• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

FSXA Suspension Animation Issues

Messages
468
Country
ca-ontario
Hi folks, I am having some issues with a current project and could do with some assistance.

The problem lies with the animation of the landing gear 'scissors' as can be seen in these shots...

Susp_1.jpg

Susp_2.jpg


For some reason the scissors are 'passing through' each other rather than moving the way they were set up in GMAX.

I have redone the animation in GMAX at least three times and it is correct there (i.e. both parts of the scissors remain connected at the mid point joint with key frames every 10 frames) and I have spent several hours messing with contact point data especially in the areas of compression ratio and damping ratio with no luck. The main gear scissors are the worst case although the nose gear scissors also show this effect to a smaller degree but do not pass through each other and so the effect is less noticeable.

I am starting to think I may need to add some sort of constraint to the animation in GMAX to 'force' the lower scissors to stay connected to the upper scissors/joint pin but I have no clue how to do this nor which type of constraint to apply.

Has anyone seen behaviour like this before and can anyone offer suggestions on how I might fix it.

Thanks for looking.
 
Possible solutions:

1) More keyframes

2) "Reset Scale" on both scissor parts.

3) Workaround
 
...I am starting to think I may need to add some sort of constraint to the animation in GMAX to 'force' the lower scissors to stay connected to the upper scissors/joint pin

I use constraints to build animations like these; but constraints don't export to the sim, the successful animation has to be Collapsed to keyframes before exporting!

Do the links animate in FSX at all? If they do, but don't follow your animation exactly, check the animation length, start frame and end frame in the Animation Manager. If the links have frames 115 to 190 while the oleos use 100 to 200 there will be visual discrepancies like your shot shows.
 
Just a thought, but you know that suspension is animated at keyframes 100-200, not 0 - 100, right?
 
I use constraints to build animations like these; but constraints don't export to the sim, the successful animation has to be Collapsed to keyframes before exporting!
Ahh, I wasn't aware of that, I assumed (wrongly obviously) that constraints would be exported with the animation.

Do the links animate in FSX at all? If they do, but don't follow your animation exactly, check the animation length, start frame and end frame in the Animation Manager. If the links have frames 115 to 190 while the oleos use 100 to 200 there will be visual discrepancies like your shot shows.
They do animate just not correctly. I have double checked and remade the animation several times but your comment made me go back and look at the parts in the animation manager again and for some reason all the suspect parts seem to have lost the info on frame length! :eek:

Looks like I will have to re-do all those (again) and I will report back after checking in FSX.
 
I just re-did the animations again and also re-assigned all the tags in the animation manager and I am still having the same issues with the gear scissors. :confused:
 
I set the scissors to be correct at frame 100, no compression, and at frame 200, full compression. FS interprets linearly where they should be between these frames. If they do not look right when the airplane is sitting on the ground (static compression) then you need to fiddle with the contact point static compression, and compression ratio numbers.
Roy
 
I set the scissors to be correct at frame 100, no compression, and at frame 200, full compression. FS interprets linearly where they should be between these frames. If they do not look right when the airplane is sitting on the ground (static compression) then you need to fiddle with the contact point static compression, and compression ratio numbers.
Roy
Thanks for that Roy, I will go back and play with those again.
 
In the animation rollout expand the "assign controller tab, click rotation and next on the "?" symbol and select linear from the dropdown list if it isn't allready selected.

BTW, contact points won't bring your animations out of sync, the cause is somewhere else.
 

Attachments

  • controllers.jpg
    controllers.jpg
    31.1 KB · Views: 470
Mathias's pic is from 3ds Max: if you're using Gmax it looks like this:-

rotationcontroller.jpg



and you might consider making linear rotation the default rotation controller from that dialog box.
 
Thanks for that picture Tom and I am indeed using GMAX. This project is the first one I have done where I needed to use animations (all my other modelling has been for scenery items) so it's all new to me. I haven't used that rollout at all for all my other animations (which work fine) so I guess I need to read up on it to see how it works. I guess I have been animating by 'brute force', moving the slider, moving the parts, moving the slider, moving the parts, etc., etc., etc.
 
I just checked all the suspect parts and all scales are 100 on all axes.

Doesn't matter. Clicking the "Rest Scale" button a few times *could* help regardless.

If I could find one I'd use it! :rolleyes::D

I had a similar problem with the spoiler(on) actuators on my Dornier, but I can't find the thread. In any case, I had to go for a (unrealistic) workaround in the end.

My gear scissors and other parts working with the same principle, however, work quite well.



I use constraints to build animations like these; but constraints don't export to the sim, the successful animation has to be Collapsed to keyframes before exporting!

Yep.

"Show trajectory" and then "Collapse To Keyframes" can also work.
 
Thanks to Mathias and Tom I now have a correctly working animation. :)

Apparently all my animations were 'non-linear' (I can't remember the exact term now) so I remade all the scissor animations setting the animation rollout tag to linear as suggested and it now works fine in FSX with no crossing of the scissor parts during the animation.

Thanks for all the suggestions guys, I couldn't have done it without ya!

Onwards and upwards! :rolleyes:
 
Several times I've received models to rig that were built by professional 3d design folks with no flightsim experience whatever...

Without exception, all animations were done with Euler transformations set. I had to write a maxscript to automatically parse all the hundreds of parts and change them to Linear transformations!

What's odd though is that sometimes TCB or Euler transforms will work, but as you've now seen often enough they don't work out too well! :p
 
I see that Bill. I have since gone through the entire model and changed all animations to linear. ;)

I'm just glad I've only animated the outside so far. :D
 
Back
Top