, but we must understand that if they did free platform, they expect to make money on add-ons their own or via own store in best case for us.
 
If people (like me) went out and bought their stock product, was because of the chance in having an unlimited world was in my finger tips. Now, I will be limited to an area...

That's the thing, I think someone decided that people like us just aren't a market it's worth going for. As to whether the market they've gone for is worth it only time will tell, I just think we're too invested in the old system to really take an objective view.
 
One thing to bear in mind is that Flight is likely to be as extensible under the hood as the FSn series. How, where, when (if ever) that extensibility gets used/exposed is up to MS. I sense they are going to take their time - and it could be a long time or short (for the avoidance of doubt I absolutely do not know).

There is no doubt in my mind that they are aiming at a new audience. I would like to think that this is not the out and out gamers - shoot to kill. It is though about getting a new group of folks interested in Flight Simulation and flying. It is, I surmise, about bringing new blood and new users into the broader simulated flying world. I suspect that overall that many users of the current flight sim community fall into the 'Baby Boomer' age group. If the community is not renewed then it dies out over time. Flight in its current form is not going to appeal to the FS9/FSX long time users who have gotten over the leraning curve and who want AI, ATC, heavy jets and so on. As far as I can tell it was not intended to.

However in the context of FS Developers Flight is a closed environment unless/until Microsoft decide to open it.
 
That's a very good summary, Jon

My observation is however, that the Microsoft has treated its early developer liaisons with absolute contempt, spurred on largely by self-interest.

There WAS the promise of 3rd party development, and an SDK. That was revoked, with almost no warning.

They will need to treat prospective developers with more respect if they want them to get on board and develop things down the track.

Developers would be wise to ensure that they understand exactly what their rights are, and how they sit if developing closed DLC for Microsoft.

Microsoft have shown (both generally and specifically) a tendency to put their own interests well above any others.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top