• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

New Flight Sim

Messages
49
Country
us-newyork
So I noticed all the bad comments about Microsoft Flight and this idea came to me. We have a bunch of great developers here and I thought if we all worked together we could make our own flight sim. Using all the base FSX files and all the developer programs for FSX we could make a pretty cool sim. If our talented people did the complicated stuff and created the airplanes and we all made a few airports we would all be able to have a say in the sim. :scratchch
 
Try making one airplane add-on, then ask this again. You have no idea what kind of work is involved to make a good sim. Look at Flight...it took them three years to put out a very visually pleasing, realistic sim/game. They have a team of like 50, plus others from other groups and companies helping them. I can't see all of us putting something better together within a reasonable amount of time, sadly.
 
So did the creator of FS.. IT was a college thesis project and his friend helped him. 2 People.


Not 30... not 50.. not 300...
 
To answer the first question on this post;

Several of us are considering this, and trying to work a strategy. Several game engines are out there that are leasable.


Present 'packages' that add on dev's have created could be 'renamed' in format, couldn't they? Then they would be different formats.
 
I dont mean this as a criticism. Far from it, but i simply dont understand what with X-plane, Aero-fly, P3D and other platforms out there, whatdraw of going through all that pain to produce for flight is about. could someone please educate me?? Ive chosen to follow P3D. Perhaps its a dead end, perhaps not ( but at least i'll stay in business?? ). Flight from my experience as a beta tester just doesnt seem to be worthwhile..
Thanks
Pam
 
Let's use Outerra game engine. I would be willing to be part of the design and modeling; not smart enough to program stuffs though :)
 
Let's use Outerra game engine. I would be willing to be part of the design and modeling; not smart enough to program stuffs though :)

Outerra treats each aircraft as a package, just as it does the sceneries I think utilizing the base Outerra engine has a lot of merit, making aircraft and especially flight models may need something else in order to get away from the up down side to side movement you would get in any old game..
 
So did the creator of FS.. IT was a college thesis project and his friend helped him. 2 People.


Not 30... not 50.. not 300...

That's true, but then compare that version of FS to FSX or FS9. I'm not saying it's not doable but to get something that's a realistic alternative to FSX is going to take a lot of work by a lot of people.

You also need a decent physics engine that provides the flight aspect, which is different to writing a flight model for someone else's engine. Although on the plus side at least there might be some decent documentation for it...
 
Try making one airplane add-on, then ask this again. You have no idea what kind of work is involved to make a good sim. Look at Flight...it took them three years to put out a very visually pleasing, realistic sim/game. They have a team of like 50, plus others from other groups and companies helping them. I can't see all of us putting something better together within a reasonable amount of time, sadly.

Visually pleasing, ok..realistic sim/game is an extension of hope!!!...realistic??, no AI, no ATC, no cars, clouds that look like pop corn in the sky!, a ding dong strip in the sky with speed and direction, hit the coins all over, the island looks as if the bubonic plague hit it, it´s dead!!!...C´mon where do you see the realism???...its just one more game.

Anyways.....I bet anyone here, that within 5 years we´ll see great things with the Lockheed babe and pretty sure a new Sim worth it´s salt. The "Flight" type of games (except the great Combat ones!!) will not appeal the "masses" to make it worth the work to maintain it....not everyone likes flying stuff, many hate it, just ask people at over populated airports all over the world!!!!...I personally hate "Real" airports fer sure!!:mad:, they are total madness, and its dangerous to be there. Flight Sims will always be for a reduce group of "Airplane lovers" like many of us, people who have aviation in their vanes or have been bitten by the "flying influenza mosquito"...trying to make "everyone like Flying with a Game is really looking for the arc of the divine cosmic wind in some Mayan water hole":D:D
 
Last edited:
:redflag: Unfortunately you have to stop before you start.

You would need to license the core files from Microsoft.

This would really only be true if the developer was trying to redistribute the files with the game. There are many open-source "community" editions of games these days that require the original game to be installed so it can use the art files from it. I haven't checked in the FSX eula to verify this, but chances are it wouldn't violate anything (I haven't found a game yet that it does).

One big hurdle would be the patents MS holds on FS. There are large parts of the sim that are covered by very vague patents. One would have to very carefully implement these parts of the sim under the guidance of a lawyer to ensure MS couldn't claim patent infringement.

So I noticed all the bad comments about Microsoft Flight and this idea came to me. We have a bunch of great developers here and I thought if we all worked together we could make our own flight sim. Using all the base FSX files and all the developer programs for FSX we could make a pretty cool sim. If our talented people did the complicated stuff and created the airplanes and we all made a few airports we would all be able to have a say in the sim. :scratchch

Trust me, there are many people in the 3rd party addon business who have considered exactly that. I'm not trying to start rumors or cause wild speculation but I guarantee you that some people on this very forum are researching the possibility of this as we speak, and might even already be implementing it.

As an aside, making a flight sim is not hard. I have "made a flight sim" already in the course of my university studies. Making a flight sim that has the highest-fidelity flight dynamics, Crysis 2 style graphics, and the extensibility to create a huge 3rd party market is what we are really talking about. As we saw with Flight, if one of those things doesn't live up to the ridiculously high standards that this community demands then it is deemed as an instant failure.

The fact of the matter is that this is a business. Most of us are thinking about this like engineers, not businessmen. Is it possible for one man to build a flight sim? Sure. Austin Meyer did it (he was the only one working on X-Plane until the most recent version, I believe). The FSX/ESP engine is roughly 1 million lines of code, as stated by the folks at LM. I am staring at a personal project of mine right now, involving high-fidelity 3d graphics, that is sitting just shy of 100,000 source lines of code as calculated by the Visual Studio code metrics. I am a student, far from being a graphics/simulation expert, who works on this in his spare time. So it is completely possible that a small team could produce a realistic sim given enough time.

Unfortunately, those developers have to feed their families somehow. Taking on such an endeavor is an extreme risk and I think that's why many projects like this fail. Sure, they can find ways of getting funding, but things like this take time and the right mix of people. These people also have to get it right. They can't be learning as they go and must make the right design decisions from the beginning. Anyone who has worked in the engineering field for some time can tell you that it is possible to do a project like this on a tight budget with a small staff if they are all-star players. This is just an extremely risky business decision, and most people who would be interested in this type of field wouldn't be willing to take such a huge financial risk.

Sorry for the rant. I guess my point is just to give it time. I guarantee you that us "simmers" have not been abandoned by any means. I think the future is bright for simulation and can't wait to see what is coming a few years on down the road.
 
Last edited:
I would be all for helping with our own sim platform, but there are considerable hurdles that are in the way. Theisomizer has done a good job of pointing these out - legal and money. There's also a workforce issue.

Who's going to write the code and (stab in the dark here) millions of lines of it?
Who's going to manage the project?
Who's going to design the planes? Texture them? Add the handling? What planes are going to be added? Are the the planes going to be PMDG or default detail?
Who's going to design all of airports and how?
Who's going to manage money? Where's that money going to come from? If this isn't volunteer, then who's going to manage paychecks?
Who's going to keep tabs on everyone?
Who's going to design the scenery?
Who's going to keep everyone communicating?

Get past those and I imagine quite a few here would be up for it. As for adding to a platform, isn't that essentially what we do now?
 
How about FlightGear, freeware open source program?
I have less experience about this program, please enlight me if you have time.
 
I posted (tongue in cheek) on another forum on this subject, setting out the steps to be followed.

Step #1 was agree the specification.
 
Hi,

As many above me, I agree that it is probably not so realistic.

Look at FlightGear. That project is running for about 15 years now, using volunteers. It is very interesting to see what can be done as open source. But most of us will agree that graphically it doesn't meet FSX yet.

Although technically a one man project is possible, I think to make something really high quality and user friendly requires quite a big team. That's why most games are made by big studios.

For the moment I am happy with FSX and keeping my eyes open for X-Plane, Flight, Prepar3D and FlightGear. I think if FSX would no longer please me as a platform to developer for and I would want to have influence on the platform, I would more likely join FlightGear than try to start from scratch again.
 
Back
Top