• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

FSX Window Cutting

Messages
1,101
Country
unitedkingdom
Hi guys,

Sorry for opening a new thread, but i've left the smoothing behing until I can really get the windows looking correct,

Now there is a superbly shaped AI model of the AN-140, my model will be user flyable flyable. I've attached some screenshots of the model, they've not cut the windows out, it's part of the texture, then the windshield is mapped separately. Exactly what I want to do, but how do you do that, this is the 4th time I've tried to cut the windows but they simply look aweful. I've tried boolean and shapre merge operations but none, with a lot of tweaking give the desired result and end up in just one big mess?

Obviously there are no boolean operations or shape merges used here;

http://www.unitedtrafficteam.net/upl...7_an140upd.jpg

http://www.unitedtrafficteam.net/upl...5061_an140.jpg

http://southwestdesign.org.uk/Untitled-1 copy.jpg

http://southwestdesign.org.uk/Untitled-2 copy.jpg

This is an image of my model as it is, the shape is fine, i'm happy with that;

http://southwestdesign.org.uk/Progress12.jpg

Any help please, is it worth me posting a new thread in the modelling section?

Thanks,

Piran.
 
Last edited:
Hey Piran,

Ive developed a cool way to cut windows out, but its slightly comprehensive. But.... For me, its quicker then the Boolean and Shape Merge methods. What I do is cut them out from a side view 'manually'.


I create a template outline of the window(s) with Splines. These are perfect and up close are very rounded at rounded corners, like the ultimate perfect outline of the window with no notchiness so I have an idea of it being perfect. I can make the templates over photos for maximum shape perfection. They must be the right size, curvature, etc.

Next, I begin cutting Edges by 'dividing' the Edges with new Vertices where the Edges on the fuselage 'intersect' with the Template. Another words, I add a Vertex at each line cross over with the Template. Note that you can only cut the window from a single view, not angles, so its all 2D, like Left side. You must do this to only a Editable Poly, as Editable Mesh doenst have the ability to place a Vertex in the middle of an Edge. Poly does.

Note, to add a Vertex to an Edge, you go have your Fuselage as a Editable Poly, go to Edge mode, "Create". Then click on Edges where you want the Vertex at exactly.

Next, you must place Vertices in the center area's of Polygons where the edges of the template go into and have curves. So now, you must right click and make your Editable Poly into an Editable Mesh as only Mesh objects can have Vertices installed/placed into the centers of Polygons. (Polys will end up being unstable and Vertices will not fall on exact locations, so you switch over to Editable Mesh and you go to Poly Mode and then 'Divide' and start cutting Vertices into the Polygon surfaces where no edges are, completely inline with the Template.

As you place each Vertex, you will get 'rays' of Edges beaming out from each Vertex placement. Thus you might have to go a ways and stop, switch back to Editable Poly, delete a few extra Edges, then go back to Editable Mesh and continue cutting Vertices in line with the Template.

Note, you cannot delete Edges from in a Editable Mesh object, as you will delete the 'surface' area. But in Editable Poly area's, you can. Some will refuse to delete, but most will delete. You have to have at least one Edge going to Vertices or you delete the Vertices you placed. That is why you bounce back and fourth from Editable Mesh and Editable Poly. Each do certain things.

Once you have all of your Vertices laid out, and you are happy with them, like in small corners with curves, you can start 'connecting the dots' by adding an edge to each set of Vertices (where none exist). To do this, go back to Editable Poly, Edge mode, Create. Start clicking on a Vertex, click on next Vertex and you create an Edge between the two. Continue all the way around. You will have to delete some Edges to cross over them. Continue carefully as you go.

When done, you may now delete non-used Edges and start cleaning up the mesh zones. Note that you should not have a zillion Edges, and your edge work must 'flow' in appearance or it will be like crumpled foil.

Now, one last thing. You may have to move Vertices around 'very very very' slightly to give them a rounded, organic appearence. What I mean is that when you add a small curve over a flat topped Polygon (cutting the curve across flat plates), the visual can look 'notchy' so I move the curve into a slight 3D appearance and then it looks natural instead of chunky or jagged.


You learn to do all of this as you go. Just move careful and logical and move along slowly.

This will take less time then doing a quick Boolean or Shape Merge, as with those two, you get a MASSSSSIVE amount of extra Vertices, ludicrous amount, and have to go around the cutout welding and welding. With my method here, you have 'no' extra Vertices, and when you are good enough, you can cut out windows and doors from pre-mapped fuselages with great ease and 'not' have to remap. Takes good craftsmanship though, but can be fast and very clean.


I hope this helps. Its my fave route now after years of model making.
 
Here, you can see how rounded and smooth your shapes can get.



Note though, on your front windows, I 'think' they might be plates; flat. Very hard to do. Start out simple, then once your windows are basically shaped, then round out the curved corners so you do not mess up their flatness. Cut the curved corners by my method above 'after' you get the plates flat and fitted perfectly into the nose shape.


Tube liners are hardest that have flat windows, making them to fit perfectly into that nose. Very very difficult.

1LH-1000x633.jpg




Bill
 
Back
Top