• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

FS enthusiasm down?

Messages
187
Country
us-florida
I have noted during these past years a sudden drop in enthusiasm for anything related to FS. FSX hasn't had the same sucess as FS2004 in terms of people using it, sales for payware addons have dropped significantly (compared to years 2003-2007) perhaps due to piracy, but pirates never purchased anything... even with freeware, the amounts of downloads have diminished significantly.

is it me only who has noticed this? if not why is this happing in an era of great scenery, aircraft and other addons that enhance significantly the FS world.:confused:
 
I can't speak for the entire community but I think its because they want to spend their money on more useful things. Don't get me wrong 30 dollars for a nice looking scenery is not bad, I would go ahead and jump on it, but for some people maybe they have better things to grab onto such as child support? Kidding, maybe gas money?

Edit: Fly Tampa might realize this, because they just made MDW for FSX and it requires your old MDW key I believe.

Thoughts anyone?
 
Last edited:
Hi,

I don't do commercial addons, but if I look to things like activity of this community I don't feel there is a big decline. There are still many people interested in making things.

I think there is a decline in new freeware addons, but that is mainly caused by the fact that making addons for FSX has become more complex. You need much more knowledge to be able to make an addon for FSX than for previous versions. Also the expected quality is much higher nowadays, so that makes it harder to people to start making addons.
 
I am not sure I see much of a decline either. I think when MS closed ACES there was some downturn since people thought maybe this was the end of the road. However with Flight in the wings interest seems to be picking up. I agree with Arno that FSX is more complex to work with and has not been a 'good' version for FS. FS9 is so there is still a big following for that and we should hope that Flight will also be a good version.
 
I am not sure I see much of a decline either. I think when MS closed ACES there was some downturn since people thought maybe this was the end of the road. However with Flight in the wings interest seems to be picking up. I agree with Arno that FSX is more complex to work with and has not been a 'good' version for FS. FS9 is so there is still a big following for that and we should hope that Flight will also be a good version.

I can't agree FSX is not a 'good' version of FS, the graphics and details that FSX has are the best I have ever seen. You are right it is a bit more complex to develop, but what I have seen is as you say, a huge following for FS9 still, even so if is more than 8 years since that sim was released.

Is there anyway to know the actual population of the real fanbase of FS? is it above 10 thousand? by real fanbase I mean those who purchase, download and remain active in the community.
 
Hi,

I would also not say that "FSX is not good", on many points it has improved on FS2004 a lot. Unfortunately not on all points that we hoped, but still it is the only version I develop for at the moment.

I guess it will be hard to determine the real fanbase. But for sure it is more than 10000. I would say a few hundred thousand.
 
If one considers what can be achieved wihtin FSX, by developers like ORBX and many others, then I d certainly think that FSX is NOT a bad version.

Of course, there is always the major performance issue....:p
 
I think customers decide on the equipment involved (e.q. costs).
Thats the reason for FS9 still in Place.
Win 7 might short cut that costs.
Under the line: Yes for the advanced users of FSX there is a benefit, but only if you can afford the necessary hardware. If you simply do not dare to think about that you might stick with FS9.
Obviously it is a matter of fact, that you will need a much more comprehensive environment to get the FSX benefits.
Are there benefits, yes.
But customers need to pay the involved advantages in advance.
If they can afford that in the numbers than yesterday or even if they dare to think about any hobby: I would say NO.
 
Arno, good for you man, if you can go with out commercial add-ons. I must have spent TONS over the years on it.

I can't see how any body CAN'T these days with out wanting to liven up their FSX experience.

Especially with the new technology for scenery, aircraft, etc, there's more accurate choices than ever for it.

I know I for one, get in the hum-drum state of mind sometime, but I'm pushing my efforts on developing now for FSX and also doing 3D Model Cars and Aircraft when I don't feel like flying, to keep me occupied.

I still very much love Flight Sim, and am quite enthusiastic over it, since it's the closest I can come to real world flight.
 
Hi,

Hope you do not mind my voicing perception of things.
FSX buyers count much more than 100.000, I guess.
But what are they doing with FSX, that is the question.
In my experience and what I hear from friends that I try to convince to try the 'game' (which they think it is and nothing more than that,) is that :
- either they find the threshhold too high to be able to enjoy the game (too complicated and they try a couple of times more and then they quit);
- or their hardware is not up to it and quit;
- or they get bored because they cannot shoot down some other craft and quit;
- or when they have played it a couple of times they get bored with it in general as they would with any other kind of 'game' and quit;
- or when they do enjoy it, they want to enhance their experience and find the enhancements too difficult to implement and quit;
- or when they manage to add some addons, their skills/time/ interest are not sufficient to use the extra development programs available and quit;
- or else they stumble on some FSX shortcomings and decide to quit and find some easier alternative.
That could leave one out of ten actively interested (= 10,000?).
And one out of ten or maybe a hundred will continue to be interested and try using the extra programs available (nine out of ten will quit=1000?) and one out of ten will master these programs (nine out of ten will not and quit=100?) and one out of these ten will have the knowledge and the interest to develop these programs for all of us(=10?).
Now, and forgive me if my calculations are wrong, I guess we have some developers (developing programs) counting one hundred at the most.
And that would mean, we have at least one million that have bought the product.
Amazing that there is still some interest in FSX!!!
I am afraid scientifically this is not OK and a lot of parameters are not included but in my guts I feel one million or more is the right figure.
The price of FSX is somewhat 70 USD in general (times one million = 70 million) and you can guess why MS is trying to develop a product that earns more money.
Sure hope my poor calculations are wrong but it is intriguing.
 
Hello,...

Roby is probably right in the reasons that he gave... and yes your probably right that there is a decline in purchases,... but the past 4 to 5 yrs have also been the worst in all sales of software that are titled as "games" also. Yes the ecomony could also be a reason...

I also agree that Jon and Arno is right too,.. there is a diiference in creating scenery etc for FSX and is a little more complex then 2004. I think the most generalized reason is time and money. I'm sure when things get better for the generalized public (world) so will FS,.... I'm not holding my breath though on Flight until it actually comes out,... I, for one, don't follow assumations or gossip,... the only people that can answer any questions considering Flight is MS,... and they aren't talking,... Yet (only pieces of video, to tease the "dogs" with,... (no one was meant to be harm by any or similarities there of,... or dogs for that matter). :D
 
I have heard a few people ask about the future of flightsim. My opinion is that FSX is extremely powerful and most users simply lack the computing power to tap its true potential. I think in a few years when computing power catches up FSX would be made to look photoreal in all aspects. When we can crank our sliders up to 100% and still have spare power, then we can make models that are super realystic, which will include humans and traffic and all sorts. I could be wrong but thats my two cents.

Regarding Flight. I could be wrong on this so please dont barrage me with comments, but I believe it is being made to implement MS Live which will include xbox. An xbox doesnt have the power to run a sim like FSX so I think its going to be quite gamey. I believe they have stripped away many sim variables in order to add the graphical bling that gamers want but im not worried becuase like I stated previously FSX is king and merely requires MORE POWER GRUNT GRUNT!!
 
Last edited:
l love your mathematics Roby , but what worries me is that FSX deLux sells for 27 euros , at least here , and that probably means something .
 
Regarding Flight. I could be wrong on this so please dont barrage me with comments, but I believe it is being made to implement MS Live which will include xbox.

No barrage from me, simply one salvo of 73,324 multi-drive missles, with 56 gigaton, bomb-pumped laser heads... :duck:

"MS Flight" will have absolutely nothing to do with X-Box. Period. You can take that to the bank.

I call everyone's attention to this statement directly from the horse's mouth:

For continual updates over time and to view a teaser of the future of Flight on the Windows PC*...
http://www.microsoft.com/games/flight/#news1

*NOTA BENE: emphasis mine
 
Hi,

Hope you do not mind my voicing perception of things.
FSX buyers count much more than 100.000, I guess.
But what are they doing with FSX, that is the question.
In my experience and what I hear from friends that I try to convince to try the 'game' (which they think it is and nothing more than that,) is that :
- either they find the threshhold too high to be able to enjoy the game (too complicated and they try a couple of times more and then they quit);
- or their hardware is not up to it and quit;
- or they get bored because they cannot shoot down some other craft and quit;
- or when they have played it a couple of times they get bored with it in general as they would with any other kind of 'game' and quit;
- or when they do enjoy it, they want to enhance their experience and find the enhancements too difficult to implement and quit;
- or when they manage to add some addons, their skills/time/ interest are not sufficient to use the extra development programs available and quit;
- or else they stumble on some FSX shortcomings and decide to quit and find some easier alternative.
That could leave one out of ten actively interested (= 10,000?).
And one out of ten or maybe a hundred will continue to be interested and try using the extra programs available (nine out of ten will quit=1000?) and one out of ten will master these programs (nine out of ten will not and quit=100?) and one out of these ten will have the knowledge and the interest to develop these programs for all of us(=10?).
Now, and forgive me if my calculations are wrong, I guess we have some developers (developing programs) counting one hundred at the most.
And that would mean, we have at least one million that have bought the product.
Amazing that there is still some interest in FSX!!!
I am afraid scientifically this is not OK and a lot of parameters are not included but in my guts I feel one million or more is the right figure.
The price of FSX is somewhat 70 USD in general (times one million = 70 million) and you can guess why MS is trying to develop a product that earns more money.
Sure hope my poor calculations are wrong but it is intriguing.

Just so I don't get your hopes down, the figure of people that actually buy for FSX is something in the lower 25 thousand.

Know the info from inside, one of the most sold products for FSX, can't say which one or in what store, but its under 25 thousand copies.

Can't say any more.
 
Fair enough Bill L. Do u reckon it will have the same funtionality as FSX regarding sim variables? Do you agree with me that FSX has much untapped potential due to lack of pc power?
 
Fair enough Bill L. Do u reckon it will have the same funtionality as FSX regarding sim variables? Do you agree with me that FSX has much untapped potential due to lack of pc power?

Yes and yes. Each generation of new processors has brought more capability to expand and extend performance of FSX.

Likewise, the base cost of higher end hardware continues to drop as newer generations of processors are released.

Just now Tiger Direct has this on sale for $899.99

Gateway FX6850-51u PT.GBN02.012 Desktop PC - Intel Core i7-2600 3.4GHz, 8GB DDR3, 1TB HDD, NVIDIA GeForce GT440, DVDRW, Windows 7 Home Premium 64-bit

This is one HOT machine for the price! Too bad it's not available outside the U.S.
 
LOL! Well,.. at least MS admits they are teasers,... though nothing tangible. :D
 
Quote
the figure of people that actually buy for FSX is something in the lower 25 thousand
unquote
Buy (addons) for FSX or bought FSX?
More arithmetics :D: difficult to imagine I am so unique as to be one out of every 280,000 earthlings to have bought FSX!:).
 
Back
Top