• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

FSXA Updated Objects not displaying?

Messages
112
Country
unitedkingdom
Hi there,

I'm new to this (seemingly excellent) tool so it could well be that the issues I'm experiencing are all my own fault. I have loaded & installed 1.65.5384.

Opened up an existing airfield and gone through a number of cycles of adding buildings, roads etc and also deleted a few of the original buildings and changing road/taxiway/runway surface textures.

However when I go to FSX, I notice a couple of bits of strange behaviour:
1) The airfield does NOT show up when I select the "Search add-on scenery" option, even though the BGL file is located in the correct directory. Nevertheless, the modified airport does seem to be the one that appears in the "Default Scenery" list. (This seems to be reinforced by the fact that the "State/Province" value that was missing from the original and which I added in ADE shows in the default list.)
2) Objects from earlier saves (and indeed the original airport) seem to persist in the latest compiled revision of the airport. For example, I replaced the original (huge) tower with a much more realistically sized one and see BOTH when I load the airport.

Am I making schoolboy errors? :)

Running FSX Acceleration, pretty much vanilla. Not running FSUIPC or WideFS, so viewing changes in FSX directly.

Cheers,

Z
 
Hi and welcome :)

For your first question. If you are modifying a stock airport then you load the airport from the stock list as you found. I am not sure what the add-on scenery list of for. Provided that any airport is saved into an active scenery folder like Addon Scenery\scenery then it always shows up in what you call the default scenery list.

On question two it is rather difficult to diagnose without seeing the project file. Can you please confirm to me that you are not opening your work from the compiled Bgl file? If you are then you do need to stop. ADE produces a project file (.ad3 or .ad4 extension) which you save when you save the airport. This contains a lot of information that is not in the Bgl file and all sorts of problem arise if you just load the bgl file back. So if you are working that way then I would recommend deleting all and any bgl files you created for this airport. Then open the ADE project file - I assume that somewhere along the way ADE got you to save it ;) Compile that and see what you get. If the problems persist then please attach the project file to a reply here so that we can check out what is happening.
 
Hi Jon,

Thanks for the speedy reply. Am opening the .ad4 project file, but I had a nosey around and saw that compilation created BLG files in both the Addon Scenery\scenery and the Scenery\World\Scenery folders, then put 2+2 together and got 5. Here's the file. Incidentally, I was trying to be smart with the exclude areas I tacked on around the perimeter as FSX seems to have an annoying habit of sticking huge autogen houses in these places.

Z
 

Attachments

I will look at your file but be aware that exclusion rectangles won't remove autogen
 
Hmm. Was just reading another thread on that. Seems I need to get to the airport background polygon. Not sure how to do that but I'll have a dig!! :D
Edit: D'oh! The "exclusions" I added are, it seems, background polygons... Is best practice to create a single big plate on which the airport is located or is the trick to minimise the overall number of vertices?
</Edit>

Whilst I'm here, is it possible to recreate the undulations found on 27/09 with ADE or is that an FSX limitation?

Z
 
Last edited:
OK Immediate finding - this project has been loaded at least once from a Bgl file compiled with ADE. The reason I can tell is that there are a lot of small exclusions visible:

ScreenShot00079.png


I have marked some here with arrows. Each one of these was created by ADE as a micro exclude to exclude stock objects like generic buildings (Blue rectangles), library objects, taxi signs and so on. Generally you can't see these in ADE since it hides them in the project file but not if the compiled Bgl file is loaded back. If any of these have been moved or accidentally deleted then the stock object they are excluding will come back again. I don't know how much changing around you have done and I haven't tested what it looks like in FSX yet.

Is there any chance you have accidentally done anything with these micro excludes? Perhaps you can identify one or two of the objects that are coming through from the stock airport?

Also I assume that the airport background polys are there to exclude the unwanted autogen.
 
Ah, yes, it is possible I once loaded from the BGL (I was on a bit of a steep learning curve) after the application hung during attempted multi-object editing (I've had this a couple of times since btw - the multi edit box clicks the done button without closing the form. In fact, nothing will close the form other than killing the application with Task Manager). I thought I'd lost the most recent edit of my airport so went on the hunt for more recently saved files which probably resulted in my loading a project by opening a bgl file. However, I saved under a new project name and this may be the problem.

I can upload the earlier project file if this would help?

Yes, the background polys are to exclude unwanted autogen. I happen to know the RW area reasonably well and the autogen is infuriating!!

Really appreciate your assistance Jon. If the smart thing for me to do is start from scratch please don't spend too much of your time debugging my learning project. Clean sheet might well do me good.

Z
 
We have had reports of hangs with some dialogs. Can I ask if you have FSX running and are connected to it? Is ADE actually overlaying FSX? If you are connected and it happens again please just try disconnecting and if that doesn't work then close FSX

Please post a project file prior to your load from a bgl if you have one. BTW ADE has several ways to create backups in case of crashes. If you get offered to reload the airport after a CTD then please do that. It will bring the project back to the last autosave. This is an article on the ADE backup features: https://scruffyduck.screenstepslive.com/s/help_docs/m/20268/l/253109-how-do-i-backup-my-project-1-65
 
FSX is installed on the same machine as ADE although I've tried to be quite disciplined about not running them concurrently. Not sure if this is what you mean by "overlaying FSX".
Since I wasn't trying to do a structured test I can't give you precise steps to reproduce the hanging I've experienced but as I say, it seems to occur when trying to edit after selecting multiple objects. At one point I realised that I'd created all my vehicle routes in concrete when I wanted asphalt or tarmac and so tried to select a large number of sections (maybe a dozen) and then change their properties. I suspected at the time that I may have inadvertently selected a background picture (I've had 2 concurrently loaded) and the lack of common attributes might have found a bug. If you'd like I'll be a bit more systematic and see if I can get a set of steps that reliably reproduce the issue.

The autosave, didn't seem to save me with the file I attach now. I know for sure that I had manually saved changes and passed an auto save point on the attached file but when I came to load it found that a number of buildings that I had modified prior to the crash were missing. I don't recall if they were present when I loaded the .bgl and *thought* that I'd gone back to the original project file as a basis for the 2nd version. Perhaps not. Sorry!
I haven't deliberately moved micro excludes, although I did move the original taxiways quite a bit and shuffle around the "stock" buildings as well as adding quite a few more. Once I became aware of the limited shapes and textures of the default buildings it became my intention to replace them by building up a library of custom made buildings (have reasonably good 3D CAD skills but not started this yet). I'll take a look at the article too - thanks for the link.

Z

PS/ For anyone reading this and thinking ADE has issues, please don't forget I'm using a beta here and despite being comfortable using CAD tools have never attempted airport design. The software is REALLY addictive and more stable than many applications that I've parted with hard earned cash to use.
 

Attachments

I am glad you like ADE. Don't worry about reporting problems though - no one else here minds keeping me up nights trying to figure out what went wrong ;)

I compiled the second project you sent me and this is what I see looking at the tower:

ScreenShot00080.png



This is the stock airport:

ScreenShot00081.png


looks like the same tower to me so perhaps you have not changed it in this project version - also there are no apparent duplicates. Am I looking at the right thing?
 
Correct Jon. This file was before I'd started on the tower. However it does contain an tall building (approx 5 storey that you can see in the car park behind the tower - a Library Object GUID 7a66942c-3411-499e-96a9-6aeac2a5f20c) that I deleted in the 2nd version - likewise the covered fuel station. However when I load the later file in FSX, both these objects are still displayed.

I guess the best way to describe what appears to happen is that FSX displays v1 and v2 simultaneously. I know I added the perimeter road in v2 and originally had it in concrete. Despite it now showing in v2 as asphalt, it shows in FSX as concrete, as if perhaps an older edit is being layered on top of the current one. Would a screenshot help?

Z
 
OK - please check that you don't have two Bgl files for the same airport - this would be a common cause of these problems. I don't see the fuel station when loading your version of the airport. Remove any bgl files that you can see that you created relating to this airport. You might find this article of interest if you want to understand 'layering' : https://scruffyduck.screenstepslive.com/s/help_docs/m/20268/l/199760-priority-matters

Also you might find Simple Airport Scanner helpful if you can't find the second bgl file. It is available from www.scruffyduck.org
 
Thanks Jon. So, I'll delete all the BGLs in the FSX tree that I've created with ADE then compile from v2 and give it a whirl. Alas MY FSX machine is also the house media centre PC and I can't drag my daughter away from "Great British Bake-Off" until later. Grrrr.

I'm still not clear how I should be dealing with the problems I've created with the tiny exclusions. If they are there to obliterate objects that (by definition) I won't want, am I just creating problems down the road if I don't get back to the original MS airport before proceeding?

Z
 
There seems to be a weird bug in version 1.65 that does not exclude default towers - I have no idea why at the moment but that would explain your duplicate tower.
 
See my other post George - there is definitely something not quite right ..................
 
Curiouser & curiouser:
I renamed all the bgl files under FSX that I had created with ADE to x.bgl.00n the loaded up ADE and compiled the most recent file.
Result: same old objects still there.
Next, rename the all the ADE generated bgls again and DON'T compile anything from ADE.
Result: Modified airport (i.e. containing an apron I added etc) displayed in FSX.
Conclusion: There's a bgl lurking somewhere, probably generated by a compile that I did early on in the scheme of things (don't ask me where) that has always been loading and causing the additional objects I'm seeing. Odd, because I haven't changed the output folder at any point. ADE can't be changing the default MS airport can it?

Looks like I need to install SAS and play "hunt the rogue bgl".

Z
 
I think we have determined that the problem exists only when compiled with the P3D compiler.
 
George is right that the tower issue is present when using ADE for P3D. I am working on a fix which should be available shortly and might at least eliminate that problem
 
I have now released a fix for the problems related to compiling for P3D. However to be clear these problems did not affect FSX so probably will not help with this thread.
 
Back
Top