• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

GMAX over 3DSMAX

Messages
187
Country
us-florida
Hello colleagues,

I really like Orbx, and what they do is awesome work better than anyone out there no doubt.

they have recently released Brisbane scenery which looks astounding. however coming accross their details of the scenery I happen to look at this:

done with 3DStudioMax, which allows plenty of innovation over Gmax methods

as a developer who works with GMAX for many years I find myself now in a point on which I am somewhat 'outdated in innovation'. why would fellow colleagues utilize such language towards other simmers who most of which don't know anything about design and what they hope to do is sound fancy (aside from their prices) so that their scenery is better? when those screen shots and videos look mighty awesome?

did they use the FS2002 SDK for their ground polygons? probably, why didn't they say that too? and make the rest of us look 'behind'.

is just silly.:rolleyes:
 
IMHO - What makes a scenery out standing is the quality of the textures, regardless what program you used to create it. True 3DSMAX has some improved tools one can use, but if you are inventive enough, the end result is still the same.

Looking at some of the models fellow members of the forum have produced is a clear indication that GMAX is a powerful tool in it's own right.

David
 
I recall seeing something on the Orbx forum, sorry, didn't bookmark it. I got the impression that they used fully rendered models to generate shadows which are then baked into the textures, including night maps. This would certainly be tricky to do in GMAX:)

You'll notice from official Orbx screenshots that they turn off FSX shadows, and this is a recommended setting. Their models all include shading, either as part of the textures or objects sit on a softly-shaded plane.

That's probably why you only ever see those beautifully moody shots of Orbx airports, because in sunlight the shadows still stay soft.

Don't be too offending by the marketing hype, the work they do is fantastic, but marketing is marketing, after all. I'm sure that the people who actually do the work didn't come up with this sales pitch. I think that the same marketing guys turned a patch into an 'innovation' by giving it a fancy name -- developers would never think of that...

As far as GMAX vs 3DS is concerned, I'd love to be able to afford 3DS.

A few years ago I was working away modelling a stairway for a terminal, and a friend who worked professionally in 3D thought it was funny that I was building it by 'hand' so to speak. He showed me a 3DS tool which built stairs of just about any specification in seconds:)

I'm not too sure how the FS2002 gamepack figures with Orbx, but I think that Bill Womack who built Twin Oaks (now that micro-mesh is a real innovation) used it. I have no idea about Brisbane.
 
To get some nice "baked" textures without 3dsmax you could model your model in Gmax then export it to Blender where you render it and save the rendered textures to be used in your model. (This way is FREE)
 
Last edited:
I'm not too sure how the FS2002 gamepack figures with Orbx, but I think that Bill Womack who built Twin Oaks (now that micro-mesh is a real innovation) used it. I have no idea about Brisbane.

I am sure they did use the FS2002 gamepack for ground polygons. I don't know how else can you do them? no one else has come up with a method to do in FSX, AFAIK.
 
If you want to go to 3DS Max, you will find it impossible. You need Max-7 through Max-9 or Max-2008. You cannot use Max 2010. It will not recognise the 'FSX SDK Max' tools. (It will not work nor be able to export model files).

Autodesk refuses to sell previous editions of Max. (Tells you something about their marketing expertise).

If you can, find it on Ebay, like an unopened box, non-student edition, not an upgrade, but the full version. If you can find it there, you are good to go.


Moving from Gmax to Max is a jump. I am doing it now, making a plane in Max for the first time, and its a chore learning all the new hiding places for settings. But, its almost the same as Gmax. I am changing alot of the quick-keyboard shortcuts to work like Gmax. The 'rendering' part is nice, but I found it wasnt as nice as I had thought. I still redid the renders moderately in Photoshop. I thought they would be more better. I could be just missing some settings in the Render sections though.



Bill
 
Ah Bill! The Renderer in Max is hugely configurable, not to mention complicated!

One could spend a full year just learning how to set up the lights and camera, not to mention all of the truly huge selections of "camera lenses" and output sizes!

Such as 35mm Anamorphic (2.35:1) at 4096x1743 pixels, ActiveShade!

Here is an ActiveShade render using 35mm Anamorphic (2.35:1 Squeezed) at 1024x871 pixels (no lights set up though).

gns48001.jpg
 
As one of the devs for YBBN, my first major airport YMML was largely made with GMAX.

I moved to Max when started on YBBN, initially because my partner in crime Russ White, already had Max along with many years doing 3D modelling and design. He is truley a master.

Anyway, the reality of the difficulty of two developers working on the same project but with different tools was just too hard.

But having completed an entire project with Max, i could never go back to Gmax now. While yes its true that you can achieve the same results with Gmax. Max is just way more intuative in many areas, so its easier to achieve the desired result.

One important part of Max is that you can visualize the model in full resolution textures. So its much easier to know what you will get when you export.

UVW mapping is far more accurate in Max also, and there a few extra tools here that make for easier mapping.

Also the Aces SDK tools work better in Max, than Gmax.

The reason i ended up using FS2002 ground polys is because its a proven design method. I made YMML with a fully functioning FSX ground poly, but due to the need to heavily LOD the plane to get it to lift off the ground to stop flicker led to many support issues. So in essense i took the easy way.

I prefer my FSX ground poly as the detail mapping etc look better as is overall perfoemance. But from a commerial sense i could not afford the time to keep developing it considering the scale of the project.

I do want to have another go with YMML V2, where i will take everything i have learned from YBBN and apply it where i can.

So the in no way do i imply that gmax devs are inferior, the reality is most of the guys in Orbx use Gmax, but it just Max has more to offer a developer as a whole, and i just find it easier to use.

Is there marketing hype in Orbx, sure, but thats for the customers. We know devs can work that out.

But what really makes us is the team work. We have been been bugging each other for many years now and VOZ was our training ground.
We really like to push the boundries in Orbx and within our team we push each other like mad. One guy will come up with something cool, and the rest of us are like, Wow how'd you do that? That is what makes the end result, the tools just help you get there.
 
Hi,

Thanks for the answer. For most features you will see that the exporter is the limitation, not the tool itself. Even GMax can do much more than the exporter supports. Having never worked with 3DS Max, I can't comment on those things, but I believe something might be easier in it.

About the ground polygons. Once I start working on that for my next project (when I will continue on the gPoly tool) I would like to give it a try to make them with the FSX SDK. I think it would require that the tool calculates the curvation of the earth for you.

That's exactly what I like, try to push the limits in FS a little bit further :).
 
Is there marketing hype in Orbx, sure, but thats for the customers. We know devs can work that out.

.

Thanks, but there ins't anything wrong with being great and as you folks been awesome, just that for the rest of us who do not use 3DSMAX we do a great job, certainly with max you are pushing the limits which is excellent. The only thing is why market that to customers who maybe more than 90% haven't any idea of what is GMAX much less of 3DSMAX. then customers will ask and demand us to use the same techniques as you do (which is fair if we are selling this) but you are setting a precedent to all of us by stating that 3DS MAX is superior to GMAX to people who haven't any clue about developing for FS.

Great job and I congratulate you on your work, but try to keep it fair for the rest of us on what you state to other simmers out there.
 
The only thing is why market that to customers who maybe more than 90% haven't any idea of what is GMAX much less of 3DSMAX. then customers will ask and demand us to use the same techniques as you do (which is fair if we are selling this) but you are setting a precedent to all of us by stating that 3DS MAX is superior to GMAX to people who haven't any clue about developing for FS.

We have seen that before in the past when GMax was just released for FS2002?. How many users did not think everything made with SCASM was bad and everything made with GMax was good? While you can make an identical BGL file with both.
 
I think the 3DSMax / Gmax information is already out there amongst consumers ... mainly courtesy of some of the Add-on aircraft developers, who have trumpeted their updated models as being 3DSMax developed.

Speaking as a Gmax user ... 3DSMax does have some significant benefits ...

and one (quite significant) drawback.
 
We have seen that before in the past when GMax was just released for FS2002?. How many users did not think everything made with SCASM was bad and everything made with GMax was good? While you can make an identical BGL file with both.

Quite right, but the differences between working with SCASM and GMAX at that time was quite extraordinary. Performance and the modeling was completely different and people noted that quite significantly.

Whereas when working with GMAX vs 3DSmax, basically the developer will the only one noting the difference, so for the consumer what would the difference be as much? basically you will have to tell them in a users manual or in this case in a product page that things are much better because 3DSmax.

by the way, I think is totally legitimate to do that, if you are doing different than others go ahead and promote it but come on lets think here Orbx is already the best out there, no need to use such fancy words. Just my 2 cents.
:confused:
 
Quite right, but the differences between working with SCASM and GMAX at that time was quite extraordinary. Performance and the modeling was completely different and people noted that quite significantly.

But if the developer used the right SCASM code he could get the same performance as with GMax. But people would still think it is bad, because SCASM made it. That's the same kind of misinformation going into the community and of course the users can never verify if it is really true.

Getting good products depends more on the developer and his effort, than on the tools used. With enough knowledges the tools don't matter that much.
 
Getting good products depends more on the developer and his effort, than on the tools used. With enough knowledges the tools don't matter that much.

Quite so, Arno! It is the skills of the artist that determines the final result, not the tool(s) used.

One need only consider the art of woodworking. No expensive machine can ever reproduce the "artistry" of a master craftsman's hand work with primitive tools.
 
But if the developer used the right SCASM code he could get the same performance as with GMax. But people would still think it is bad, because SCASM made it. That's the same kind of misinformation going into the community and of course the users can never verify if it is really true.

Getting good products depends more on the developer and his effort, than on the tools used. With enough knowledges the tools don't matter that much.

You are quite right. Until recently something like that happened Flytampa released KBOS a few months ago and in their product page they stated: "Not using old SCASM code for performance". One user in their forum commented that its misleading and that of course they are also using SCASM code for their ground polygons, the people at FT acknowledged that and removed that from their product page, those things are confusing for consumers, they know not much about designing, they needn't hear developer language. I think.

Companies such as Orbx and FT needn't that type of language to sell their products they sell very well, and orbx now with that comment is setting the precedent that Gmax is not too 'innovative' that is a trend that will now continue. :(
 
Quite amazing that some of you can get so concerned over a marketing phrase. I'd suggest anyone who is concerned simply take out virtual sissors and clip the link in your brain between that marketing schtick and your world. Just clip it, and ignore it. Viola! Everything is ok again!
 
I agree with Bob5568.

You cant tell others what they can and cant say on their sales pitches. Thats not right.

For instance, you could state that yours is 'Built by the incredible Gmax' and now all the FSDS guys can come after you saying 'hey! thats not right. You make us look bad!'.

You need to be able to deal with your own market and not worry about others. Some incredible payware out there is created with FSDS, and the work looks better then Max work. Its the artist, not the brush, that makes masterpieces.

Thats my humble two cents.

On a side note, you could state that your creations are made with the infamouse Gmax, a sister product of the famous movie industry version called 3DS Max. (G-max or gMax is the 'gaming' version of Max, basically a base version of 3DS Max 6).

Dont worry what others are saying about their products. Be more concerned with what you are saying about yours.. Put in some cool lingo of your own. Dont even mention what yours is created with if you think it might demean your product lines. Just remember those talented souls putting out amazing work with FSDS, Blender, Lightwave (the Victory hull was created in LW), and other such 3D design engines...



Bill
 
For instance, you could state that yours is 'Built by the incredible Gmax' and now all the FSDS guys can come after you saying 'hey! thats not right. You make us look bad!'.

Bill

It's okay, Bill, FSDS users aren't insecure souls. We don't mind others using hardcore modelling programs.
 
It's okay, Bill, FSDS users aren't insecure souls. We don't mind others using hardcore modelling programs.

:o


I had never thought of someone being embarrassed publically of using Gmax. One heck of a sophisticated 3D design engine, very state of the art, even today. I used FSDS to point out that people proudly voice their use of FSDS in their creations.

I salute you guys that use FSDS. You are hard working, talented souls.

:D
 
Back
Top