• Which the release of FS2020 we see an explosition of activity on the forun and of course we are very happy to see this. But having all questions about FS2020 in one forum becomes a bit messy. So therefore we would like to ask you all to use the following guidelines when posting your questions:

    • Tag FS2020 specific questions with the MSFS2020 tag.
    • Questions about making 3D assets can be posted in the 3D asset design forum. Either post them in the subforum of the modelling tool you use or in the general forum if they are general.
    • Questions about aircraft design can be posted in the Aircraft design forum
    • Questions about airport design can be posted in the FS2020 airport design forum. Once airport development tools have been updated for FS2020 you can post tool speciifc questions in the subforums of those tools as well of course.
    • Questions about terrain design can be posted in the FS2020 terrain design forum.
    • Questions about SimConnect can be posted in the SimConnect forum.

    Any other question that is not specific to an aspect of development or tool can be posted in the General chat forum.

    By following these guidelines we make sure that the forums remain easy to read for everybody and also that the right people can find your post to answer it.

3d grass

mskhan1991

Resource contributor
Messages
935
Country
pakistan
is there a more efficient way of making volumetric 3d grass other than just copying rectangular polygons with grass textures on them?

Like flytampa's KBUF airport.
i am thinking abt making this a part of my scenery.

Any help would be appreciated.
 
I haven't seen FlyTampa's scenery myself but from the screenshots it may as well be small polygons with alpha textures placed randomly on the ground in different angles.

Other than that there is a nice tutorial where they've used layers of polys with a texture and a noise (with alpha) which gives the impression of more realistic grass. Not particularly nice from the side-views though but may become nice with some tweaking..

See here: http://www.webdesign.org/3d-graphics/tutorials/low-poly-grass-and-hair.543.html

you could also try the hair&fur modifier if using 3Ds
 

they look the same from evvery angle .....THE GRASS
aircraft on grass in intended to enhance the visual satisfaction for -"it is 3d grass'


VIEW FULL SCREEN IMAGE (IMAGE IN WINDOWS AND SLIDE WINDOWS ARE poor grade and does not show the exact work.SO DOWNLOAD AND SEE . they are no textures but the real stuff,.you Won't be disappointed.
is that 3d enough for you.
anything else? trees? which don't look like ffolded paper in sceneries?
FLower?plants?any other landscape element?


Chao
-Ashish
(Architect by Profession.)
urbanstructures@gmail.com
 
Last edited:
These look awesome indeed..! any info on how to develop them however? I assume these are true structures, but what about polygon counts and performance?
 
all the parapharnalia you shall read is necessary that will hekp you develop things leke these without help .the core of the concept will be strong so you can derive any thing.
for developing such things prodeuct like Ez Scenery is must . or you'll never achieve frame rate ....descent frame rate.....and patience becuase it can go as far as filling a chart paper of 1mts.x 1mts. with dots until unfill space on that paper is no more than 10% (collectively) not one [articular end/part/edge.:eek:
though i'm not good at explanations and expressions but still try.........
There is something, you would'nt believe , i Follow just one principle in every field of life. "There has to be a First time for everything."
forget polygons counts/polygons with textures, no matter the photoREALISTIC .
example lets take an example of small airport but which is international
what would your impression be for a normal graphic card user with a scenery
.....with TeXture files .....say the set of textures (20 files )with 14 texture file size = 5.48 or say 5 mb each ?
and the Scenery objects are all the most complicated and complex(-est) 3d objects?
your answer will be---- even with graphics card (normal ) on would'nt never get more 8-10 on frames and without graphics card?...................forget it ......hardly 4-5 or may be 6 .
I'd say no
I've successfully found a way to use the most complex 3d object and with everything in detail (not depending on textures to make it look like w
hat to wish to achieve in the end.using textures is the name of game.)
ok
say you make a complete jetway that is 3d. (no boxes with textures to make it look photo real ) this 3d jetway even have every single 3d wire that is visible from outside.to put it in a nutshell. say ... you want to make a door that is opened after the jetway is attached to aircraft .
simple procedure
make a polygon with with both sides or may be one side.
take a picture of a door
edit it for using as texture in slight simulator and
bingo
or make an object with 6 or 4 sides and the apply textures to it////
now at bottom rail , i.e bottom side is usually.......... wont be visible after doors are hinges to the jetway . So, it's no use texturing that size and uselessly add to the size of door.
1st method is more preferred .
2nd way is preferred by paywares to achieve quality but they sure such things are minimum in number after all they want their product return them some good earning. if only quality and not frame rate . then it's a junk
lets get back to the topic.
now making a complete 3d door with every thing that is really three dimensional. door handles, locks ,panels(if it has any) with every level difference i.e a portion of door is setback /portion of door protruding outsides.
ThIS Is the worst idea one would go for ..flight simulator scenery ..
you simulating aviation and not interiors or say architecture .
would'nt it be great to have these while maintaining the simulation performance to be in limits of smooth experience... usually yyou can simulate or fly with not much complain on frames and to enjoy simulation Ushould have frame ( iin the least) not below 24 . right ?
this is the worse limit and why go for it when you still can achieve more 30-40.
this will be like --FIRST CREATE A PROBLEM AND THEN SIT TRYING TO SOLVE THE PROBLEM this is the basic guideline for scenery development .n
NOW
when you put that Complete 3 DIMENSIONAL Jetway in flight simulator what happens?
from point of view of FLight Simulator we'll see what it has to do .to give results.
TOO many 3D objects . some are joined , some placed side by side , some are intersecting the other ,some overlapping , and they all have their own textures i.e door handle is steel, one pnel of door is translucent ,some part of panel is transparent ,( and if shadows are activated via setting) the as a complete model .....how does the physiography(study of shadow behaviour ) needs to be taken care . how does the physio fall , is it falling on some oother 3d objects or on the ground ,then scio also falls on a part ..portion of which is translucent... then the value of translucency /.....after passing the transclucent potion or object , shadow intensity is changed(increased).so that intensity needs to be worked .. to objects (complex 3d are say intersecting , and after intersection (collective)shape obtained then the further final physciography of the collective object .so oooooooooooooooo
many tedious woork required for the processor.....,..
what about simulation then //...:eek:
siimple thing is .........flight simulator has to work more with complex 3d objects and use its basic guidelines collectively work out the entire 3d objects.
but
for processor/flight simuator it is easy to work-out with basic simple shape and their individual characteristics including shadow
it knows very well and can easily process a simple box with simple or should i say simple shadow from the box.
the processor can do that very fast ///so concluding POLYGONS DEFINES SUCCESS.
it wants simple plain things so we do that
YOu want to make complicated door i tell what to do.
make a handle of steel and create a bgl file along with mdl file .
so their is translucent panel also so make a translucent panel and create bgl and mdl.
and similarly all variations of various objects individually
were is the 3d door ? patience my friend patience.
now since you are using.......say..........ez scenery...........then make a library
file i.e bgl using ez library manager . say 'DOOR is name of final Library BGLthat has these individual objects .
while makeing a library it will ask for mdl file, and you d have a bgl and mdl file for individual objects.so now door is the bgl that has components .
start flight simulator run ez scenery and construct a door while inside simulator. ON SITE using the said components ..i.e compose your door .....this is were pateince is tested
and when you restart your flight simulator .click "FLY now" RESU:LTS?
i gaurantee-= BIG WIDE OPEN MOUTH....you'd say "i m surely dreaming"
" no sir it ain't no dream,its right in front of you .VIRTUAL DOOR/JETWAY and frames? thats what result into " BIG WIDE OPEN MOUTH"

since the door was cn completed outside and placed at a location it is a headache for simulator. --level difference .intersections, overlap . trunslucent ,setbacks.protuding objeccts,material difference in one 3d object soooo
many things and flight simulator will treat it as oone complex object withlots of variations.
BUT BUT AND THE BIG BUT..
you composed the door while inside simulator and when you Assisgned its position/location it is a simple basic shape at a particular location (square/rectangle/cylinder/ etc )
and simulator knows how simple it is to deal with basic primary object.
it WILL NEVER WORK IT AS A COLLECTION (COMPLEX 3D)and deal with it as individual object which is damn easy to work,...SIMPLE OBJECT...SIMPLE PHYSIOGREAPHY ...SIngle MATERIAL ,SINGLE CHARACTERISTICS easy job for it does not require to work out intersection,overlaps,etc.

Please ignore any grammatical and spelling mistakes , instead use your brains
have an interesting day
Chao,
Ashish
 
Wow that's a big reply...thanks for getting into the trouble of explaining your designing strategy, I m sure many will find it useful.

However with my question I was hoping that you would provide some relevant help/advice to everyone in this forum/thread into how would you go about creating a small field of grass for FSX using gMax.
 
Wow that's a big reply...thanks for getting into the trouble of explaining your designing strategy, I m sure many will find it useful.

However with my question I was hoping that you would provide some relevant help/advice to everyone in this forum/thread into how would you go about creating a small field of grass for FSX using gMax.

Actually, I was wondering the same thing myself... ;)
 
Right ... well, now ... about the 3D volumetric grass.

"Flight of Ideas" simulator.
 
well...going back to the discussion..just now finished finished reading the above post...:D

Does anybody have a smart way of creating low poly 3D grass other than the 'classic' one?

Thanks
 
Last edited:
I made some using the above mentioned tutorial. Its not great but its not bad either. Not sure if this is what u meant?

3dgrass1.jpg



It might not look spectacular but its better than flat grass and its LOW POLY.

Tutorial is here: http://www.webdesign.org/3d-graphics/tutorials/low-poly-grass-and-hair.543.html

I believe you can make awesome grass in 3DS but I dont have it so i cannot confirm. There are several methods to achieve this in 3DS. Such as Vray or Hair Tool
http://www.cgdigest.com/how-to-create-grass-in-3ds-max/
http://www.evermotion.org/tutorials/show/7946/grass-with-3ds-max-and-v-ray-for-flat-grounds
http://3dm1.blogspot.com/2007/04/grass-tutorial.html
http://www.cgshelf.com/grass_tutorial.php

Did anybody understand Ashish? I really wanted to because it seemed useful. If anybody understood....please gimme in plain english. Im a bit thick.
 
Last edited:
Did anybody understand Ashish? I really wanted to because it seemed useful. If anybody understood....please gimme in plain english. Im a bit thick.

Although the individual words are "plain english," the thoughts conveyed are not cogent at all.

In fact, I'm unsure just what the point was, since the entire reply is apparently unrelated to the focus of the topic! :rotfl:
 
Although the individual words are "plain english," the thoughts conveyed are not cogent at all.

In fact, I'm unsure just what the point was, since the entire reply is apparently unrelated to the focus of the topic! :rotfl:

What a relief to hear you say that Bill!!

I was starting to think I was the only one not finding a relationship between the OP and the answer given.:confused:

Regards, Mike Mann
 
OK....now how about a very simple way of doing grass???, funny such a common thing in nature and so complicated for us all...nature is a wonderful and mysterious thing...:confused:....any simple way??, have you seen how ORBX shows clumps of it in such a great way??:eek::eek:...Ashish thanks for your thoughts on the subject, beautiful pics alright.
 
Last edited:
ORBX grass is composed of models. Basically the same concept that applies to trees. They have now taken it one step further by making the planes animated with skin and bones. Easily accomplished. I proved this to myself by creating swaying trees and grass. You can also add little animated planes with leaf textures which will give you falling leaves from the trees. There is no real simple way of creating grass unless its flat.
 
ORBX grass is composed of models. Basically the same concept that applies to trees. They have now taken it one step further by making the planes animated with skin and bones. Easily accomplished. I proved this to myself by creating swaying trees and grass. You can also add little animated planes with leaf textures which will give you falling leaves from the trees. There is no real simple way of creating grass unless its flat.

Indeed, does seem that good grass=many polys...BTW, have tried the skin/bone animation on a few textured planes, but saw a rather strong FPS effect, was it only me or did you also notice something similar?
 
Last edited:
Yes any time you implement skin and bone you will get a frame hit, but it shouldnt be huge....I suspect something the matter. On my current project which is the R66 helicopter, I have alot of skin and bone animations and I still get the set frame rate.
 
Anyone understand what Ashish explain? Is that about texture baking or somthing.
Please tell us if you do understand how to make 3d grass.
 
Anyone understand what Ashish explain? Is that about texture baking or somthing.
Please tell us if you do understand how to make 3d grass.

What he explains is completely off topic and irrelivant...probably the most annoying thread on here.

Just ignore it all, he does not want to tell us anything about grass when we ask him how we can make realistic looking grass... He will just write a massive reply blabbing on about doors on jetways.
 
Back
Top