• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

Prototypes and Copyrights

Status
Not open for further replies.
Messages
39
Hi guys!
I have one question about copyright. I mean, if i made, like a payware, an Aeronca or Piper, in this case I have to buy a licence or something like that from them(have in view real companies-designers)?
Thanks!
 
In theory, yes.

There have been a few companies that have become belligerent about their planes being modeled in FS.

The vast majority of planes, however, are released without any licensing.
 
Thanks hcornea!
Have you ever contacted the companies for authorization or notification?
There have been a few companies that have become belligerent about their planes being modeled in FS.
I hope this aren't applicable for companies like Glasair and Helio!?
 
Boeing, Douglas, Lancair, Cessna are some of the major companies that do not want FS people making payware of their planes. They charge a large price for using their shapes and names, and they have that right. But, to do this to free advertisement seems like shooting yourself in the foot to demand things of people when they are actually doing you a service.

(Example, person hands out 'your' business cards to thousands, getting free advertisements out 'for' you and future business and pilots come flowing in from this).


But, aside from that. Some companies really appreciate it and see the good in it, that it is free advertising. To have a plane made by a pro group that they might have to hire would cost them around 20K I would venture to estimate. This would be an inhouse team, with payroll, with medical fees, expenses, equipment and programs (Max at $4400.00 per copy), etc, etc. They could actually easily spend 40 or 50K on a very good model.


Companies like Quest, Piper, Epic, Mooney, and others have appreciated the advertising. They do appreciate the 'asking first'. Contact their legal department to request permissions.

I heard that in Federal Court, in America, a plane that is out of production is no longer under copyright. It must be in production. Logos are different, names are also withstanding if they are still in business, such as Cessna, so you cant use their names. Prototypes, like the Boeing Bird of Prey (a very sleek, cool looking bird that gets me going wildly), is 'not' in production, but Boeing 'might' find a way to try to block you from using it.


Some of the bad news in at least working with companies; they require thousands down (usually) like 2K down (USD), then 10 or 20% of your net profits, plus you must have liability insurance for your firm, usually. I heard Lancair wanted $9,000.00 USD down, plus royalties and monthly payments. (I thought that was HILARIOUS).


Hope that helps.
 
Last edited:
The general position is that the manufacturers' own the Intellectual Property Rights in their products. That gives them the right to control their use, so the best course is to ask them if you intend to use them on a commercial basis.

The downside is that a particular manufacturer may not care one way or the other but, if asked, may say 'no' because that's the easiest and least risky answer to give.

Intellectual Property Rights are more than simply copyright.
 
Thank you guys!
I heard Lancair wanted $9,000.00 USD down, plus royalties and monthly payments. (I thought that was HILARIOUS).
RealAir!? I don't think that they paid for their last plane, or they are!?
And do you have some trouble with your amazing wt-9?
 
Back in 2005 a Boeing licencing agreement required $1000 up-front payment and royalties of 4% of the invoiced price. with a minimum annual payment of $1000. That implies sales of at least $25,000 a year
 
Thank you guys!

RealAir!? I don't think that they paid for their last plane, or they are!?
And do you have some trouble with your amazing wt-9?


I emailed Aerospool and they talked with the board and voted to do it. They assigned one of their key people who wanted this to go. He sent me what ever I needed, like landing gear drawings, photos of the landing gear bays, etc, etc. He made only two requests. Make one for FS2004 and also for IVAO multi player. With IVAO, I had to make very basic model versions and they finally accepted them at IVAO. With FS2004, the model was 1/2 million Polygons and I had a fully detailed engine as well. So, I had to figure out a way to export the model into FS2004. Thus was born the refined version of Gmax unlimited FS9 export or FS-Unlimited export. That got Miroslav his FS9 version, and we also came out with the FSX version, which then couldnt take over 1/2 million Polygons, so we had to take out the female co-pilot. Then, we needed it approved by Chudy Jan, main test pilot at Aerospool and it passed with flying colors. He enjoyed it.

They didnt request any royalties and they helped the progress of the model so that it was what they wanted it to be like. For instance, Miroslav would tell me something didnt look right, so I made the changes. This happened a few times. He would send me pictures of what he was talking about. Helped me and my modeller out immensely.


When I do work 'with' a factory, I try to work 'for' them, to help them. So I walk on eggs to make sure I do everything right, say everything right, etc. Some of these models go out to people that are training for them for a license, etc. Some are thinking of buying the actual plane, so they want an 'idea' of what they are about. So getting them right, in the payware arena, is 'key'. It needs to be really nice....
 
Back in 2005 a Boeing licencing agreement required $1000 up-front payment and royalties of 4% of the invoiced price. with a minimum annual payment of $1000. That implies sales of at least $25,000 a year

So that's why Ariane's 737s are so effin' expensive...
 
Guys, thank you!
lionheart, thank you a lot! Your experience are very helpful for all of us. Thank you again!

Summing up
If i want to model an aircraft from famous trademark I must ask a permission
But what about small ultralight and homebuilt plans such as Rutan Long-EZ, Fly Baby, ASSO etc.? How's it work for them?
Thanks!
 
Why not ask them?

That is the best advice you will find. The second-best advice is to contact an attorney. We do not encourage threads about legal issues at FSDeveloper.

Dick
 
Ask... Thats what I do.. Contact the front desk, ask her. If she cannot help, then the law department there. Sales might also help. They will usually side with you. Diamond aircraft did that with me, sales department.
 
I agree

Sales and Marketing are the guys most likely to see the request as an opportunity for free advertizing. If you can get them to go into bat for you then you should be on your way.

Also consider the implications of not asking. You create a super model and it goes out and is very popular with the punters. One just happens to mention it to his friend who works for the company. Next thing you get hit with a request for fees and royalties. What happens then? You pay up? You have to withdraw your model, compensate your buyers and swallow the time/cost effort of development.
 
Bill, problem with "free advertising" in form of FS models is it can shoot you in the leg, if not done right. Imagine someone selling an addon with a nice "Officially endorsed by *Company" taking up half every picture, and it is buggy, flies wrong, eats twice as much fuel as it should (because who cares, fuel is free in FSX) etc. Many would say "If they endorse this POS officially, what will the actual product be like?"


btw. I heard about Shark Aero (almost "next door" to Aerospool, in Senice) being interested in having a model of their airplane... it was a while back though, but if someone is looking for an interesting little GA to make, they might be game.
 
Larger companies have licencing departments to deal with this. Unfortunately or FS developers, these departments are geared up to handle major requests and one from an FS developer is likely to be too small for them to bother with.

Also whether there's an FS add-on or not will have no real effects on sales. A corporate buyer won't be influenced by that.
 
You only need an "Endorsed by..." across adverts if the company insist on it, in which case they're going to QA your model before endorsing it. We're talking about avoiding legal trouble here,such as Boeing and others have caused in the past.
 
lionheart,

Sounds like you got the attention there of someone who is into flight simming? Is that the case? I would think that would help in one's case.

Also, did you take any kind of special "approach" when seeking permission, like "we are just poor flight simmers" or " this is only a hobby", or did you take a more professional approach citing models you have created before, convincing them of the marketing benefits, etc.?

Clutch
 
Bill, problem with "free advertising" in form of FS models is it can shoot you in the leg, if not done right. Imagine someone selling an addon with a nice "Officially endorsed by *Company" taking up half every picture, and it is buggy, flies wrong, eats twice as much fuel as it should (because who cares, fuel is free in FSX) etc. Many would say "If they endorse this POS officially, what will the actual product be like?"


That is why they all request testing and testing 'before' it goes to public. The companies want it perfect, how they like, not me, so I usually have to change alot of things. In the end, it works out great for everyone.


btw. I heard about Shark Aero (almost "next door" to Aerospool, in Senice) being interested in having a model of their airplane... it was a while back though, but if someone is looking for an interesting little GA to make, they might be game.

I 'love love love' that plane design. I have a ton of pictures of it. I wish I had the time and resources to insert it into our production que. I would love to model that beautiful bird. Such a sharp design.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top