• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

FSX/mdl Strange behavior

Messages
32
Country
denmark
At last I have learned to make a .mdl file from 3ds Max X file, all over to FSX. I have mentioned it in an earlier post.

I don't know what you say in english, but the trees isn't growing all the way into Heaven, or Rome wasn't build in one day......! The same is for me with the .mdl files.

What I do, then I want to see a model I am working with is, I use an already made aircraft, and replace the .mdl with the new one I have made by my self. Isn't it how you are working as Well?

Here comes my problem. It looks like it isn't use the new .mdl but use the old one, like it can remember it. Yes I know it sounds strange, but it is true. I have now used hours, and can't figure it out. If you don't understand that I mean, I will here try to explain it:

Let's say I'm working with an P47.mdl and the model shows fine in FSX. Now I make some changes - compile it again, replace it, but it is still the first model which is shown in FSX. First I thought I forgot something in the compiling and copying, but no. I do restart FSX, so it isn't therefore. That I can do with succes, but a little depressing, is to move or delete the P47.mdl file, start FSX, then try to select the aircraft and then FSX will crash. Move or copy the P47.mdl file back again, restart FSX, and wupti the "new" P47 model is shown.

Is that behavior normal, or....?


Regards

Henrik
 
Henrik,

Make sure your 'model.cfg' is setup for your new model name.

You can use the old model name in the folder you are using.

The name in the 'model.cfg' file must be the same as your new model. And... you can use the same model file for both exterior and interior, till you are ready to have separate interior/exterior models.


I always copy the folder of another plane (to start a new project) and then change everything for the new name system. You will need to rename the airfile as well to match the plane name. But that's for when you are ready to start creating new airplane folders. Lets get you going on this first.
 
Henrik,

Make sure your 'model.cfg' is setup for your new model name.

You can use the old model name in the folder you are using.

The name in the 'model.cfg' file must be the same as your new model. And... you can use the same model file for both exterior and interior, till you are ready to have separate interior/exterior models.

I'm sure I use the same name as in the model.cfg.
 
I'm now in a stage, where I don't know if I shall drop my computer from the 50th floor and be a member in a boxing club, just to get rid of my frustration.:banghead::banghead::banghead: By the way, we don't have such high buildings in Denmark :)

To get a little succes, (and then I can build more and more on), I tried to make a simple box. Made no texture, just a box. Then made a GUID and friendly name, export it in a .X format. Then I ran XTOMDL.exe from a .bat file Lionhearts was so kind to show me. Copied and renamed the .mdl file it gave me to my *aircraft*/model folder.

Then I open FSX, find the right aircraft from the list, select it, FSX write "visual model could not be displayed". :mad:

I have compiled the oilrig, which followed the Prepar3D SDK, done the exact same as above, and here I had great succes.

I have attached the .mdl, and if someone can use it. I can't attach the log file, so here it is:

Found dictionary file: ..\..\bin\modeldef.xml
OutputFile: testx.MDL
Output file after modification: testx.MDL
Creating output MDL file: testx.MDL
CRASHTREE no granularity specified
CRASHTREE completed in 00:00:00.0060003

If someone is thinking that it is because he is using 3DS Max 2012 x64 and Prepar3d SDK, then I can say that I have tried it in Prepar3d as well. It is exactly the same problem.

Please help me...!!!!

Regards

Henrik
 

Attachments

It needs to have a texture.

I have now tried to give my simple box a standard texture. Still the same problem.:(

I have just tried with a simple 512x512 .bmp file. I haven't tried with a .DDS file. Is that the problem?


The more and more frustrated Dane

Henrik
 
Succes! Succes!

I won! What a fight:)

I found the issue which have spoiled my sleep the last few days. For some of you guys, it is maybe logic, but for me it wasn't.:o I have been trying so many combinations of that could be wrong, and with advices from all you, it drived me crazy:banghead:

What I did!!! I have been modeling a little in Gmax and FS2004 without this problems, using Milton Shupe's standard aircraft folder, from his C162 tutorial. I have always used his aircraft folder as a beginning, and it have worked fine with Gmax and FS2004. I'm not an expert, but there must be something in that folder, FSX doesn't like.

What I did was downloading an aircraft which I knew was a pure FSX aircraft. Then I used that aircraft/model folder and there was succes from the beginning. What a victory:):) I must have stared me blind.

It needs to have a texture.

It isn't true, I compiled fine with and without texture.

Thank you for watching my fight;)

Best regards

Henrik
 
It seems to work for me.

Model.cfg:

[models]
normal=BoxAircraft

Texture:

BOX.dds

Preview:



Take off:



Flying:

 
Hi,

Much of this behavior can often be attributed to having FSX installed in a Program Files folder, on an OS later than XP. MS decided that they should enforce their rule that no files be changed in a Program Files folder, once the original application is installed.

Well, FS doesn't follow these rules (especially when we update things ourselves), and *sometimes* it "locks" a folder or folders and won't let updates occur - it still uses the old version of the modified files. Sometimes this results in addon liveries not showing up in the sim, sometimes any modified files are not displayed (but sometimes the old one is).

And yes, it happens to many people that think they are full administrators but are really not - that requires special techniques.

It also appears that it only happens with certain files and folders, and not others. So that's probably why it started working when you switched to a different folder.

The usual solution is to move FSX to a folder outside of any Program Files folders.
 
Congrats again!

Feels great to finally get a object in FS. I remember the first time it worked for me. I was in FSDS and nothing would export, but I kept on making my plane. I got a new computer and moved everything over to it, one day exported the plane and it worked!!! My graphics card on the original computer didn't work with FSDS. Great when things finally work.
 
Back
Top