• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

I hate Gmax!

Heretic

Resource contributor
Messages
6,830
Country
germany
I just lost an hour of very hard work because of this [censored] piece of [censored] software!

"Can't write to file!"
- "Okay, I'll just do a 'Save As...'"
Saves okay at first, but then throws another [censored] "Can't write to file!" error!
- "F[censored] you too, you geriatric piece of C++-coded stupidity!"

Try to open any of the last two saves and..."File Open Failed". "I'LL GIVE YOU AN "OPEN FAILED" ERROR, YOU TOASTERLOVING BUGFEST!"

Not to mention the constant [censored] crashing right out of the blue. Sometimes spitting out an error, sometimes it doesn't even bother to do that!


If you're just taking up modeling for MSFS: FORGET ABOUT GMAX!
Use a proper tool, like Blender and leave this bag of errors and instability where it belongs - in the virtual graveyard!


*Angrily shoots kitten*
YOU SEE WHAT HAPPENS WHEN I'M ANGRY, GMAX?! YOU SEE THAT?!
 
I think we knew you don't like Gmax... and until recently Blender just wasn't an option. But don't you have automatic backups set? Mine does an auto-save every three minutes or so.
 
I think we knew you don't like Gmax...

I was looking for an old thread but couldn't find one. :oops:

and until recently Blender just wasn't an option.

It fortunately is now. The problem, however, lies in converting old (g)max projects for it.

But don't you have automatic backups set? Mine does an auto-save every three minutes or so.

Mine every five. A failure to understand that backup files are saved as *.ax files or so and NOT "..._recover.gmax" has led me into thinking that the backup function had utterly failed me.



If you're into shooting kittens poor things. they need replacing here-
https://it-it.facebook.com/pages/Gattile-di-Cuneo/272204872843246

Don't worry, I couldn't harm one of these little, fluffy balls of innocent hate. It's just a figure of speech to indicate Hulk-levels of rage. :)




I'm basically back from where I've started. Next stop maybe:
http://www.fsdeveloper.com/forum/threads/exporting-from-gmax-to-3ds-max-with-ffg-a-new-tool.425397/
 
Did you open file "Autobak*.gx"? It is in the folder gmax/Augoback. You need to change open file to "any file" (not only gmax file) and you will see the recent backup in there.
 
No, did not do that as I didn't know that backups were *.gx files.

It's too late anyway.
 
You are not alone Heretic. I lost all of my complex entrance to VTBS terminal before I knew how to retrieve from the crash. I did that model 3 times from scratch!
 
Windows shadow copies saved me a few times with corrupt files. A usb drive with backup enabled - quite useful.

Glad you're back to square.

Oh ... And that filenumber appending thing, but I'm sure you do that anyway.
 
You are not alone Heretic. I lost all of my complex entrance to VTBS terminal before I knew how to retrieve from the crash. I did that model 3 times from scratch!

Wow.



Glad you're back to square.

Thanks to FFG, I have the model in Max 9 now. Save for the well known crash related to the Material Editor, it's just so much more stable.

The funny thing is that I did the entire 737 in GMax with only a fraction of hiccups. The model file for the Convair must be cursed or so.
Another odd thing is that GMax produced a 15 MB .mdl file, but a .mdl exported from Max is just about 5 MB. There were some oddities after importing the model into Max, but these just couldn't have caused such a massive discrepancy in filesize, now could they?

Oh ... And that filenumber appending thing, but I'm sure you do that anyway.

Yup, but I do it by hand.
 
I use Gmax and never lost more than 5 minutes of work. Not only do i have auto backups running but i save my projects in steps and usually end up with a history of 2 months of files to go back to by date. The auto backups come in a few file types. Just change the extention from .gx to (.GMAX) :idea:
 
I don't know what happen in Gmax but something is going on when I attach something up to a new thing or delete something out. I found that later if I use Reset X form, it seemed to be better and more stable. I don't know if it is relevant to the crash. But you can try.
 
The exterior model is still in GMax and withinthe half hour of work I've spent on it today, I got two random crashes. One was an "unknown system exception" upon right clicking and one was a simple CTD.
The funny thing is, that both crashes occurred within the first ten minutes. The remaining 20 minutes saw no hiccup whatsoever.*


Word of caution, by the way: GMax will delete its "undo" history after every save, so the shorter your save intervals, the more often you'll have to reload from an autobackup file.



*3DS Max purred along in the background during all that.
 
T
Word of caution, by the way: GMax will delete its "undo" history after every save, so the shorter your save intervals, the more often you'll have to reload from an autobackup file.

*3DS Max purred along in the background during all that.

not in my version. just tested it, made 12 changes, then saved, went back to the beginning.. Other than the occasional fatal error where it closes, Gmax has been rock solid for me.
 
Actually, I use 3dsmax2012 too and I found that it is not as stable as Gmax. May be it needs more resources for the program. When I open up a lot of reference plan using satellite photo, they turns black without texture. However some features are very useful. So I need to save frequently. Sometime the file corrupted by something and no way to recover it back. Many times that I need to shut it down and reopen to export. If I export many times after a long time using the program, it crashed. Very annoying.
 
Last edited:
3d modelling is a very large subject and many of us take years to really learn the business, never mind all the capabilities of our modelling programs. After using Gmax for the time my projects have taken I'm pretty familiar with most of the menus, if not all the modifiers, and am still amazed at how capable it is. It has areas where it's less than fully stable but these are where I take more care.

The most impressive thing is this heavyweight software is free! I can crash Photoshop, 3ds Max, MS Word if I try to do things they're not really for, but that doesn't mean I'll ditch them. Most of my early problems in Gmax were when I didn't know what I was doing or how to do it.
 
I do 'not' miss the crashes. That was grim. Save save save....

When it wasnt able to save to HD, it hit me you might have an issue with a virus that is out there called 'Recycler'. Horrible program that takes over your Registry and permissions and plants is reseeding seeds in the recycle bins. Difficult to get rid of, and the description you stated is exactly what happens. Cannot save/overwrite that file. Cannot do this. Cannot do that. You do not have permission. etc, etc... Go into Windows Safe Mode and open your recycle bin and see if there are files in folders in there with padlocks and have GUID names. If so, delete them, then reboot and see if they reappear.

In the mean time, welcome back to Max! Fewer crashes. If you can, get Max 2014 and the P3D SDK (if you are working on FSX / P3D projects). The new Poly tools, selection tools, etc, are amazing.
 
I loved Gmax...free and amazing. And....I hated the crashes also.

That's why, when I started grad school, I bought the student version of 3dsmax9, and later upgraded to a full license in a wonderful upgrade sale. Same awesome interface, much more stable. The problem for me is the tool is too interesting to remain within the confines of using fsx as the renderer, so I've branched out into a full fledged learning proces of the mental ray renderer and high poly modelling. So I don't produce much fsx stuff anymore, but I owe my pleasure with max to fsx scenery design. coffee_table.jpg color cups.jpg
 
Great renders, Bob. That is exactly what I want to do is learn to do renders better. Right now, I cant setup a good render. It would be awesome to harness that.

Sadly, everyone uses V-Ray to render with and that is another 1K or 2K USD. sigh....
 

Attachments

  • Wow1 - Copy.jpg
    Wow1 - Copy.jpg
    187.8 KB · Views: 542
  • MotorGlider 01.jpg
    MotorGlider 01.jpg
    869.5 KB · Views: 541
  • MotorGlider06.jpg
    MotorGlider06.jpg
    903.5 KB · Views: 475
Back
Top