• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

Microsoft simulators petition

Status
Not open for further replies.
Didn't think ACES were developing Flight!

They got their pink-slips after FSX, did they not?

The best 'petition' would have been for customers to buy DLC, as I'm sure this is the primary motivator.

As a developer, I have to declare my ambivalence, given there was never an open platform.


Sent with Tapatalk for iPhone
 
Flight was a project of "Firebird Studios," not "ACES," which was indeed closed down totally during the "Great Sacking of ACES" debacle.

Firebird Studios did have quite a few of the former ACES employees in its ranks, but it was a completely new and separate entity from the defunct ACES studio.

I wish folks would do some basic research before sounding the trumpet and exposing their ignorance to the world at large. Such ignorance greatly diminishes the impact of whatever action they are proposing... :(
 
Check out this website and sign the petition to bring back the simulator devlopment team.

http://www.change.org/petitions/mic...ck-the-aces-flight-simulator-development-team

It was a good thought, Cessna150.


Just a heads up, since MS was mis-handling FS and not making wise decisions concerning managing the cool Aces team, some of the team have now moved on to Prepar3D (from what I have heard, including Beatle, the code guru of FS). So if you want to enjoy some of their latest work, I emplore you to try out P3. Its awesome. (runs smooth... ;) )


Bill
 
Surely the real point is that ACES was disbanded because Microsoft decided FS11/Next wasn't commercially viable. Has anything changed to make it reverse its decision?
 
Gerry, I think the op was petitioning the closure of Firebird, but got his wires crossed.

As you say, they disbanded ACES because it was not financially viable.

The prospect of DLC seduced them into making Flight! but this too proved not as profitable as they wished it to be.

(Another personal guess) making good FS add-ons take so much time, it is not quite as cost-effective as they thought paying people by the hour.

There is a large amount of "love" that keeps the add-on market going, not cynical business interests.
 
So, you guys think Microsoft will end the development of Flight Simulator franchise for good?
Either way they tried not make so much money to their effort.
I was wondering why Microsoft don't develop their Flight Sim as FSX. Make the whole world like before and have version for developers to preview what we have done. Then when we develop addon, we have to sent back to microsoft as an Addon Store. Like the way Simmarket does. The put some process and put it on shelf for end users. They get commission.

Microsoft will be happy with what they have done. The income after that they need less effort.
Developers will be happy. They will fill out the world that Microsoft did. Fun with their job and get money too.
End user will be happy. They get what they want. Detail world, detail aircrafts, fly what they want to fly to anywhere in the Sim world.

Everyone is happy. Sorry that this is just my imagination. If Microsoft still do not listen to us, I think Flight Sim Franchise will die.
 
Last edited:
Tic,

I don't think it is as bleak as that.
Prepar3D offers an option for FS Addicts, and is still being developed. X-plane is an alternative with growing content.

I don't think it is any secret that Microsoft initially started liaising with developers to find out their work methods and tech, in what initially seemed like the collaborative effort you describe.
My interpretation of what happened next is that they got greedy and wanted to develop all the DLC themselves. I might be unfairly harsh on that, but that is my observation.

The irony is that they would have done exceptionally well with "commission" based (think: Apples Appstore) high-quality addons, and the scope of developers would have created a plethora of content to maintain interest.
Greed, and a fundamental misunderstanding of the community that is your core business. Entire civilisations have fallen for less.

I think it is a shame that any venture of this nature fails, but 500 signatures equating to 500 purchases of a DLC pack is not going to keep the studio running. Microsoft are under extreme pressure and seem to be struggling for "vision" at the moment on a corporation level.

Flightsimmers are an almost insignificant niche market. To put it in perspective, how much do you think the upcoming launch of Halo 4 will make both in Game, DLC and Xbox console sales?

FS-developers make stuff because they love aviation, the challenge of making new worlds and planes. If it was just money, they would find something else to do. Corporations make stuff to make money. No love, just business.

We are pilchards (possiblly even krill) , and they are fishing for whale-meat.
 
Last edited:
FS-developers make stuff because they love aviation, the challenge of making new worlds and planes. If it was just money, they would find something else to do. Corporations make stuff to make money. No love, just business.

HCornea


I was cooincidentally thinking of this last night.

The amount of money I invest in some of my projects is more then I get out of them. I am spurned on by the project itself rather then the funds that might be made.

Probably why I am nearly broke, lol.... I love my job. :D
 
I was cooincidentally thinking of this last night.

The amount of money I invest in some of my projects is more then I get out of them. I am spurned on by the project itself rather then the funds that might be made.

Probably why I am nearly broke, lol.... I love my job. :D

I think the same way. This is the job I love not the job that make me rich.
The way I thought is win win situation. Everyone gets what one wants. That's all.
 
Last edited:
I don't believe Microsoft will develop any sort of flight game in the forseeable future. No one in Microsoft would now even think of asking for funds to develop one now.
 
I don't believe Microsoft will develop any sort of flight game in the forseeable future. No one in Microsoft would now even think of asking for funds to develop one now.

I agree. Having cancelled the traditional flight sim development a couple of years ago (FSX); and then tried and failed with a new concept; I do not think there is anywhere left for them to go. I would go as far as to say we have seen the last one. But then what do I know and I have been wrong before and surely will be again :)
 
The ACES team was fired. Some went to P3D, others to Firebird, and a few started CGF http://www.cascadegamefoundry.com/

They were spread out. MS dropped the ball on that one.

FS was a decent over-time money maker. In 2006 fsx was #10 on top 10 list, and #9 in 2007..
FSX sold over 1million copies world-wide in its first year holiday season.
2007 figures were reportedly half that (economical slow down affected this). Albeit MS keeps the numbers locked up in a safe, Stores still reported the sales figures which are close to the figures listed here.
Problem was supply was not up to demand its first year, and when supply was replenished, the bad reviews were out (hardware based reviews). that deterred another 500,000 units being sold before the next holiday.
FS2k had the same hardware reviews but supply well exceeded demand thus more copies sold in year 1.
Since inception in 1980, MSFS has sold over 20 million copies from FS1 thru FS10. The median price adjusted for inflation is $45-$55 per copy. Over a 22 year period, thats decent profit.
Also, MSFS rarely had any advertising, unlike games that hit 25 million units in 1 year which have Chuck Norris's dark night elf as a means to gain notoriety(world of Warcraft).
Final Fantasy, Call of Duty, SOCOM, and other massively sold games advertising was heavily distributed. FS was a notch above word of mouth.
 
Last edited:
But then what do I know and I have been wrong before and surely will be again.

I'm sure that is your wife opinion!

I do not think there is anywhere left for them to go. I would go as far as to say we have seen the last one.

I have to agree. One problem a BIG company has is getting excited about small market products.

The Flight Sim business is just too small for a company as large as MS to get involved in.

On the scale of game software - it is at the very high end of development and support costs. Doing the whole world right is just too expensive.

And on the sales end - it is pretty low on the income level. The game market sells to people who want easy to 'learn', easy to play games with set goals and accomplishments. The 'arcade' market. Folks like us are a pretty small part of the market.

Not worth Microsoft's time and effort. I think the financial return curve started down after FS2000 and even though FS2004 was very good, for MS it wasn't a huge hit. FSX was steady but certainly unspectacular.

Flight would have had a future if the sales have been real strong, but obviously that did not meet minimum goals.
 
Since inception in 1980, MSFS has sold over 20 million copies from FS1 thru FS10. The median price adjusted for inflation is $45-$55 per copy. Over a 22 year period, thats decent profit.

Is it? Without knowing what the developments costs are you can't say what the level of profit is, I think if we knew what the actual profit was we'd have a much better understanding of MS decision.
 
Is it?[...]

Yes it is, as long as there was a profit! The problem is somewhere else. It is the golden calf of profit maximising.

The natural way would be like this. An apple farmer harvest 1000 apples, after all payments to helpers and paying off all costs he has 370 apples left. He needs 365 apples for food each day until the next harvest. So he has a profit of five apples. And all his neighbors will say, he is a good farmer who even is able to produce something for bad times or bad surprises. This system works for centuries.

But nowadays some so called experts are successful to sell us the wisdom that it must be 50 apples over and this has to increase from year to year. At least at a rate of 7%.

Means after ten years 100 apples more, after 20 years 200 and so on, and so on...

On the gravestone of the capitalism will once be written:

"Too much was not enough"


My two cent...

Mick!
 
Is it? Without knowing what the developments costs are you can't say what the level of profit is, I think if we knew what the actual profit was we'd have a much better understanding of MS decision.

The profit would average 30% of 45-55, not the entire 45-55 be profit. I think I left that part out.

To illustrate how I meant it: FS2004 sold 1million+ copies year 1. At 55 each copy, thats 55,000,000. 30% or 16.5mil of that was probably the profit level. 35-39% was taxes-19.25mil.
Development cost was around 6 million for fs2004 according to a MS release article in 2004. I dont know what all that includes or if it was total dev cost or just application programming minus licensing(learjet, boeing, cessna name and likeness of model licensing rights), material, or etc.

FSX dev cost was not publicly released to my knowledge.

Now take the 20million copies, by 50 each copy average, thats 1,000,000,000 in 22 years, minus est dev cost of 30% - 300,000,000 and 35-39% 350-390,000,000 taxes, leaves profit of approximately 400,000,000 -(dev cost and taxes are estimates). Thats decent over 22 years.
 
Now run the same figures for Halo, or Office, or Windows and see how it compares, because I'd guess that's what MS did and decided it wasn't worth the effort.
 
Yes it is, as long as there was a profit! The problem is somewhere else. It is the golden calf of profit maximising.

Not really, if your mythical farmer could produce 500 bananas a year for a profit of 100 bananas for the same effort wouldn't he be better off doing that? He could even work less for the same profit giving him more time for other things. Or maybe you like inefficiency and waste?
 
The profit would average 30% of 45-55, not the entire 45-55 be profit. I think I left that part out.

Now where near that.

Out of a $45-$55 price - the developer company - Microsoft - is going to get a gross of about 60%, maybe as little as 40%.

The Microsoft share will be about half of the gross you started with - before expenses and taxes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top