• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

Payware Design Software

Messages
61
Country
unitedkingdom
Hey Guys,

I need some advice/opinions on some design software that i want to use to design aircraft.
I have been looking at Autodesk 3DS Max but i dont really fancy paying $3000for it!!!!.

Is there any other programmes out there that are able to do high quality VCS and models like PMDG' aircraft?

Thanks
James
 
Hey Guys,

I need some advice/opinions on some design software that i want to use to design aircraft.
I have been looking at Autodesk 3DS Max but i dont really fancy paying $3000for it!!!!.

It wouldn't do you one bit of good to spend all that money...

...only to THEN discover that it's completely worthless for FS development anyway!

The last versions of Max that can use the FSX SDK haven't been available for several years: Max7 (v7.0), Max8 (v8.0), Max9 (v9.0) and Max2008 (v10.0)...

For aircraft design:

GMax (free)
FSDS ($'s)

For scenery design:
both of the above +
Google Sketchup (free) + MXC (free)
 
Thanks Guys,

Sorry about that, just that i heard people use it to create aircraft, what do you recommend more gmax or FSDS?

James
 
Thanks Guys,

Sorry about that, just that i heard people use it to create aircraft, what do you recommend more gmax or FSDS?

James

GMax is free, FSDS is payware. I use neither so I cannot say which is best/easiest. Maybe start out with Gmax and see how you get on?
 
FSDS is much, much easier to use for beginners, but is nowhere near as capable as gmax/max. It can be extended somewhat by using the FSDSTweak program, but I graduated to gmax and max long ago. I would recommend you start on gmax, but if you really can't cope with it, you can buy FSDS and use that.
 
FSDS is much, much easier to use for beginners, but is nowhere near as capable as gmax/max.

Whilst I mostly agree on the initial "ease of use" for FSDS, the various difficulties one will eventually encounter with trying to go from FSDS to the sim (particularly FSX) makes learning GMax's foibles rather pale in comparison... :D

As it happens, while I was helping the author of FSDS "update" his program for FSX, I had to d/l a copy of FSDS so I could do some experiments and testing. I stared at the screen for twenty minutes trying to figure out how to draw a simple "box!"

So much for the claims of an "intuitive interface!" :rotfl:
 
Last edited:
Well, I suppose it depends on how each person works. I never liked gmax/max to start with, but I do now.

Also, don't forget the Google SketchUp route if you want to do simple scenery. Nothing beats that program for ease of use - I had that one figured out within a few minutes, although I don't use it for FS. The conversion process from SketchUp to MDL is the only sticking point there.
 
The conversion process from SketchUp to MDL is the only sticking point there.

With ModelConverterX that has been reduced to a few mouse clicks as well in most cases :). But it is only an option when you want to make scenery object, for making a VC or an flyable aircraft SketchUp will not work.
 
I had better add my 2p.
I (and only a couple of others) have successfully used 3D Canvas Pro 7.1.2
($70) to build FS9 and FSX Native models - http://www.amabilis.com

This model and VC were made entirely using 3D canvas and an old paint tool called picture publisher.
http://www.fsdeveloper.com/forum/showthread.php?t=17727

How it was done:
The aircraft: http://forums.uktrainsim.com/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=88061
The Engine http://forums.uktrainsim.com/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=88248

The 3D canvas source files:
http://cid-06b528339820717e.skydriv...oads/3DC Source Models/baswallow-3dcanvas.zip

I have a few more aircraft coming soon (or when I find some spare time)
 
Go with GMAX, that is the biggest community, can do practically everything 3d max can do, and thanks to Arno we can even convert our models to other formats later if needed.
 
My 2-Pence:
I started with FSDS in the early times, then I have got GMAX with the prof engine delivered.
Jesus, that was a step into the future.
Ok, the learning curve was not that easy. I did know the Catia-System, but taking FS into concern, that did only help a litle bit constructing FS-specialized airplanes.
It is not just learning the underlying IT-Program, it is much more the understanding of FS-aircraft.
I was then used to model every single part coming from the world of machenery design.
In FS-Design of aircraft frame rates are the polling factors.
In conjunction with good fly-models, panel- and sound files, not to forget the texturing.
Texturing indeed is used at all times to cut the frame rates.
GMax has a good capability in using textures and in interacting with moving parts.
For free, with all its possibilities one of the best 3D-modelling software I have ever seen.
OK, very, very hard to learn if you are cominmg from scratch.
 
I suggest Gmax. I started out in FSDS, but later went to Gmax.

FSDS is ULTRA EASY! Very awesome program for starting out on.

Gmax at first seems very hard, but thats because it has so many tools. You will only use a few of them if ever, so do not be intimidated.

The reason I went from FSDS to Gmax was that Gmax handles fluid shapes and cutting out of rounded shaped windows and doors better. Thats the main reason. I found out later that its faster to work in. But if you have problems coping with learning things, then FSDS is your route to go. If you want super rounded parts and want to cut out rounded windows and have gear doors go invisible when they go flush/closed, then Gmax is worth it to learn. Just remember to do the tutorials in order and DO NOT ADVANCE to the next tutorial level until you can do the one you are learning by heart/memory... Jump ahead and you miss very important tools and training that you will need in the next step(s).




Decapod,

Dang! You are quite the pioneer in going into your own directions in FS development. Very nice. Thanks for posting the links to this new software. Very nice work.

Can 3D Canvas to Rendering?

Thanks also for the X file Super_Scale trick for FS9. Works brilliant....!




James95,

By the way. Max is $4200.00 plus dollars, not $3,000.00.

Also you cannot have it on more then 2 computers. So if you fry two computers in the next 6 months, and you had it on both, then you must buy another issue of Max.

Personally, I think Max is a total rip-off. It used to cost about $1200.00 and didnt have such lame regulations on it. Now its priced so that only a few people in the world can afford to have it and at rediculous regulations such as use on your own computers. Every dev has a backup on their laptop of their design program so they can work away from the house, and everyone purchases a new computer these days nearly every 2 years. Who is going to pay $4200.00 every two years for a program like that? Oh... Yes... Studio owners. None of us can afford that...

Its good to have alternatives and backup plans.


Bill
 
Last edited:
NormallY people are talking/complainig about AutoCad engines, even for some minor points talking about machinery integreation.
So for any reason, constructing in a normal environment might be AutoCad, Catia, or something else. Just cutting it down to FS it is GMAX, or payable Conversion.
Sounds strange, but it is the truth.
 
Back
Top